TIPS ETFs Fight Inflation... But Not The Kind You Expect

|
 |  Includes: IPE, SCHP, STIP, STPZ, TDTF, TDTT, TIP
by: Morningstar

By Abby Woodham

With a name like Treasury Inflation-Protected Security, perennially favored TIPS certainly seem like a natural choice for an inflation hedge. Unfortunately, TIPS funds don’t do that particular job as well as many might expect. An inflation hedge is an investment that co-moves with inflation and preserves purchasing power, but the TIPS indexes tracked by the largest exchange-traded funds have historically exhibited only a small positive level of correlation to inflation--far from a perfect inflation hedge in the traditional sense.

Despite their low correlation to inflation, TIPS funds remain wildly popular: About $27 billion is invested in the 10 TIPS ETFs currently on offer. These funds may not be a perfect inflation hedge, but they are a great option for the investor who thinks the market is underestimating future inflation--in other words, for hedging against unexpected inflation.

TIPS can be considered the closest thing to a truly risk-free asset, as they combine the security of Treasuries with inflation protection in the form of Consumer Price Index-adjusted principal. The CPI represents the amount that an urban consumer would need to spend to purchase a certain basket of goods and services. Inflation will drive the price of that basket higher and deflation will make it cheaper, which is reflected in increases/declines in the CPI. When the CPI goes up, TIPS’ principal is adjusted upward accordingly. Even though the interest rate on the bond remains the same, the semiannual coupon is paid based on the adjusted principal. Through this process, a TIPS’ principal and interest payments are protected against inflation as measured by the CPI.

Today’s risk-off attitude means that investors have willingly snapped up TIPS and related funds, despite negative real yields on new shorter-maturity TIPS issues caused by a nominal rate lower than the expected future rate of inflation. Buying a TIPS at issuance and holding it until maturity is a guaranteed way to protect that lump of cash from inflation (as determined by the CPI) until a later date. Many investors buy a laddered portfolio of individual TIPS to immunize future cash flow, which is a straightforward and generally successful way to preserve purchasing power between two points in time. However, TIPS funds behave differently.

Like any bond, TIPS pricing is mainly driven by changes in the real interest rate. When real interest rates rise, TIPS fall, and vice versa. Therein lies the rub. Changes in the nominal rate can and do move TIPS pricing, even during periods of unchanging inflation. An investor buying a single bond and holding it until maturity is less likely to be concerned with these price fluctuations. However, investors in TIPS ETFs who are using these funds for more-tactical purposes are likely to take notice. Most TIPS indexes have high durations, so changes to the nominal rate have a large impact on the prices of the underlying bonds. The impact of changes in inflation expectations can be swamped by gyrations in underlying rates, which goes a long way toward explaining why broad TIPS funds exhibit such low levels of correlation with inflation. That said, shorter-duration TIPS indexes are somewhat more correlated to inflation, given their lesser degree of interest-rate sensitivity.

Understanding the difference between expected and unexpected inflation is central to understanding TIPS and forming an investment thesis. Ask yourself: Do you think future inflation will outpace the market's current expectations? An easy way to calculate the market's current expectation for future inflation is to look at the break-even inflation rate, which is the difference in the yields of TIPS and Treasury bonds of the same maturity. If inflation ends up coming in higher on average than the break-even rate, the TIPS investor is better off. The easy part is calculating the market’s implied expectations for future inflation; it is much harder to come up with an accurate prediction of future inflation and invest accordingly.

Today's inflation rate is well below the historic average, despite the massive monetary stimulus that has been applied by the Fed. This expansionary monetary policy has been enacted to encourage spending, but it also has the potential to eventually erode purchasing power. Quantitative easing's future impact on inflation may be greater than the market expects, and if it is, TIPS will beat Treasuries.

For some historical perspective, the 10-year break-even rate of inflation was as low as 0.04% in 2009 and has averaged about 2% over the past decade. When the break-even rate is below average, it suggests that TIPS may be relatively cheap versus the Treasury with a corresponding maturity. Right now, the 10-year break-even rate of about 2.5% is above the trailing 10-year average, which has led many to caution that TIPS are overpriced. However, the long-term average inflation rate has been closer to 3%. If you think inflation will ultimately exceed current expectations, TIPS might still be priced attractively enough to offer inexpensive inflation protection. For such investors, the menu of TIPS ETFs may offer some useful tools.

Introducing Your ETF Tool Kit
Investors have never enjoyed more ETF options for buying TIPS than they do today. Topping the list is iShares Barclays TIPS Bond (NYSEARCA:TIP), which is by far the biggest TIPS-focused ETF on the market with just south of $23 billion in assets under management. This fund buys all TIPS with at least one year left until maturity and $250 million par value. TIP is cap-weighted, meaning that at present intermediate maturity bonds make up about 70% of the index, while long-term issues account for the rest. If you anticipate higher-than-expected inflation across the curve, funds like this are the right choice. Because of its size and trading volume, TIP has all the liquidity one could want. Other solid picks are SPDR Barclays Capital TIPS (NYSEARCA:IPE), which has a portfolio with an average duration of 8.67 versus TIP’s 8.2, and Schwab U.S. TIPS ETF (NYSEARCA:SCHP), which is the cheapest option by far with an expense ratio of 0.07% after its September fee cut.

As discussed, the price of TIPS will react to changes in the risk-free cost of capital just like Treasuries. With real durations of more than eight years, this group of funds is most certainly exposed to interest-rate risk. Investors worried about rising rates could consider settling into the short end of the curve. Not only are shorter-duration TIPS funds less exposed to interest-rate risk, but they also have a somewhat higher correlation to inflation than their longer-dated brethren as explained above. Among this group, we like PIMCO 1-5 Year US TIPS Index ETF (NYSEARCA:STPZ), which buys all TIPS issuance with 1-5 years remaining until maturity and a face value of at least $1 billion. The other option is iShares Barclays 0-5 Year TIPS Bond (NYSEARCA:STIP), which is far smaller and much less liquid (as measured by average trading volume) than STPZ.

If you're fitting TIPS into a pre-existing fixed-income portfolio and want to take a more targeted approach to managing the allocation’s duration, there are two relatively new TIPS products that fit the bill quite well: FlexShares iBoxx 3-Year Target Duration TIPS ETF (NYSEARCA:TDTT) and FlexShares iBoxx 5-Year Target Duration TIPS ETF (NYSEARCA:TDTF). Real duration, a commonly used metric for TIPS funds, only measures a portfolio’s exposure to changes in the real interest rate. Modified adjusted duration measures the portfolio's sensitivity to changes in interest rates and inflation expectations, and it can be much more volatile. These funds attempt to keep modified adjusted duration stable at three years or five years. TDTT and TDTF have been incredibly popular in the past year, enjoying almost a billion dollars of net inflows between the two.

Disclosure: Morningstar, Inc. licenses its indexes to institutions for a variety of reasons, including the creation of investment products and the benchmarking of existing products. When licensing indexes for the creation or benchmarking of investment products, Morningstar receives fees that are mainly based on fund assets under management. As of Sept. 30, 2012, AlphaPro Management, BlackRock Asset Management, First Asset, First Trust, Invesco, Merrill Lynch, Northern Trust, Nuveen, and Van Eck license one or more Morningstar indexes for this purpose. These investment products are not sponsored, issued, marketed, or sold by Morningstar. Morningstar does not make any representation regarding the advisability of investing in any investment product based on or benchmarked against a Morningstar index.