click to enlargeClick to enlarge
The numbers for 2008 are in, and we can now quantify just how rough the year was for commodity spot markets.
So far in 2009, the results are much better, though that’s not the case across the board.
Out of our basket of 14 hard and soft commodities, only coal and gold finished 2008 in positive territory. Coal was up 12.6 percent due to a relatively strong first half of the year, while gold rose nearly 6 percent during the year as many investors concerned about rapidly devaluing assets fled to a safe haven.
Contrast this to the stellar performance of commodities in 2007, when all but three of the 14 finished positive. Wheat led the way with a 77 percent gain, followed by oil’s 57 percent increase and lead at 43 percent.
In fact, even though coal was at the top of the heap in 2008, its performance was 16 percentage points worse than in the previous year, and gold’s gain last year was 25 percentage points lower than in 2007.
Lead plummeted to the bottom of the chart in 2008, trailed closely by copper, nickel and oil. Of course, for oil, it was a year of extremes – it soared to a peak of $147 per barrel in July before nose-diving to under $45 by year-end.
In bull markets, the old saying goes, a rising tide lifts all boats. In a falling market, those same boats often end up as shipwrecks.
You can see that in the 2008 returns. In none of the previous eight years did so many of the 14 commodities finish underwater – the next worst year was 2001, when nine had negative returns.
2001 was one of the worst years for commodities in recent memory, with natural gas falling 74 percent, oil 26 percent and nearly all of the industrial metals turning in double-digit losses. But even that year pales next to 2008.
The mean return for the 14 commodities in 2008 was -34 percent (-17.4 percent in 2001), and the median was -37.4 percent (-16.1 percent in 2001).
Eleven of the 14 commodities finished with a loss of 20 percent or more in 2008. That is more than the previous eight years combined.
2009 is still young, but two spot commodities are already down more than 20 percent – crude oil (-23.8 percent) and natural gas (-20.2 percent).
It’s been a much better six weeks for silver, which is up nearly 19 percent in 2009. Palladium (+15.8 percent) and platinum (+14.9 percent) have also started the year on the right foot. Gold is up about 7 percent.
And lead is once again buoyant – it’s risen about 12 percent so far in 2009.