-
Font Size:
-
Print
- TweetThis
Ask your barber about gold. He or she will tell you it's a good investment.
He or she will explain to you that the dollar is terribly weak because the Federal Reserve is printing huge amounts of money so gold is the only safe investment these days. He or she heard it on a commercial on AM radio - actually, not one commercial, but dozens. A bunch of his or her friends and relatives sent him or her emails about how gold was going to rise to $2,000 or maybe even $5,000 or even $10,000 per ounce. It was even on TV. Wow, if he or she had any money to invest he or she would sure buy gold.
But that's really the problem: he or she doesn't have any money. He or she cannot expand his or her business because his or her bank will not lend her the money - or him. His or her house may well be near foreclosure. His or her credit card company is about to drop him or bomb her with interest rates she can't pay. He will not get a car loan to replace the clunker parked behind the shop and she won't get a student loan to learn another skill when local layoffs cut demand in the barbering business.
The supply of dollars is shrinking, thus...
click to enlarge
...the price is once again rising – fast.
If people would only read a little further into their recently-dusted-off macroeconomics textbooks they'd find that while the government creates some money, the private system generally creates multiples of that amount. Well, it used to. Now what the private system does is destroy money as loans and credit lines are called in and cowardly business “leaders” throw layoff gasoline on the deflation fire. People are figuring out that the recent glut in bank reserves they see in the Fed's H.3 release is not an inflationary blast, but a probably insufficient bulwark against deflationary disaster. If Citibank (C) didn't tell you that loudly enough, I hope Bank of America (BAC) did. If you didn't hear their message, just wait for the next debacle. The American capitalist system has become a money-destroying machine.
Once deflation sets in, there will be no profits to be found – anywhere. But as I write this and gold puts in the second spike of a double or triple top, the value proposition short gold becomes really too good to ignore. If gold can break convincingly out of the anti-bubble, fine, you stop out somewhere between here and north of $1000/oz. Pick your spot, but it's not a bad loss. If gold cannot break out of the commodities anti-bubble, you are in contrarian heaven. In that scenario, gold loses a minimum of $250/oz before it gets another sustained uptrend and the fundamentals remain bearish for the foreseeable future. I think this present spike in gold will prove about as reliable as the recent spike in the euro:

They are (were) both based on the same, flawed, short dollar thesis.
In my view, going long gold is just another manifestation of the Deflation Denial syndrome. I think the smart play – maybe the only play – is to be long deflation in this environment. If you can find a better deflation play than going short gold – make it.
Disclosure: No positions
Related Articles
|






















This article has 39 comments:
What scenario would cause you to change your mind?
Say a move by Gold back to $750?
The USD moving up another 20%?
A move by the US Markets to DOW 6,000 and S&P $600?
Or would Oil below $30 do it?
With 28 analysts bullish on gold and only 3 bearish, I would think some sort of caution is called for on the short term, say 2-3 months. Just an opinion.
When the dust settles, the dollar's problem remains. Every dollar represents a dollar of debt, and we have to service that debt, from tax revenues or just plain printing money.
What will happen to our tax base during a sustained deflationary period? If you need a clue, look at California.
And don't look now, but we have a few more retirees expecting their welfare, er, social security checks in the mail. Medicare, anyone?
The only way to save the dollar is to pay down debt. If you think that will happen, then yes! Short gold!
But if you think people will become wary of loaning our government money, you may want to go the other way.
America needs the world's savings to keep us afloat, and those savings will not be coming here for much longer.
Maybe you should go back to your barber for some sound financial advice.
i'm inclined to go w your opinion of what my barber would say as there's about much hair pushing out from my back, nose & ears these days as my head, and my wife does a pretty good job w what's left over... last i remember, the subject was more towards country music & local high school football than economics & it might surprise them a bit much if i showed up for a consult on the price of gold.
thanks for the tip.
Mr. "Socrateazz"'s suggested to me that it might be useful to explore the deflationary attitude that has taken hold in America. I will do so in a follow-up to this piece.
Clearly, there are many people who think that deflation is unlikely or unlikely to be of any duration. I would simply suggest that whether or not he believes there will be significant deflation, a wise investor would nevertheless have a deflation game plan, given the present economic circumstances. So far I have not read of a better deflation play than going short gold, although I'm sure they exist. If you think of one, make it. Oh, and then please write about it.
Thanks again.
Whoever wanted to buy gold has already gotten plenty. Why would they continue to buy at these levels?
Not to mention the profit taking that will occur.
All I have to go on is what I see as a consumer, everything going up in price except electronics.
Also, foreign individuals will buy gold if THEIR currencies depreciate. There needn't be inflation in the US for gold to rise--buying pressure can come from anywhere. Finally, inflation need only be a threat on the horizon for it to motivate gold-buying. Thus, even in a deflationary environment, gold could rise until expectations are fulfilled. It could rise longer than shorts could stay solvent.
Speaking of which, gold has risen $10 in London this morning, to $907. The professional shorts are making themselves scarce. Maybe they know something.
However I buy gold, keep, each and every month, and I don't care what the current price is dollars. The absolute safest bet on a deflation scene is long cash. Why get cute?
Two questions occupy my waking moments:
1. When will all the new money gain traction?
2. Where is the tipping point where printing translates into collapse?
I am convinced that one of the two will occur, and it now seems the economy will continue to slow down until one of them does occur. I don't know, and there is no way for me to know, how long this will take. The worst possible scenario is that we will endure a forced liquidation period similar to that which was experienced by hedge funds; sell everything of value you own in an effort to stay afloat, while your income source is threatened. At some point this liquidation period ends (capitulation) and then currency devaluation begins to be felt. Just as the middle class is left jobless, homeless, and assetless everything they need to survive skyrockets in price. Granted, this is a nightmare scenario, but it seems possible, so I am hedging my PM positions with hefty amounts of cash. The purpose of the cash, literally, is to defend the PM position.
Strong hands.
Scarcity vs inflation, demand and scarcity will win.
I think the Investment counselors are well on their way in accepting all commodities as having a place in porfolios.
Gold Bugs will just have to accept gold as just another investment in the not to distant future.
If Calpers can go the commodity route, anyone can.
stockcharts.com/h-sc/u...=$GOLD&p=D&b=5...
When I look at this chart I see gold in the early stages of an uptrend. Since the November lows gold has been making higher highs and higher lows. The 50 day moving average turned up rougly a month ago. The price is also making new highs the last few days in strong rallies.
What remains to be seen is whether / when gold breaks above the $920 level and how it acts thereafter. A strong move above the $920 level with good follow through will be a very good sign for continuing strength in gold. If that were to happen, I wouldn't want to be short gold.
www.ft.com/cms/s/0/b87...
"The International Monetary Fund is caught in a stand-off between members over whether to label China’s currency as “fundamentally misaligned”, a politically explosive move that could stoke global tension over economic imbalances."
Go Treasuries!
The author is not shorting gold. Why not? If you believe that the Fed et al will not not continue to print dollars, raise rates, give more billions to banks, then you should be pounding those keyboard keys to load up on DZZ.
Then again sir, you may just want to wade in, toe by toe, into the gold tsunami that is beginning! You will be glad you did. Have a great day!
Long term the place to be is short the Long Bond. However, I wouldn't be surprised to see the FED or the Plunge Protection Team spring into action to create a mini rally in the long bond price.
This is the risk of simply shorting the long bond and forgetting it. The guys struggling to keep the music going have very deep pockets and can take virtually unlimited losses in the short term if it suits their needs.
Be aware and tread carefully.
Everyone has heard the Joe Kennedy 'barber' story. What gold really is in my view is a monetary metal (not a commodity metal) that is a 'safe haven' hedge against bad times - whether they be inflationary or deflationary. I spent a great deal of time studying this between September and December of 2008, and posted my conclusions (and reasoning) on a series of 11 Blog Posts on stockresearchportalblo.... They are there to be read by anyone interested in doing that under the Category 'Gold as an Investment'.
Maybe people are talking about gold, but I know very few people who are out buying coins and bullion. It still gets a laugh when I tell my friends (relatively educated on investments versus the general population) to buy gold.
To answer your question, EVERYTHING is a better deflation bet than gold. If gold falls, everything will be falling too. Maybe gold will fall more, but you'll make money shorting most anything. However, gold hasn't fallen for several months now. I would rather make a high probability, small gain bet on deflation in financial assets, rather than a low probability, high return bet on gold joining the other commodities with 50% losses.
Do you think that the national debt is going to increase exponentially or decrease? This really isn't that hard to figure out.
So short gold, and borrow money to do it too. Your faith in paper and ignorance of history will benefit some of us...that is, unless the USA outright defaults on its debt...then you will be right.
Ergo, the future of the USDX is either a) down, or b) down. Will someone please explain this to Shedlock, the deflationists, and the radical dollar bugs?
On Jan 26 11:01 AM ShockOnT wrote:
> (monetizing). Value retention in the dollar has a supply/demand
> component and a confidence component. Right now there is a the supply/demand
> component is positive due to the great unwinding. Confidence, however,
> is another story. After the deflation the US will be left with a
> smaller real GDP and ballooning national debt/govt deficits. With
> less ability to service trillions in debt via tax revenues, one would
> have to conclude that confidence in the dollar will wane. When the
> "great unwind" is over the remaining support mechanism for the dollar
> will be removed and real assets will appreciate versus the dollar.
>
Supply and demand...commodities like food should always go higher.
Taxation...governments want to always spend taxpayer's money so
they directly or indirectly create an inflation in cost of living.
The third cause is where I think why I see more deflation in upcoming years.
Leverage...if a bank is lending at 30 to 1 reserves than they are creating a massive inflation. But right now that's not in the cards. Tighter leverage and
regulations should rule for a long period of time.
So items like real estate, yachts, luxury items, credit cards and lines of
credit...all things that I see continuing to retract for a few more years.
Contraction should mean lower earnings and lower P/E ratios.
Government stimulus is a short term (6-9 month) boost only...then back to
more deflation. Our economy is leveraged based...cash buyers do not create
inflation. Without leverage our economy will continue to adjust to much lower
cash buyer based levels. I'm not a gold bug but might be proven wrong..
consider it an asset and subject to leverage like any asset.
now if only the real world had the same kind of deflation taking place.... that would be wonderful!
Shorting gold? I like your logic, but too many gold bugs will keep it up IMHO, at least for a while.
On Jan 26 07:17 AM dlaw wrote:
> Thanks for all your comments, as always.
>
> Mr. "Socrateazz"'s suggested to me that it might be useful to explore
> the deflationary attitude that has taken hold in America. I will
> do so in a follow-up to this piece.
>
> Clearly, there are many people who think that deflation is unlikely
> or unlikely to be of any duration. I would simply suggest that whether
> or not he believes there will be significant deflation, a wise investor
> would nevertheless have a deflation game plan, given the present
> economic circumstances. So far I have not read of a better deflation
> play than going short gold, although I'm sure they exist. If you
> think of one, make it. Oh, and then please write about it.
>
> Thanks again.
You betcha. Therein lies the rub. It does not matter, or maybe rather, it matters less and less how strong the dollar is, when it comes to keeping the price of gold down.
If the price of gold bullion is going to go down, then why is the US mint making hard to obtain coins? Or, how about Comex not meeting its orders. Or, GLD (the Canadian Spider Fund) that is buying tonnes of bullion? Or, the South African mint slowing down Kuggerand sales? And then there's China, hoarding all the gold it can mine.
I see bullion bouncing around, but trending higher to the end of the year. Then watch out!
The biggest thing I don't like about gold is that its a crowded trade in the crowded end of the canoe - a bad, bad place to be in the investment world. When your barber says buy, you should usually sell. The Horizons BetaPro Adviser Sentiment Survey just released had this to say, "Advisers have been consistently bullish on gold bullion for the last eight quarters, with two-thirds of the advisers continuing this positive outlook." The last eight quarters? That's two years, and gold has gone way up over that time. But I still dislike any high profile investment. If it's the subject of any poll, it's too high profile for me.
I rather short David Bailey. What a fool!
seekingalpha.com/artic...
Interest rates are also manipulated (some say), such as treasuries being bought by the billions with Chinese and Saudi recycled dollars, to keep rates low. Some believe that there is very little actual honesty in the markets at this point, if indeed there ever was,
The battle between inflation and deflation has been joined, but there is not yet a predictable outcome. It looks to me as though deflation will win out, because the destruction of money and credit resulting from unwinding the astounding amount of leverage used by large international interests seems too much to overcome. We can invest billions of dollars, but when credit (money) is destroyed, its multiplier effect is also destroyed. I do not believe it is possible to inflate enough trillions of dollars into the U.S. economy to overcome the destruction of credit and its multiplier.
In terms of gold, some believe gold prices will be manipulated to fall in order to make the dollar -- a fiat currency worth nothing but the ink and paper used to print it -- a safe haven. In the long run, many believe that gold will emerge victorious, when the dollar becomes hyperinflated. One thing is clear: so far, the track record of gold is better than the track record of the dollar as a store of value.
Gold anticipates, what has gold not anticipated at this point in time? Gold enthusiasts have already priced in Hyperinflation and USD decimation.
IMO
I just bought some DZZ.
"Some say the dollar will collapse this year, but collapse against what? The euro? The Russian ruble? These currencies are even weaker. In the very long run, each citizen must become his own central bank. Every responsible citizen must hold some physical gold, platinum and silver -- physically, not through derivatives".
I want a pure financial play that recognizes the dollar issue. That is why I am short long term treasuries...RYJUX NOT TBT, constant leverage trap is too frightening for a long term hold.