By James Brumley
They say timing is everything, particularly when it comes to stock investment. I don't disagree. That's why I recommended caution with most of the major super-discount retail stocks back in April -- it just wasn't the right time to take on a new position in any of those stocks.
A lot can change in eight months, though.
And it has, at least for one of these discount retailers. Thanks to some more encouraging clarity on the earnings front, combined with a big release of the technical tension its chart had brewed up, this stock is now a compelling buy.
Insanely Overvalued In The Recent Past
It's no real secret that dollar stores such as Family Dollar (NYSE:FDO), Dollar Tree (NASDAQ:DLTR), and Dollar General (NYSE:DG) have been on a roll since the Great Recession. Consumers are still feeling pinched and in need of real value for their dollars. Retailers that can give shoppers the most bang for their buck stand to win plenty of new business, and these three stores have sure done so.
This isn't just a theoretical benefit, either. As I reported in April, since 2008, Family Dollar has managed to grow its bottom line at an average annual pace of 23%. Dollar Tree's income has grown an average of 31% annually since 2008. Dollar General's bottom line growth has reached triple-digit proportions during the past three years, and even though it started to slow last fiscal year, that's largely because it was running out of viable places to plant its flag.
Take a look at the chart below:
That growth is nothing less than phenomenal and investors were right to be impressed. Investors weren't right, however, to pay an excessive price for that growth -- even heavyweight investors like Warren Buffett, who took on a $48 million stake in Dollar General shortly before my April article.
At that time, Dollar Tree shares were sitting on top of a three-year rally that sent the stock soaring 300%. Family Dollar had rallied nearly 200% during the prior four years, while Dollar General shares had doubled in value since late 2009.
The size of the rallies themselves weren't the problem with these stocks, however. The red flag was simply that these rallies had been a lot stronger than earnings growth, leaving all three stocks at price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios high enough to make even some technology and growth investors a little nervous. Dollar General was trading at 19.5 times trailing earnings in April, while Family Dollar and Dollar Tree were trading at 18.6 and 23.5, respectively.
Yes, many stocks have survived worse overvaluations, but those stocks weren't from the world of discount retailing, either. That's why I specifically made the point that "the right time and price for an entry is probably going to require about a 25% correction from peak levels."
And guess what finally happened since then?
A Nice Entry Point To Claim Your Stake
In the interest of fairness, though my suggestion was on target, my timing was off -- the group's peak and subsequent pullback didn't start until June. But, it did happen -- in spades. Dollar General fell 18% between its high and low during the middle of the year, while Family Dollar shares gave up a little more than 17% of their value between June and September. These moves certainly burned off a great deal of any overbought pressure, but they haven't burned enough off to merit an entry into either stock yet.
Dollar Tree, however, has completely cleared its decks with a whopping 33% pullback that didn't end until earlier this month. With all the would-be sellers likely shaken out already, this stock's chart has an enormous amount of room to continue this rally.
That being said, this isn't a purely-technical investment idea. Although Dollar Tree shares have more room than Family Dollar or Dollar General have before resistance kicks in, the stock is supported by a solid fundamental argument, too. It's the cheapest of the three stocks in question on a trailing P/E basis, and after 15 earnings beats in a row, that projected P/E ratio of 14.6 may well underestimate the company.
Risks to consider: Ironically, the one thing that could trip up any of these three stocks is a firm rebound in the economy. If spending preferences return to higher-priced goods, then these retailers won't exactly offer what the average consumer wants these days. Also, bear in mind that none of these stocks will be able to grow in the future as rapidly as they have during the past three years.
While the deep-discount space continues to be rewarding for all of its key companies, make no mistake -- Dollar Tree is the stock to step into if you're looking to stake a claim now. A 20% gain from current prices could be realized in the very foreseeable future. But, given 2011's romp, a 40% reward could be in the works for investors willing to stick with it for a full year or so.
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.