Harvard Winters
Long/short equity, growth at reasonable price, value

Advice For Capitol Federal Financial, Inc.: Pay More Special Dividends And Stop The Share Buybacks

Last June, I wrote an article about Topeka, KS-based thrift Capitol Federal Financial, Inc. (NASDAQ:CFFN), in which I argued that CFFN was highly overvalued because while its price/tangible book value per share (TBV-PS) multiple might seem low at only 1.01x, it was too high given CFFN's poor return on average tangible common equity (RoATCE). RoATCE averaged 3.60% for the five quarters after CFFN's December 2010 second-stage conversion from mutual form. Although thrifts generally have lower RoATCEs than banks, good ones can still post RoATCEs of 12% or higher.

CFFN has since posted three quarters of financial results. What has happened? Assets fell by another 3.5%, or 5.7% in total from their year-end 2010 peak. RoATCE increased slightly, averaging...

Join Seeking Alpha PRO to read this archived article and 11,574 other archived articles
IDEA GENERATORXExclusive access to 10 PRO ideas every day
INVESTING IDEAS LIBRARYXExclusive access to PRO library of more than 15,000 ideas
SECTOR EXPERT NETWORKXExclusive access to all sector experts for direct consultation
PERFORMANCE TRACKINGXTrack performance of all PRO stock ideas
PROFESSIONAL TOOLSXProfessional Idea Filters to zero-in based on industry, market cap and more
"In just the first month of using PRO, I used it to generate two ideas which were actionable for me. As a result of these two positions, I have earned more than 20 times the annual subscription costs for PRO."Michael Yagemann, Greenbridge Capital
"I am pleasantly surprised with the scope of small and mid-cap coverage PRO offers. You can't find that any where else."Patrick Rice, Mainstay Capital Management
You may cancel at any time for any reason, and receive a prompt refund for membership on months paid and not used (max. 6 months). Details