Seeking Alpha
Gary Tanashian, Biiwii (13 clicks)
Newsletter provider, long/short equity, macro, gold
Profile| Send Message| ()  

The following is an excerpt from the NFTRH 220, published on January 6:

Sentiment (Data courtesy of Sentimentrader.com)

(click to enlarge)

Well, what do you know? Most U.S. stock sectors are becoming unhealthy from a sentiment perspective (above), as the commercial hedgers have gone quite bearish (below). Here is the graph from NFTRH 218:

(click to enlarge)

…and a short-term sentiment timing graphic:

Sentiment Bottom Line

Note that Jason's comments are in contrast to the current NFTRH view that markets could remain strong into spring and then go bearish. A valid question is how long can markets continue higher while being sponsored by dumb, performance-chasing money? The answer is often "longer than you might expect". But we should respect the idea that U.S. markets are in a poor risk vs. reward stance now.

Referring back to the top graphic on page 21, there seems to be one lonely sector - one red headed stepchild - that is out of sorts with the whole process of a degrading risk vs. reward setup. While it is painful in the short-term, it is certainly a positive with respect to the fact that there are phases when the precious metals go contrary to the broad markets.

Hulbert's latest data available to Sentimetrader shows a -6.3% for gold newsletter writers. Anecdotally, a friend advises that Lance Lewis has stated that Hulbert's HGNSI was actually down to -12.5% on January 3. The Sentimentrader data is delayed. This would mean that gold newsletter sentiment is as bad as it was during the summer when prices were 100 bucks lower. That is a bullish divergence, contrarian-wise.

(click to enlarge)

The bottom line is that the sentiment data backs up NFTRH's stance of a bullish risk vs. reward on the precious metals (again, this does not mean lower prices cannot come about in the short-term), a bearish risk vs. reward on the broad markets and for sure a bullish risk vs. reward view of the precious metals in relation to the broad markets.

Wrap Up

Please remember that a perma precious metals bull did not write that last paragraph above. Yes, the PM's are in a secular bull market and I am big picture bullish. But when the shorter-term risk is high in the precious metals, the NFTRH has consistently noted it. When risk vs. reward is good in the broad markets, we note it. If at any point it looks like I may be serving up dogma, please contact me and let me know about it.

I try very hard to keep personal views as a rational monetary system and market watcher subordinated to what I see actually happening in the markets on a week-to-week, month-to-month basis. But I have eyes, and as such I see inflation being promoted once again. The work done to date pretty much comes down to the Adjusted Money Supply as being the final leg to be kicked out from under the table that holds Ben Bernanke's carefully arranged place settings. Rising money supply would bring on the next inflationary phase and most probably the next leg up in the precious metals bull.

But there is another scenario that most gold and commodity promoters will not mention. What if rising Treasury yields stop the economy dead in its tracks and actually trigger a real deflation, as money simply seizes up and stops moving? What if the money supply does not rise? What if, just maybe the weakness in the precious metals is a forecast to this condition?

This question is not meant to scare people because I expect the opposite. We are only 1 week into 2013 after all, with Operation Twist barely in the rear view mirror. But various indicators in today's report say it is important for the precious metals to begin to outperform other markets soon, in line with favorable sentiment and risk vs. reward profiles.

We will continue to manage the process in-week with interim updates.

Disclosure: No positions were mentioned in this article. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Additional disclosure:

Source: A Look At Sentiment