Global Stock Markets: Highs, Lows and What to Expect in 2009

As investors ring out the old year, trading volume should remain light until battle-weary traders return from the holidays next week. Not much weight should therefore be placed on market movements during this “thin” period, and the S&P 500 Index will probably not deviate a great deal from its three-week trading range.

click to enlarge

Ushering in the New Year, investors will not only be hung over from 2008’s financial rout, but also still be grappling with the vital question: What is the most likely direction of the stock market?

I have analyzed a number of fundamental and technical considerations in my recent posts (“Stock Markets: Is this It?” “Is the Tide Turning for Stocks?” and “Is the Stock Market Rally Real?”). Additionally, breadth indicators are also useful tools to assess the inner workings of the market’s rallies or corrections, and are discussed in this article. These indicators are used to identify strength or weakness behind market moves such as the rally since late-November, i.e. to assess how the bulls and the bears are exerting themselves.

First, a quick review of the stock market scoreboard. The MSCI World Index and the MSCI Emerging Markets Index have improved by 18.7% and 21.9% respectively since the November 20 lows. As far as the U.S. markets are concerned, the Dow Jones Industrial Index has gained 14.8% since the low, the S&P 500 Index 18.4%, the Nasdaq Composite Index 17.8% and the Russell 2000 Index 25.3%.

click to enlarge

Although the MSCI Emerging Markets Index and the Russell 2000 Index now qualify as being in new bull markets (at least in terms of the traditional definition of a 20% rise), all indices still have an exceedingly long road ahead to regain the start-of-year and top-of-bull-market levels.

The table below shows the key resistance and support levels for the major U.S. indices. After having flirted with their respective 50-day moving averages earlier in December, all the indices are again at these resistance levels. The next targets are the November 4 highs, followed by the key 200-day average (not shown on table). On the downside, the December 1 (not shown) and all-important November 20 lows must hold for the uptrend to remain intact.

click to enlarge

Let’s consider six measures of stock market “internals.”

(1) The advance/decline spread tracks the difference between advancing and declining issues and is widely used to measure the breadth of a stock market advance or decline. The chart below shows that the spread between declining and advancing issues on the NYSE has been moving in the right direction (for bulls) since the November lows and is actually again in positive territory.

click to enlarge

(2) The up/down volume spread is determined by subtracting the volume of declining issues from the volume of advancing issues. The chart is similar in appearance to the one above and the conclusion is the same.

(3) Net new highs are calculated by subtracting the number of new 52-week lows from the number of new 52-week highs. The panic day of October 10 marked an “internal bottom” when 92.6% of the stocks on the NYSE broke to new lows (whereas a “price bottom” was recorded on November 20). Net new highs have since improved markedly, but new lows are still in excess of new highs.

click to enlarge

(4) Turning to Lowry Research, its Selling Pressure Index (supply) has been steadily declining, but the Buying Power Index (demand) has not made headway as potential buyers remain unnerved and stick to the sidelines.

The 84-year-old Richard Russell (Dow Theory Letters) said:

Normally, at final bear market bottoms, the Buying Power Index will plow higher as institutional money rushes in to pick up ‘bargains.’

(5) The number of NYSE stocks trading above their respective 50-day moving averages has increased to 56.8% from almost zero in October. In order to be bullish about the secondary trend, one would expect the majority of stocks to be above the 50-day line. For a primary uptrend to manifest itself, the bulk of the index constituents also need to trade above their 200-day averages. This is a slow indicator, but the number at the moment is still a non-existent 8.0%.

click to enlarge

(6) The Bullish Percent Index shows the percentage of stocks that are currently in bullish mode as a result of point-and-figure buy signals. With the figure at 52.3%, this indicator conveys the same message as the previous one.

Although stock market breadth has been moving in the right direction since October/November, the “internals” need to make further headway – advancing issues eclipsing declining issues, up volume outstripping down volume, new highs outpacing new lows and a higher percentage of stocks entering a bull phase – in order for an overall bull market to get traction.

It is too early to say whether the declines have been completed and the rally is sustainable. Failing stronger internals and further evidence of the thawing of the credit markets and the world’s financial systems starting to function normal again, investor confidence will probably remain reticent (with $8.85 trillion staying on the sidelines in cash, bank deposits and money market funds).

However, one should be cognizant of the fact that while the financial news continues to be awful, the stock market lows are holding and bases are forming. Selective buying – companies and sectors – in global markets is in order, and ’09 may turn out to be a good year for a discerning stock picker. However, make sure to separate the wheat from the chaff because many companies will fall by the wayside during the New Year.

Comments

[Schweizer:]

It's pretty clear the pros aren't buying. They are selling to the usual victims with the help of the Wall Street media.

The November low was a panic low and not a capitulation low. Capitualtion is when no one wants stocks, period. With the latest EPS forecast for SP500 earnings now at $42, and a Bear market bottom of a PE=8 (based on the last 4 big recession bottoms), the SP500 could/should see 42 x 8 = $332 in 2009. Perhaps we will see capitulation then.

2008 Dec 31 05:53 AM

[axelrod608:]

>> "’09 may turn out to be a good year for a discerning stock picker" >>

EVERY year is a good year for a good stock picker. There are always winners even in the worst of markets.

I see '09 as a real threat to the overly optimistic. Jumping into a bear market rally could turn to disaster when the next shoe drops.

The safe play is to assume a very long U-shaped bottom. Assuming a quick V-shaped bottom just doesn't seem realistic given earnings projections and a host of other market info.

2008 Dec 31 09:58 AM

[Kinnick:]

Pretty tough to give much validity to the trading range for the last week of december with the light volume. We nudged just north of the MA50 on the S&P, but with so little conviction I just can't believe it. We've did this in mid December as well, and while the MA50 appears to be leveling, the lack of volume gives is much less credibility.

I closed a few long positions today. I'm not bullish on Q1 2009, but lord knows I've been wrong before. We'll see what happens on January 5th.

Jan 01 04:40 AM