Another Downgrade For Skullcandy And Another Oversized Response

| About: Skullcandy (SKUL)

A little over a week ago, I wrote optimistically that Skullcandy (NASDAQ:SKUL) could make 2013 a comeback year. Those hopes were dashed right at the gate of the New Year as Jeffries downgraded SKUL from Buy to Underperform with a $6 price target. As the general market was enjoying a tremendous rally, SKUL spent the day selling off to fresh all-time lows. The stock closed the day with a 12.7% loss. Perhaps only the closing bell saved SKUL from hitting the price target on the day as well.

Click to enlarge

Jeffries slams Skullcandy


Streetinsider quoted Jeffries as blaming competition for the downgrade:

Jefferies downgraded Skullcandy from Buy to Underperform and slashes its price target from $17 to $6 citing a lack of pricing power and increasing competition.

'The in-ear headphones which comprise over 60% of SKUL's revenues are under significant pressure from a variety of competitors, and we believe this trend will likely continue in coming quarters…And though SKUL is diversifying into more on-ear and over-ear headphones, these growth categories inherently carry lower margins.'

This assessment is readily discernible from the last earnings conference call, and I cited most of it in my last piece on SKUL. While I expressed optimism, Jeffries clearly thinks the opposite. Unfortunately for SKUL investors, the market has shown a keen interest in analyst action on SKUL and has moved with lightning speed in response. While I recommended trading the Morgan Stanley downgrade back in September by buying the stock for a bounce, I am not recommending the same here.

Morgan Stanley placed a $15 price target on SKUL at the time, and the stock sank FROM $15 to $14. This time, the stock remains above this latest price target. If you do not already own shares in SKUL, it could be worth a flier to start scaling in here, otherwise, it makes sense to just wait out this latest analyst-driven pounding.

The next potential catalyst for SKUL is that more shorts might start to cover once/if the stock closes in on $6/share. Short interest has dropped about 50% over the past 4 months or so, but it remains about 40% of the entire float. At some point, the risk/reward for continuing to hold these massive short positions gets poor enough where more substantial short-covering will commence. The $6 price target from Jeffries provides one likely milestone for this event.

Be careful out there!

Disclosure: I am long SKUL. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.