Seeking Alpha
About this author: By this author:
Thanks to subscriber Tom for sending this. In the clip below, Jon Stewart does his usual masterful job, this time on CNBC's worthlessness. Here's an index of key moments:
  • Cramer's "Bear Stearns is fine" call. (3:03)
  • "Lehman Brothers is no Bear Stearns. . . . Lehman Management is incredibly engaged and responsive." (3:15)
  • Merrill won't need to raise additional capital. (3:30)
  • Cramer saying Bank of America (BAC) is going to $60. (3:50)
  • AIG is not going bankrupt because its subprime mortgage exposure is manageable. (4:00)
  • Cramer's October 2007 call to buy stocks. (4:54)
  • Cramer's February 2008 call to buy stocks. (5:06)
  • April 2008, Kudlow & Co., "The worst of this subprime business is over." (5:14)
  • Cramer's June 2008 call to buy stocks. (5:20)
  • November 2008, "The fundamentals are coming back into play. . . . people are starting to get their confidence back." (5:26)
  • Jon Stewart: "Wow. If I had only followed CNBC's advice, I'd have a million dollars -- provided I'd started with a hundred million dollars. How do they do it?" (5:34)
  • The ultimate example of a worthless CNBC executive interview: Ponzi scheme maestro Allen Stanford. Talking head Carl Quintanilla's million-dollar question: "Is it fun being a billionaire?" (7:06)

Print this article with comments

This article has 45 comments:

  •  
    Stewart & staff put a fine point on public ridicule of those who fully deserve it. For a comedy show they pack in a lot of news.

    By contrast, given the utter failure of so many CNBC calls, CNBC seems to have more value as business entertainment and political opinion for market watchers, but little reliable guidance.
    Mar 05 08:13 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    BTW, here's a good link via "businessinsider" to cut & paste for the daily show piece:

    www.businessinsider.co...


    Enjoy!
    Mar 05 08:20 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Jason
    I would not follow Cramer's pics but if you follow his general Advice you may do well. I can point out a few other things like Peak oil and it was supply and demand. Not of oil but of oil futures contracts last July. That was the supply and demand

    However all joking aside was'nt Cramer the one who told people last September if they did not need money in the equity markets to pull it out?

    Cramer is predicting the bottom in housing for next Summer

    Cramer called a bottom in financials last Summer late. Little did he or many of us knew at the time the bottom was a string of w's. with the peaks lower each time.

    He makes investing interesting. It's not all his fault I scuffed up his crystal ball by stealing it for medic's bowling night.
    Mar 05 09:15 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Like all other cable news channels, CNBC is merely showbiz, and should not be taken seriously. Don't you just love the "All Stars" (as they call themselves) on Power Lunch engage in a daily food fight as Dennis, Michelle, Rick and Melissa rant and rave, shouting at one another-- reminds me of high school days-- and Dennis spews ridiculous ideas! Then there's the daily Kudlow rant. They should be on the Springer show! (The Motley Fool advises members to stop watching CNBC as a first rule of successful investing.)
    Mar 05 09:21 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am glad this is published. Next stop the Obama hunt by Cramer to distract attention from CNBC's silliness and misgivings. Everything wrong is because of Obama Cramer says now. All the guesses he had that were wrong or are wrong because of Obama and Geithner and ...Bernanki. Hmm! This is not a financial network. CNBC except for Mark Haines and Harwood (spellings?) is a political opinion soap opera without a script from Kernan to Bartiromo and ofcourse the stuttering bunch from AM to PM. They should just run Faber specials on Wall Mart. See I knew I could like Wall Mart thanks to CNBC. They are good for something afterall. The whole complex is a "House of Cards" another Faber deal and Mr Immelt is doing fine watching it and GE slide to ...where? God save their audience and investors.
    Mar 05 09:27 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Many of Cramer's picks have cost me a bundle- CHK for example. But remember his rant to get out of all financials in 2007? That spectacularly accurate piece of advice would have saved me enough to pay off the mortgages on three of my childrens homes. He and Kudler & Co. are worth watching, though they make a big deal of one piece of good advice and ignore all the bad. However, any fool can give consistent good advice in a rising market. I make my own decisions, and lose money either way!
    Mar 05 09:32 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    CNBC follows the markets in real time. For what that's worth, that's their value.
    Mar 05 09:45 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    So Cramer has been wrong, so what, who hasn't in this market. Hey Kelly can you show us your wining picks in this market.
    Mar 05 10:16 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I am glad I found a forum to vent out about CNBC. There ought to have another channel that competes against this channel. That channel is the nest of greedy, arrogant, out of touch people. It looks like these are ceo-wannabes that didn't make it. They are so out of touch is hurts. Whoever produce and cast this channel should be fired. From a senile talking moron Kudlow to smart but psychopatic Cramer to greedy Cabrera. Santelli and that stupid-faced kneale these people represents what is so bad about Wall street. And they are surprised why there are seething anger in Main street
    Mar 05 11:39 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    They feed the class warfare that is going to continue to escalate for years to come.

    Santelli rant on $75billion homeowner bailout saying traders in CBOT is America? Is that a joke? How much is the govt on the hook for now with AIG and Bear guarantees, and TARP?

    Who's the worst?.......Cabrera is my vote...
    Mar 05 12:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    CNBC puts all the blame on Obama! Are they financed by the Bush clan?
    Anyway I stopped watching this political nonsence and swiched to Bloomberg.
    Mar 05 12:17 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    You socialist spin puppets are fast!!!
    Not even 24 hours after the Obama hit list of critics to silence was created.
    Mar 05 12:48 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    On Cramer's picks: Even a blind squirrel finds a nut sometimes! On CNBC: I stopped watching the hype a long time ago, same way with the weather channel it's all about the hype! The skiy is falling.
    Mar 05 12:52 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    > Who's the worst?.......Cabrera is my vote...

    I would have to agree after I read her take on the tax evasion scandal (www.cnbc.com//id/29410...). She says, "Leave UBS alone. It is hypocritical on the part of our government to do this. Do you know which country is the biggest tax haven in the entire world? The United States!"

    So individuals committing tax fraud in the US should not be punished because US banks provide the same services for non-US citizens? Why didn't CNBC mention this several years ago? At least this tip would've generated extra income for me.
    Mar 05 12:56 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Don't hold back.....Haines and Harwood are just as bad as the others,
    Haines with his temper tantrums, Harwood with his nose up the Pres. tail end.


    On Mar 05 09:27 AM User 287705 wrote:

    > I am glad this is published. Next stop the Obama hunt by Cramer to
    > distract attention from CNBC's silliness and misgivings. Everything
    > wrong is because of Obama Cramer says now. All the guesses he had
    > that were wrong or are wrong because of Obama and Geithner and ...Bernanki.
    > Hmm! This is not a financial network. CNBC except for Mark Haines
    > and Harwood (spellings?) is a political opinion soap opera without
    > a script from Kernan to Bartiromo and ofcourse the stuttering bunch
    > from AM to PM. They should just run Faber specials on Wall Mart.
    > See I knew I could like Wall Mart thanks to CNBC. They are good for
    > something afterall. The whole complex is a "House of Cards" another
    > Faber deal and Mr Immelt is doing fine watching it and GE slide to
    > ...where? God save their audience and investors.
    Mar 05 01:20 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I hate Maria Bartiromo, let's rant on her
    Mar 05 03:36 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    On CNBC. their people are more important than guests or anyone else. They are all frustrated actors who fight for the spot light. They are much more interested in what they want to say than what a guest, who may or may not know anything, has to say. If they intend it to be a serious business channel of use to investors, they have totally missed their mark. It is nothing but pure entertainment--and not much of that.
    Mar 05 04:19 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Did everyone see them all turn white when GE was vaporixzing on Wednesday? Did they think all their negativity was't going to effect them?
    You reap what you wrought!
    Mar 05 10:51 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    CNBC is nothing but bubble vision. How can any respectable news organization employ people like Cramer, Kudlow, and a prize moron like Dennis Kneale. No wonder the parent company GE is is big trouble (not necessarily because of CNBC).
    Mar 06 12:52 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    What is most absurd is that the Streeters think helping a few homeowners is unfair and incurs a moral hazard, but they are happy to take 100 times as much money and guarantees for themselves.

    Is it not unfair with regional banks and credit unions if we bailout the investment banks? Is it not a moral hazard to prop up insolvent institutions with taxpayer money?

    The Santellis don't seem to understand they have lost all respect and goodwill after getting us into this mess. Americans are a civil and forgiving people, but don't push us. Santelli: Shut up and open your mouth only to say 'thank you taxpayers, thank you Washington, thank you Obama'. After that zip it. We don't want to hear your ideas, your opinions, your political persuations or even your movie recommendations.
    Mar 06 03:09 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    An old timer told me CNBC is what the stupid people watch.. and he wants to know what they are saying!

    The show offers scores of market calls and opinions daily. So trying to judge quality by cherry picking 12 calls is disingenuous garbage
    Mar 06 07:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    How the hell do people expect anyone (Obama) to fix decades of fiscal mismanagement and obfuscation in six weeks (that's when Obama was sworn in).

    This mindset of instant gratification and impatience is what got us into this mess in the first place.

    When you do your Spring cleaning, your house always looks messier at first.




    On Mar 05 10:25 AM ED K wrote:

    > Cramer was a avid supporter of OBama now he's blaming him for all
    > our ills,it's kind of like his stock picks,loves em' today and hates
    > em' the next day.
    Mar 06 09:18 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Obama's goal is to destroy this economy and the fabric of the country so he can rebuild it in his own image.
    Mar 06 09:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    says who? drudge?


    On Mar 05 12:48 PM JLR wrote:

    > You socialist spin puppets are fast!!!
    > Not even 24 hours after the Obama hit list of critics to silence
    > was created.
    Mar 06 10:04 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I have yet to see a more irritating, self deceiving idiot than that Cabrera.


    On Mar 05 12:15 PM zvarvel wrote:

    > They feed the class warfare that is going to continue to escalate
    > for years to come.
    >
    > Santelli rant on $75billion homeowner bailout saying traders in CBOT
    > is America? Is that a joke? How much is the govt on the hook for
    > now with AIG and Bear guarantees, and TARP?
    >
    > Who's the worst?.......Cabrera is my vote...
    Mar 06 10:44 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Crammer's rant they know nothing was about lowering interest rates. This was suppose to magically solve al our problems. This shows me that he had no understanding of the depth of our problems. The other really great one was spending almost an entire show touting Bear sterns shortly before it was sold for nothing. The list could go on and on but we must be wary of anyone who needs to come up with great ideas night after night. It is hard to be stupid in a bull market but real easy in a bear market. If you stick to investing only in bull markets, if you can identify them as such, you will be more likely to succeed.
    Mar 06 11:00 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Cramer has no shame. When he occasionally acknowledges a mistake he says "I was wrong, I missed that one, I apologize", then quickly moves on to his next rant. Another favorite is to confidently tout a stock, giving all kinds of details, maybe talking to the CEO, recommending "buy,buy,buy", and then, this hedge fund veteran puts a caveat by telling the reader to do his own research.

    Fine,who can argue with that, a nice disclaimer, but then he needs to simply say that he is a clown and sit back, enjoy the costumes and the props. the schtick gets old fast.
    Mar 06 11:55 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    they should be out planting mustard seeds & looking for goldilocks.just a large group of bs.
    Mar 06 12:18 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I agree with most of my fellow investors who posted here; CNBC is not a credible forum for market intelligence and investment advice.

    But in every cesspool of bias celebrity broadcasting, there is one jewel. I have watched FAST MONEY (5:00 pm est) hosted by Dylan Radigan throughout this recession and he has been an advocate for ripping on the abuses of the insurance and investment community, especially AIG as well as the money banks. I give him credit for that and will continue to watch the show.
    Mar 06 01:04 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    When Satire Is A Better Gage Of Reality Than The News - things have truly gone upside down.

    Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert are truly fantastic.
    Mar 06 02:47 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I donm't like Cabrera either. She seems hard right to me. Santelli's rant was real stupid. A bunch of fat cat traders at the CBOT didn't like seeing the government help out the little guy after bailing out the fat cats.


    On Mar 06 10:44 AM Mousepicker wrote:

    > I have yet to see a more irritating, self deceiving idiot than that
    > Cabrera.
    Mar 06 05:06 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Auto44 wrote:

    ". . . we must be wary of anyone who needs to come up with great ideas night after night."

    Amen! I don't want to be in front of a camera -- at all! These people are in Showbiz. They like being in front of a camera. If they weren't, hardly anybody would watch.

    I think there's not much to choose between CNN, CNBC, and MSNBC. Bloomberg is often better. Fox Business News is not available to me. Fox ("fair and balanced") is sometimes more interesting than CNN, etc., and sometimes less interesting. I am fascinated by how impartisan they make their partisanship appear.

    I have to take a breathing treatment 3 times daily. I channel surf between all of them, as well as the Weather Channel. I'm supposed to go to the gym 3 times per week. Fox is usually the only "news" choice. So I have ample exposure to all, IMO!
    Mar 06 06:58 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A big thanks for this post. CNBC is a laughingstock around the WEB. (There are several venues for spouting off on CNBC. Unfortunately, SeekingAlpha truncates links). I went so far as to email a cut and paste selection of them to the head of programming for CNBC. Not suprising, I didn't get a reply.

    Love the comments above. You have restored my confidence in the investing public.

    I particularly appreciated the comment that CNBC hosts talk over the guests and the slaps against that gasbag Kudlow. (To this day, I have no idea what mustard seeds are.) I'd like to also note that his couturiere should be taken out back and shot. Green ties, blue striped shirts with white collars? Go figure.

    And a great big hand to Stewart and Colbert who have over the last couple of days lambasted CNBC with wicked brilliance.

    jegan
    Mar 06 09:14 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Why do we have to listen to that supply side proven wrong idiot rant and rave. He belongs on FOX with the equally wrong Oh'Really. Why can't GE purge Kudlow so that they get viewership?
    Mar 06 10:53 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Cramer is a joke. He always telling people to jump after the ship has sunk.
    Mar 06 11:05 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Simply put, these commentators on CNBC are a bunch of light weights, all of them. They are shills for CEO's and CFO's. They don't dare ask a difficult question or a question that could be deemed unfriendly. Their interviews are jokes and, I am sorry to say so are they.
    Mar 07 12:21 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    There is another channel - Bloomberg. Much better, just the financial news and none of the nonsense shouting and Jerry Springer type commentary.


    On Mar 05 11:39 AM paulvard wrote:

    > I am glad I found a forum to vent out about CNBC. There ought to
    > have another channel that competes against this channel. That channel
    > is the nest of greedy, arrogant, out of touch people. It looks like
    > these are ceo-wannabes that didn't make it. They are so out of touch
    > is hurts. Whoever produce and cast this channel should be fired.
    > From a senile talking moron Kudlow to smart but psychopatic Cramer
    > to greedy Cabrera. Santelli and that stupid-faced kneale these people
    > represents what is so bad about Wall street. And they are surprised
    > why there are seething anger in Main street
    Mar 07 04:00 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The CNBC crew carry on as if the banks and wall street had nothing to do with their own demise. It's all someone else's fault. Every one is doing it to wall street, wall street never did anything to anybody, they're innocent. Wall street and the jack asses on CNBC just don't get it. They don't get the fact that the American public hates wall street. Americans have no sympathy for wall street. Americans know that the wall street thieves gave the good ole USA the shaft. The wall street thieves sold out America for a buck. They screwed the America that enriched them so well, and the clowns on CNBC support the thieves. Santelli thinks non wall streeters are "loosers." That's the term he used, "loosers." Santelli is nothing more than bowel movement greed bag. He too would sell his country out for a buck, with a smile on his face and a "screw you American loosers" In China, they would execute these wall street thieves and banker scum for treason. I don't hear CNBC whinning over the tax payers money going to AIG, and the banks that fleeced America.
    Mar 07 10:18 PM | Link | Reply
  •  



    On Mar 05 03:36 PM ScottyEconomist wrote:

    > I hate Maria Bartiromo, let's rant on her

    I like her, she has that exotic look going on. Understand, I do not listen to her, I just sort of stare into those dreamy eyes...
    Mar 08 04:25 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    CNBC is not credible about markets (always too optimistic) or politics (hard right bias). Bears and Dems are always outnumbered on every panel discussion; and conservative hosts spout their drivel constantly, while liberal hosts keep their views to themselves.
    Mar 09 10:54 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Stock prognosticators serve only to make astrology seem relevant.
    Mar 09 06:40 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Cramer and the whole slew of them on CNBC are crooks. If you don't believe Cramer is a scum, watch him talk about how he manipulates the market. Put the scum in jail. Watch this video

    www.youtube.com/watch?...
    Mar 12 01:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    That was no ordinary shade of white...It was GE Halogen White


    On Mar 05 10:51 PM Sigmax wrote:

    > Did everyone see them all turn white when GE was vaporixzing on Wednesday?
    > Did they think all their negativity was't going to effect them?<br/>You
    > reap what you wrought!
    Mar 12 02:25 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Cramer's poor calls and reversals on his stance are understandable. Everyone makes a wrong call eventually. Usually they don't jump up and down and scream about them though.

    What is more laughable is the antics on Cramer and CNBC. If they want to be takes seriously really, stop being a circus and get on with the show. And stop whining, please. You're making me sick. Why not start crying while you are at it?

    By the way, there is also an alternative. It's called Bloomberg.
    Mar 12 05:22 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I'm asking Jim Cramer and NBC to stop whining not posters. Oh, and the good news is, he'll be on Jon Stewart tonight so we won't have to hear him cry after all.

    That is unless Jon Stewart says xxxx you to his face.
    Mar 12 05:47 AM | Link | Reply