Seeking Alpha
About this author:

The big news yesterday was not the attempted sale of the Obama Senate seat. It was the extraordinary sale of T-bills at the U.S. Treasury Auction.

There were a huge number of bids (about three times what was finally sold) at zero interest. No interest at all. Some marginally older T-bills actually fell to a modest discount, so when they come up for being cashed out, the owner will get less than par. The holder paid the Treasury in order to lend it money short-term. (T-bills are sold discounted and you get the interest when you redeem.)

Why would anyone want to do this rather than simply keeping the cash under the mattress? Various technical factors were said to be involved, like window-dressing at the end of the year for some funds, or TARP recipients looking for a place to hide their money from potential borrowers.

This is a trend worth following up. There are other current market anomalies. The price of gold is in backwardation instead of contango, although it may not last. That means the price for future delivery is lower than that for current delivery. There is talk of huge tankers and tanks full of crude oil being stored (which costs money) to keep the oil off the market. This is another kind of backwardation, since when the oil is finally released it will have cost more than the spot price it will command, all other things being equal.

Back during the Great Depression, John Maynard Keynes wrestled with the need to find a tactic to regenerate what he called 'animal spirits' among the Depression-depressed of the period. Animal spirits lead people to spend or invest rather than saving their money with no chance of even earning interest.

Here is what I think we should do based on ideas Maynard Keynes suggested. Every banknote should have an expiration date. If not used by the use-by it has to be turned over to the U.S. Treasury for a new banknote worth less money, discounted by a few percentage points. This is the currency equivalent of the T-bill auction this week, formalizing backwardation.

It might work a lot better than throwing money at the banks. The Japanese spent hugely trying to get out of a 10-year deflation. It did not work.

Now I do not want my scheme to become another variant on TARP or the auto-industry bailout-to-come, feeding into over-safe placement of the money. I want these banknotes to go to people who in any event will want to spend them: homeowners in arrears; the unemployed; those owing student loans; filers for credit card bankruptcy. If the money is not spent or used to repay debt, it will lose value, we will be telling the recipients.

Print this article with comments

This article has 9 comments:

  •  
    You make some very astute observations.
    Whichever way one tries to solve the global deflation problem it is going to be very painful, and I think it is dangerous to believe that Keynesian economics can provide the solutions required.

    The real problem is that too many households/companies are buried under a pile of debt. Getting people to spend money when they are fearful and are facing a debt hangover is not just a matter of firing up the animal spirits. What needs to happen is that the debt has to be worked off. This can either take a long time (i.e. the lost decade in Japan) or it can happen more quickly if there are some innovative moves towards debt forgiveness.
    A mechanism needs to be established that allows mortgage holders and others mired in too much personal debt to consolidate and write down a portion of that debt without having to go through formal bankrupcty. Just like the auto companies people are reluctant to take on the stigma of a Chaper 11.

    Banks and other large companies are allowed to re-structure and swap debt for equity why not some similar and simple mechanism that allows individuals and small businesses to do the same? Essentially you could wipe a part of the slate clean and in return grant some kind of future claims against your future return to prosperity.

    That way one would mitigate a lot of flak from the prudent folks that have played by the rules since, if they do not seek any forgivenss, they would not have to supply some piece of their future action.

    Ultimately we need to re-establish affordability in the housing market where new buyers will be able to afford and qualify new mortgages without having to factor substantial capital gains into their expectations of the cost/returns.

    2008 Dec 11 08:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I think people realized that they couldn't get rich out of thin air. Now they look at their former dreams; cars that already look old, house in the middle of nowhere, that TV set that's no so hi-def and the pile of money they own on all of it and their melted retirement savings and they want to be quiet.
    2008 Dec 11 08:55 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "I think people realized that they couldn't get rich out of thin air. Now they look at their former dreams; cars that already look old, house in the middle of nowhere, that TV set that's no so hi-def and the pile of money they owe on all of it and their melted retirement savings and they want to be quiet."

    Bingo. One doesn't hear much chatter once reality sets in.
    2008 Dec 11 10:30 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Interesting observations on zero yield 3mo T-bill and prices of crude/gold. No explanation can satisfy me on the -0.05% 3mo rate 2 days ago...makes no sense at all.
    2008 Dec 11 10:50 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Many city and county governments will be forced under law to invest their idle cash in government securities. Most of the time there is a two year limit except for retirement funds, which can invest in long term government bonds. In my state, the yield for the state retirement fund must be 7.5% to be actuarily stable. Pension losses are already equal to the period after the 911 terorist attck. It is almost a thousand dollars for everyone in the state. Only this time there is not terrorist and there is no assurance that the drop will be short term.
    2008 Dec 11 11:49 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "Interesting observations on zero yield 3mo T-bill and prices of crude/gold. No explanation can satisfy me on the -0.05% 3mo rate 2 days ago...makes no sense at all. "

    This made no sense to me either until I heard a good explanation... as follows:

    If you have $10K you COULD and perhaps should just stuff it in a safe deposit box or a mattress. BUT if you have $10M or $10B to roll over as, for example, sovereign wealth funds and other "big" players have to do ... you can't really "stick it in the mattress"... you have to do something "digital" with it....

    Other that this ... I can offer no explanation either...
    2008 Dec 11 12:13 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    New Mexico invested in Reserve Primary Fund and got $1 billion froze.

    www.prosefights.org/nm...
    2008 Dec 11 12:17 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Ah, it's refreshing to see the muckymucks writhe in agony as they try desperately to get poor people to spend their few coins. Spending is dead. It will stay dead, except for absolute necessities, for quite a while. Meanwhile the muckymucks dance the dance of the thwarted. And if you don't understand this comment, you must be rich (for now.)
    2008 Dec 11 03:16 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Because investors know that the market is broken...rigged...mani... abetted by the SEC!
    2008 Dec 12 12:37 AM | Link | Reply