Seeking Alpha

Greg Feirman

About this author:

The time of maximum pessimism is the best time to buy.
- Legendary Investor John Templeton

On Wednesday, Merrill Lynch (MER) released its monthly survey of fund managers for October.  The survey covered 172 fund managers with $531 billion under management.  Merrill called the survey “one of the most pessimistic” ever.

Here are some highlights:

  • The number of managers believing the global economy is in recession jumped to 69% - from 44% in September.
  • Sixty percent of managers believe the global economy will weaken over the next 12 months - up from 37% in September.
  • The number of managers overweight cash increased to 49% - up from 36% in September.
  • Forty-three percent of managers think global equity markets are undervalued - up from 15% in September.  The October number is a 10 year high.

According to Merrill Lynch, three factors are coming together that tend to be associated with market rallies: low risk appetite, high cash positions and a belief that stocks are undervalued (“Is Pessimism Good News?” (subscription required), Brett Arends, The Wall Street Journal Online, October 15).

Along the same lines, on Tuesday, The Wall Street Journal reported that three high profile hedge fund managers (Steve Cohen, Israel Englander, John Paulson) have moved a lot of money into cash: “‘Smart Money’ Stays on the Sides: Hedge Fund Chiefs Like Cohen, Paulson, Move to Cash to Ride Out Storm” (subscription required).  According to the article, Cohen sold about half his stock holdings last week, closing out the positions of 50 managers who work for him.

If ever there was a moment of maximum pessimism in the stock market, this is it.

Print this article with comments

This article has 16 comments:

  •  
    Only 69% believed global recession, looks like optimistic to me.
    2008 Oct 17 07:50 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    agree with user143167

    people are optimistic -in the current situation - a must read cut and paste into your browser

    seekingalpha.com/artic...

    2008 Oct 17 09:24 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I'd say this is a good time to get our personal spending under control. It will cause some pain in the Economy - but we need to learn the lesson of "spending within our means". Greed, Excess and Speculation are the route cause of this mess.
    2008 Oct 17 09:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A moment of maximum pessimism in the stock market will be the day there are no "the end is near" articles in SA like this.
    2008 Oct 17 09:30 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    We're not even close. When we're in max pessimism, you won't want to ask about stock market.

    As far as housing itself though, we're close.... After 2009's alt-A collapse (and potential subsequent flying of interest rates), we may be at a time that the world "House Purchase" would sound to society like someone committing financial suicide. When people try to persuade friends out of buying houses as if they're persuading an alcoholic to not drink, *THAT* is when we reached the bottom in housing.
    2008 Oct 17 10:09 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Why be pessimistic at all? The Fed will buy up the stock market if necessary with "monopoly" money. I guess the problem then will be to stay ahead of the hyperinflation that will result.

    Face it investors, you are being subsidized by Joe-Sixpack. Proud of yourselves?
    2008 Oct 17 10:23 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Hate to be the one to say " that this time it's different ", but the problem is the blackboxes gone wild, looking at trillions of $ in lossess.
    2008 Oct 17 10:34 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This may be a once-in-a-lifetime event with some of the largest banks failing, the end of the Wall Street investment banking model, and everyone in panic. However, I believe the government has stepped in before a complete economic implosion could happen.

    Although our economy may be broken, I believe the fear factor can only go down from last week. We will recover from this, and it's a good time to buy. We may experience a flat stock market for the next year or so, but we will come back strong.

    I talk about Warren Buffett's take on the current situation in www.investorpitstop.co...
    2008 Oct 17 10:44 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The bottom will be near when 'stock' is a dirty word no decent person would dare utter.
    2008 Oct 17 10:44 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The question I've asked myself is do I want to own stocks or have cash sitting in a savings account in a period of huge inflation.

    Our government is inflating us out of our situation and the upcoming dollar devaluation is worrisome.
    2008 Oct 17 11:30 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    moonbat1775 - Joe sixpack robs the financial sector of $480 billion in taxes every year and spends them on his middle class entitlement boondoggles. Pretending finance is a net drag on the rest is ridiculous, it has added a third of all value presently in existence.
    2008 Oct 17 11:41 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "Joe sixpack robs the financial sector of $480 billion in taxes every year and spends them on his middle class entitlement boondoggles." JasonC,

    Glad you mentioned that. What came first, the Great Depression or huge social spending programs?

    Fractional reserve banking, particularly when it is backed up by the government is a cheat. Not only that, it is unstable. Not only that, it produces mal-investments. Not only that, it causes and finances wars.

    Who would guess that a banking system built on fraud and theft via inflation would cause such misery? Ludvig von Mises for one. He and F.A. Hayek predicted the Great Depression.
    2008 Oct 17 11:52 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Don't worry, Obama will make everything all better.

    For somebody.
    2008 Oct 17 12:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I'm not sure but I think Obama said the guys name is Joe The Plumber.
    2008 Oct 17 07:48 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    How can you possibly know and why would you trust anything that Merrill Lynch has to say on any subject? They were just a day or two away from bankruptcy before being rescued. Clearly they didn't see any of this coming before it was way too late.
    2008 Oct 18 09:20 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Joe the plumber is an unliscensed plumber within a 2 person business and who owes backtaxes to the government. This person would actually come out far,far,far better under Sen.Obama's plan than from under Sen. McCain's plan. McCain useing it in the debate only shows how ignorant and desperate he is OR he is deliberately continueing to mislead the sleeping american public. McCain does not make good decisions and when he shoots from the hip can even be considered dangerous. We need good sound intelligent reasoning ability in the white house to get us thru the coming economic hard times that will son be upon us! Good Luck to you all!
    2008 Oct 18 09:24 AM | Link | Reply