Seeking Alpha
About this author: By this author:
Submit
an article to

When reading about the $50 billion Madoff hedge fund fraud, it hit me on the head: hedge fund redemptions at the end of this year are going to be absolutely huge, and that will mean a massive sell-off in global capital markets in the first quarter.

That would also mean a further rally for the the US dollar, as assets sold are redeemed largely in US dollars and thus boost demand for the greenback. Gold might take a slight set back, although it will more likely be in increasing demand as a safe haven asset and diversification against the coming dollar crash.

Inflationary stimulus

All this turmoil would really put the pressure on the incoming US president and his team, who will respond with bigger than expected stimulus packages and bailouts. That will make the upcoming and inevitable inflation even larger when it hits, and at the first whiff of inflation the bond market will tank and with it the US dollar.

Investors face a double whammy in 2009 - from hedge fund withdrawals crashing the stock market and later a dollar collapse. That would take capital markets to a real bottom.

Market bottom

My prediction of the Dow at 4-5,000 and gold at $4-5,000 an ounce for later next year still stands, and hedge fund redemptions followed by a dollar collapse will be the driving forces to achieve that bottom. It might take until 2010 to get that far but no longer.

Now try to argue the reverse: will there be sellers or buyers in capital markets after year-end redemptions come in? What is the chance of a positive tally for redemptions? Zero chance! Is the dollar bond market at a top or about to go higher? Is it hell!

Actually this will offer a great point to buy up the finest US stocks at rock bottom prices, but who will have the cash to buy by then? Certainly not anybody taking an optimistic view of the market outlook now.

I can empathize with those who feel the Madoff fraud is some kind of a warning of things to come. These frauds do not usually happen in isolation and are a symptom of the underlying malaise.

Print this article
Comments
70
You are viewing the first 20 comments View all »
     
  • Given you are required to provide 45 days notice to YE for redemptions, all hedge funds are cashed up for this and that trade is done. They have known their Ye redemptions since Nov 15th so I beleive there already is a massive amount of cash on the sidelines (most hedge funds are between 50-90% cash.

    2008 Dec 22 07:57 AM Reply
  •  
  • i disagree w/ you, Savvy. yes, hedgies need notification for redemptions but there were an amazing amount of gates put up in q4 preventing withdrawls for q4 year end. at somepoint that money comes out. this mini bear rally is drawing to a close.
    2008 Dec 22 08:06 AM Reply
  •  
  • oh my god.
    That's truly a johnny-come-lately, if there ever was one.
    Are you aware that you usually cannot just ask for redemption of your hedge fund whenever you like or a Madoff hits? There are redemption periods and advanced notice requirements. which, btw. were the main drivers behind the huge selloffs in sep-november. most hedge funds have annual or quarterly redemption schedules with a 30-45 day advance notice. that means that anyone who wanted to redeem a hedgefund with annual redemption schedule per calender year would have to notify the fund by mid-November. If you didn't - then gl, you will have to wait for another year. similar with quarterly schedules.

    ther will be soem Madoff-effekt, no doubt. but the expectation voiuced in this silly article is nothing but a moronic guess that displays the author's lack of knowledge and perhaps his whishes. but certainly it adds TERO alpha to anyone's portfolio.

    what a complete joke
    2008 Dec 22 08:09 AM Reply
  •  
  • sorry for the typos. was in a big hurry to reply to an article that's essentially total crap.
    Lol


    On Dec 22 08:09 AM User 305589 wrote:

    > oh my god.
    > That's truly a johnny-come-lately, if there ever was one.
    > Are you aware that you usually cannot just ask for redemption of
    > your hedge fund whenever you like or a Madoff hits? There are redemption
    > periods and advanced notice requirements. which, btw. were the main
    > drivers behind the huge selloffs in sep-november. most hedge funds
    > have annual or quarterly redemption schedules with a 30-45 day advance
    > notice. that means that anyone who wanted to redeem a hedgefund with
    > annual redemption schedule per calender year would have to notify
    > the fund by mid-November. If you didn't - then gl, you will have
    > to wait for another year. similar with quarterly schedules.
    >
    > ther will be soem Madoff-effekt, no doubt. but the expectation voiuced
    > in this silly article is nothing but a moronic guess that displays
    > the author's lack of knowledge and perhaps his whishes. but certainly
    > it adds TERO alpha to anyone's portfolio.
    >
    > what a complete joke
    2008 Dec 22 08:12 AM Reply
  •  
  • Add to the hedge fund withdrawals the Obama Plan that will enable each 401K participant to withdraw $10,000 without penalty and a Dow at 5000 looks more and more plausible.
    2008 Dec 22 08:15 AM Reply
  •  
  • First, is this late or what? I mean, hedge funds have been having withdrawals for quite some time. If this article had come out in December, 2007 it would have been prescient. Now, it is merely flatulant.

    Secondly, for tax reasons if for nothing else, I would have already done my hedge fund withdrawal.

    thirdly, there are a lot of stocks that have extremely low pe ratios and pay good dividends. What is your alternative? 0% T-Bills? I think that selective stocks look pretty good in this environment.
    2008 Dec 22 08:29 AM Reply
  •  
  • There is quite a lot of negative criticism of this post here, but I am not too sure that all of it is justified. I do believe he did mention 1st quarter withdrawals. That does allow sufficient time for a 45 day notice. Certainly, there have already been plenty of hedge fund withdrawals, but the point here is that as bad as everything is, the Madoff affair might very well make a few people wonder whether their money is safe anywhere other than under their matress. It makes me wonder that. I believe I read that Madoff is going to bankrupt the SIPC fund. Sort of makes one wonder whether one should remove ones funds from every brokerage account out there.
    2008 Dec 22 08:48 AM Reply
  •  
  • i think this is a good point - continued (increased?) fear leading to even further redemptions later in the 1st quarter

    not guaranteed that will happen, but certainly something to consider

    even w/an obama stimulus coming up

    we'll see i guess :-)


    On Dec 22 08:48 AM birder wrote:

    > There is quite a lot of negative criticism of this post here, but
    > I am not too sure that all of it is justified. I do believe he did
    > mention 1st quarter withdrawals. That does allow sufficient time
    > for a 45 day notice. Certainly, there have already been plenty of
    > hedge fund withdrawals, but the point here is that as bad as everything
    > is, the Madoff affair might very well make a few people wonder whether
    > their money is safe anywhere other than under their matress. It makes
    > me wonder that. I believe I read that Madoff is going to bankrupt
    > the SIPC fund. Sort of makes one wonder whether one should remove
    > ones funds from every brokerage account out there.
    2008 Dec 22 09:17 AM Reply
  •  
  • Q1 2009 may be weak for the reason mentioned above, and other reasons of turmoil and economic weakness.
    2008 Dec 22 09:25 AM Reply
  •  
  • I guess I wonder what is left to redeem?

    Tudor Investment Group had $5.7 billion invested at June 30 as disclosed in its 13-F. Its September 30 filing shows only $453 million.

    Atticus Capital, another much-celebrated hedge fund, went from $8.1 billion to $510 million.

    SAC Capital, run by the Steven Cohen, went from $14.4 billion to $7.7 billion.

    Vinik Asset Management, led by Jeffrey Vinik, who once ran Fidelity Magellan, went from $11.8 billion to $1.8 billion!

    These numbers are as of September 30. So they do not include the awful months of October or November, so current assets at these funds would be even lower now, but if you are already down 90% .... who cares?

    The reduction is of course the combination of selling to meet redemption requests, and a decline in market value of existing positions, if these funds are anywhere close to "typical" I have to conclude that downward pressure on the market on a go-forward basis has got to be minimal as ... well as they are all pretty much out of money....?
    2008 Dec 22 09:40 AM Reply
  •  
  • Get in your bunker and load the guns because,

    We're - ALL FREAKIN DOOMED!!!!
    2008 Dec 22 09:49 AM Reply
  •  
  • Peter Cooper does a nice job of laying it on the line. We too expect market averages to fall below the 2008 lows in 2009. We are noticing the wounded wealthy as they put their assets up for sale. A 20% asset price decline puts the majority of USA residents net negative on their personal balance sheets as they loose their jobs.

    The incoming USA Federal Government administrators are talking about pitching pennies into the welfare pot and building negative yield assets with them

    Good Luck

    2008 Dec 22 09:52 AM Reply
  •  
  • Looks like the mattress is the best place for cash in the first quarter. Many "experts" are calling for a rising dollor against other currencies
    and short term treasuries pay zippo but are selling out. This will provide cover for Obama and company to spend over another trillion to stimulate"
    the economy throwing cash to friends and family in the first 90 days in office, then the hangover starts and inflation will come back with a heartless and rapid vengence.
    2008 Dec 22 09:54 AM Reply
  •  
  • I'm not very conersant with this subject, but it seems to me fatpitch has a good point. While redemptions forced large scale sales of assets and helped force prices very low, not so much cash has been recovered by the punters. The other 90% or so has gone into space.
    So the 'cash on the sidelines' is not such a huge consideration.
    2008 Dec 22 09:56 AM Reply
  •  
  • epeon said:
    "Thirdly, there are a lot of stocks that have extremely low pe ratios and pay good dividends. What is your alternative? 0% T-Bills? I think that selective stocks look pretty good in this environment."

    The answer is bank CDs. The whole reason for zirp is to recapitalize the banking system by driving the money market holders into CDs.
    2008 Dec 22 09:59 AM Reply
  •  
  • All though we are ALL FREAKIN DOOMED.

    You Best have already gotten your Gold and Silver NOW. The inflated balloon is going to start up and Folks I really do not see it coming down for a long, long time.

    Oh and get some guns before the new Prez makes it so FREAKIN hard to get one you won't be able to fend off the others wanting to take it from ya.

    What a mess - Helicopter Ben and his warped views on money and now a new Prez that is trying to out do him - with hedge funds imploding to boot and would not be surprized to see a freeze on pulling out funds or a staggering limit put on that.
    Geeezzzzzzz
    2008 Dec 22 10:10 AM Reply
  •  
  • All though we are ALL FREAKIN DOOMED.

    You Best have already gotten your Gold and Silver NOW. The inflated balloon is going to start up and Folks I really do not see it coming down for a long, long time.

    Oh and get some guns before the new Prez makes it so FREAKIN hard to get one you won't be able to fend off the others wanting to take it from ya.

    What a mess - Helicopter Ben and his warped views on money and now a new Prez that is trying to out do him - with hedge funds imploding to boot and would not be surprized to see a freeze on pulling out funds or a staggering limit put on that.
    Geeezzzzzzz
    2008 Dec 22 10:10 AM Reply
  •  
  • I'm not up to speed on hedge funds, so excuse me if this is a silly question.

    When hedge funds receive redemption requests, does that obligate them to sell holdings immediately? Or can they cover the redemptions with cash on hand and sell when the timing is more beneficial to them?

    I'm just wondering if all of the YE selling is done, even though all of the YE redemptions are done.
    2008 Dec 22 10:33 AM Reply
  •  
  • look, all this talk about investments is a delusion. we are going into anarchy, there won't be anyone buying anything they can't eat wear or kill with.
    2008 Dec 22 10:42 AM Reply
  •  
  • is everybody happy @ this holiday time? have a merry "ponzi" should be the theme of the here & now.the sheeples are fleeced but still very concerned about yesterdays football score.legal or illegal,its all ponzi.im surprised no one has created a ponzi derivative(AAAAAA) rated of course by our ethical rating co'.s.
    2008 Dec 22 10:46 AM Reply
You've only read the first 20 comments