The fact that commodity prices were hit hard in the fourth quarter is no surprise to anyone. Molybdenum had it the worst, falling 53%. Oil followed with a 51% decline, copper was down 49%, nickel fell 43%, aluminum dipped 34% and zinc dropped 33%. However, some have recovered slightly since the end of 2008.
As a result of the slowing global economy, demand for materials has weakened, which is having a significant negative impact on earnings. UBS analyst Brian MacArthur noted that this has been especially tough on concentrate producers with prior period adjustments.
He said in a research note:
However, a number of companies have moved quickly to restructure high-cost operations, reduce capex, conserve cash, and prepare for a prolonged downturn.
The rapid decline in base metals during the second half of 2009 and particularly the fourth quarter is expected to result in significant provisional pricing [PP] adjustments for concentrate producers, particularly in copper, zinc and molybdenum as booked revenues are reversed, according to BMO Capital Markets.
Revenue in a given quarter is based on current prices but some sales are still subject to final pricing. “These pricing adjustments result in additional revenues in a rising price environment and reductions to revenue in a declining price environment,” analyst David Cotterell told clients.
He said PP is expected to impact larger diversified earnings by an average 3% in the second half of 2008, with notable earnings downgrades made to Xstrata plc (OTC:XSRAF) (-7%) and Teck Cominco Ltd. (NYSE:TCK) (-20%). Smaller pure-play copper producers overall show greater leverage than this, Mr. Cotterell added.
Earnings estimates at UBS are meaningfully lower than current consensus estimates for a handful of companies. These include First Quantum, Inmet Mining Corp. (OTC:IEMMF), Lundin Mining Corp. (LMC), Quadra Mining Ltd. (OTC:QADMF), FNX Mining Co. Inc. (OTC:FNXMF), Teck Cominco, Methanex Corp. (NASDAQ:MEOH), Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. (NYSE:FCX) and Agrium Inc. (NYSE:AGU). However, it cautioned that consensus estimates are often not up to date and some do not factor in prior period settlements, which could explain some of the variance.
Mr. MacArthur said:
Despite the significant drop in many input prices, we expect that operating costs have only declined slightly as the decreases in fuel, sulphur and sulphuric acid prices may not be immediately felt, and labour markets normally ease at a slower rate than the downturn in the economy.
He also expects the impact of rising costs of consumables experienced during the third quarter have been partially carried through into the fourth quarter.
However, sentiment for the base metals market isn’t all grim. The major infrastructure development programs announced by many countries, which include rebuilding bridges, upgrading transportation systems, as well as public buildings and schools, could provide a much-needed lift.
“This type of development by nature tends to be metal-intensive,” Octagon Capital analyst Hendrik Visagie said in a research note. He expects China’s program that calls for $538-billion in expenditures over two years will ramp up quickly starting in mid-February. As a result, China’s demand growth for metals is forecast to be between 5% and 8% in 2009.
Mr. Visagie said:
China’s demand growth, coupled with the drop in mine supply, should keep metal inventories down in the short term, and when the U.S. and other countries begin infrastructure development, we believe metal prices will increase significantly.
However, the U.S. program is expected to take longer to implement as a result of the need for congressional approval.
Blackmont Capital’s George Topping said:
Corrections of this magnitude are not uncommon within the commodity cycle; however, the velocity of the decline has been tenfold faster than in previous cycles..
He told clients that the massive correction in such a short time gives producers very little time to adjust their ore reserve base to accommodate lower prices. As a result, their primary defence mechanism has been to shut down loss-making operations.
Meanwhile, many of the world’s mines have been operating at full capacity to take advantage of higher prices, so the best grades have probably already been mined. The same situation applies to development projects that have been frozen to preserve cash and allow further study at lower metal prices, Mr. Topping said.
While he thinks the supply response will sow the seeds of the next metals cycle, demand must first stop falling. Blackmont anticipates weaker global economic growth in the first half of 2009 but sees stabilization for developing economies like China and India in the second half of the year.