Last June, I wrote an article about Topeka, KS-based thrift Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. (NASDAQ:CFFN), in which I argued that CFFN was highly overvalued because while its price/tangible book value per share (TBV-PS) multiple might seem low at only 1.01x, it was too high given CFFN's poor return on average tangible common equity (RoATCE). RoATCE averaged 3.60% for the five quarters after CFFN's December 2010 second-stage conversion from mutual form. Although thrifts generally have lower RoATCEs than banks, good ones can still post RoATCEs of 12% or higher.
CFFN has since posted three quarters of financial results. What has happened? Assets fell by another 3.5%, or 5.7% in total from their year-end 2010 peak. RoATCE increased slightly, averaging...
|FREE||SA PRO MEMBERS|
|IDEA GENERATOR||X||Exclusive access to 10 PRO ideas every day|
|INVESTING IDEAS LIBRARY||X||Exclusive access to PRO library of more than 15,000 ideas|
|SECTOR EXPERT NETWORK||X||Exclusive access to all sector experts for direct consultation|
|PERFORMANCE TRACKING||X||Track performance of all PRO stock ideas|
|PROFESSIONAL TOOLS||X||Professional Idea Filters to zero-in based on industry, market cap and more|