Alcoa's Share Price May Fall To $5 In November-December Timeframe

Nov.12.12 | About: Alcoa, Inc. (AA)

We have been regularly reporting on the share price model for Alcoa (NYSE: AA) since April 2011. Here we revisit and update the AA model using new data, including the monthly closing price in October 2012 and the estimated CPI components for September 2012. The principal result is that the model has the same defining CPI components and time lags with slightly changing coefficients. Therefore, the model is a reliable tool to predict the evolution of Alcoa shares. The new observations validate our previous predictions. Essentially, the model is stable during the past 18 months and forecasts the AA price over the two-month horizon (the consumer price index, CPI, data lag by approximately 20 days behind the monthly closing price of the share). It shows the fall in the price down to $5 in November-December 2012. If the prediction is right one should not consider buying AFL stock right now. We will revisit the AA stock price model in a month in order to assess the direction of further moves - will the level of $5 be stable?

Alcoa is a company in the Materials subcategory of the S&P 500 list, specialized in aluminum. Our concept is intuitive and straightforward. A company is what it produces. There are price setters and price takers. Some goods and services drive economic development and some follow up. Let's imagine a company producing some goods (services) very attractive to people right now. The company may raise the overall price for its goods (services). Accordingly, stocks go up, likely with some time lag. One of the indicators of the overall price is the consumer price index (CPI) for these specific goods and services or some very intimately related G&S. Then it is not excluded that the company's share depends on this CPI in a statistically reliable way and one can obtain a good link between the price and this CPI. Since the headline CPI evolves under the pressure of a big set of goods and services, one needs to find some dynamics reference (another CPI) which would be most independent on the CPI related to the company. Hence, we have to find two CPIs which describe the evolution of the price the best (in the LSQ sense). When both CPIs lead the price, a deterministic model can be obtained and we are looking for such companies in the S&P 500 list. Alcoa is one of the companies with a deterministic model - both defining CPIs lead by three months at least.

According to our general approach to share price modeling, we decompose the observed time history of the monthly closing AA stock price (adjusted for splits and dividends) into a weighted sum of two CPI components, time trend and free term. Two defining CPI components are selected to minimize the model (RMS) error and may lead or lag behind the share.

The original and current AA model is defined by the (not seasonally adjusted) index of food away from home (SEFV) and the price index of rent of primary residence (RPR), as reported by the US BLS. The former CPI component leads the share price by 3 months and the latter is 5 months ahead of the share price. Figure 1 depicts the overall evolution of both involved indices through September 2012. It seems these indices have been evolving in sync since 2002 with the only step-like change in the SEFV index in 2008. We present five empirical models as estimated in April, October and December 2011 as well as in February and September 2012:

AA(t) = -6.71SEFV(t-2) + 3.34RPR(t-4) + 19.23(t-1990) + 298.87, Aril 2011

AA(t) = -6.61SEFV(t-2) + 3.22RPR(t-4) + 19.51(t-1990) + 300.89, October 2011

AA(t) = -6.47SEFV(t-3) + 3.08RPR(t-5) + 19.58(t-1990) + 302.45, December 2011

AA(t) = -6.38SEFV(t-3) + 3.01RPR(t-5) + 19.53(t-1990) + 301.93 , February 2012

AA(t) = -6.29SEFV(t-3) + 2.97RPR(t-5) + 19.26(t-2000) + 491.86, September 2012

where AA(t) is a share price in US dollars, t is calendar time. Figure 2 illustrates the observed and predicted models for December 2011. The residual error in Figure 3 is $2.91 ($3.05 in December, $3.04 in October, $3.12 in April, and $3.05 in February 2012) for the period between July 2003 and September 2012. Figure 2 also shows monthly high and low prices as the uncertainty in the monthly closing price as the best share price estimate. Since the closing price has to characterize the whole month by one value the high and low prices might serve as strict statistical bounds.

Click to enlarge

Figure 1. Evolution of the price of SEVF and RPR.

Click to enlarge

Figure 2. Observed and predicted AA share prices.

Figure 3. The model error; sterr=$2.91 between June 2003 and September 2012.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.