Seeking Alpha
Paulo Santos, Think Finance (382 clicks)
Long/short equity, arbitrage, event-driven, research analyst
Profile| Send Message| ()  

Here's another (AMZN) prediction from me:'s media segment revenue growth will probably turn negative before the end of the year, then re-accelerate into positive growth. My guess would be that this will happen in Q2 or Q3.

It's a bit of a long shot, but there are several reasons for me predicting this. I will list them below.

Overall revenue growth is slowing fast

For many different reasons, including sales tax collection and price matching by physical retailers,'s overall revenue growth is slowing down fast. In Q1 or Q2 2012, overall revenue growth will break below 20% year-on-year.'s revenue came in $1 billion below expectations during Q4 2012, and also guided down Q1 2013 $1 billion below prior market estimates. At this point the market consensus is for's revenues to grow 22.6% during Q1 2013 and 24.4% during Q2 2013, implying a re-acceleration of growth in the short term. This stands in stark contrast with the recent evolution of sales growth, as we can see below, and his highly unlikely to happen.

AMZN Revenue Quarterly YoY Growth Chart

AMZN Revenue Quarterly YoY Growth data by YCharts

What is more likely to happen is for to guide down revenues for Q2 2013, much like it has been doing for all of the past year regarding the upcoming quarters.

eBook revenues are decelerating fast as per the publishing industry

Although's lack of transparency means we can't have an exact idea of the size of the ebook revenue, we have indications from publishers that ebook revenue growth is decelerating fast. did claim 70% growth for 2012, but it's again hard to say what such a number includes due to the lack of transparency.

Anyway, there have been several reports (I, II) highlighting the slowing ebook sales. At the same time has been losing significant market share to other players, namely Apple (AAPL), because obviously iBookstore is better integrated with iOS than Amazon can ever be (and still avoid Apple's 30% cut). Over the last 2 years, went from 57.1% (2010) of the ebook market down to 44.5% (2012), as per Morgan Stanley.

The chart below also illustrates how the increase in ebook revenues at mid-2012 was already slowing down when compared to a torrid 2011 (Source: ebookcomments blog)

(click to enlarge)

Finally, the straw which might break the camel's back

A lot of people don't know it, but part of's media revenues is actually gaming consoles. Not games for the consoles, but the consoles themselves. Now, both the xBox 360 and the Sony Playstation 3 are going to be replaced during 2013. The new devices will most probably hit the market at the end of the year, and there will be a very likely lull in console buying prior to that, much like it happens with every iteration of the iPhone, but even stronger given that the console cycle is much longer.

It will be this lull which might, together with the other effects, impact's media revenues to the point where they turn slightly and temporarily negative. Then, in late 2013, the new consoles might actually lead to a re-acceleration of the media segment revenues.

Can avoid this prediction?

Actually it can. has no transparency whatsoever. One of the reasons I predict media revenue will turn negative is because has, in the past, included gaming consoles in its media segment. might elect to include other weird choices in this segment to present is as still growing.

Conclusion trades as if its strong revenue growth will be unending, even in the face of successive revenue warnings. It might thus come as a surprise to the market if's original segment, its media segment, sees its revenue growth turn negative year-on-year even if just temporarily. After all, does not trade at multiples compatible with negative growth of any kind.

This event - if it comes to pass -- might thus constitute a possible catalyst leading to more a more realistic valuation for stock.

Source: Media Revenue Growth Will Probably Turn Negative