Stock Market: Is the Rally 'Real?'

What a wild day on the stock markets! At one stage, the Dow Jones Industrial Average plunged to below 8,000 to a five-year intraday low, but staged a spectacular rally late in the session to close 553 points (6.6%) up on the day. The S&P 500 Index moved in tandem to finish the day 59 points (6.9%) higher.

I referred to the characteristics of the so-called descending triangle on the S&P 500 in a post of two days ago (“Stock Markets: Which Way José?”), mentioning that a reversal to the upside often leads to a strong countertrend rally. A move in that direction occurred yesterday on the highest volume in a month. Although one shouldn’t get too fired up about a one-day turnaround, the price and volume action was quite impressive, with the October 27 lows (8,176 on the Dow and 849 on the S&P 500) still intact.

The following daily graph summarizes the market action:

Importantly, the intraday lows of October 10, when the NYSE (red line in the graph below) made an “internal low” with 92.7% of stocks hitting new lows (blue area), have also not yet been violated.

A further positive for the bulls is that, according to Jeffrey Hirsch (Stock Trader’s Almanac), the Dow has been up 12, out of the last 14 years during the week before Thanksgiving.

With the likelihood of further short-term gains a possibility (especially if the major indices record upside reversals on the weekly data by the end of today), it remains too early to tell whether a secular low has been recorded. The chart below shows the long-term trend of the S&P 500 Index (green line) together with a simple 12-month rate of change (or momentum) indicator (blue line). Although monthly indicators are of little help when it comes to market timing, they do come in handy for defining the primary trend. An ROC line below zero depicts bear trends as experienced in 1991, 1994, 2000 to 2003, and again since December 2007.

Stock markets are caught between the actions of central banks, governments and the IMF frantically fending off a total economic meltdown on the one hand, and a worsening economic and corporate picture on the other. This situation has a “no-man’s-land” feel to it. By all means, try to play a possible nascent rally, but be cognizant that, failing further technical and fundamental evidence, you are trading against the primary trend. Caution is still warranted!

Comments

[jeandit:]

Prieur du Plessis, are you the guy behind the StockMarketTiming service?

2008 Nov 14 07:31 AM

[Schweizer:]

Hank and Ben were the only buyers yesterday.

2008 Nov 14 09:19 AM

[win:]

Simple, straightforward and cogent. Thank you.

2008 Nov 14 09:55 AM

[John Lounsbury:]

Thanks for the excellent data and discussion. I have (in another comment) indicated that after DJIA support in the 7100-7300 area based on the 10/9/2002 (7286.77) and 10/27/1997 (7161.55) lows, the next support level would be at 2365 (10/11/1990 low). Looking at your S&P 500 chart, it is clear that there is intermediate support at 1994 levels, even though there are no secondary market bottoms during that time (for the DJIA).

Using your data, I must acknowledge support in the 3600 to 3800 region for the Dow, the 1994 trading range.

2008 Nov 14 12:21 PM