Seeking Alpha

For those who have been following my outlook over the past two years, you know that I have been extremely bearish most of the time but have suffered from temporary insanity in trying to call interim or even ultimate bottoms. I had some success last year in doing so (certainly not with my horrible call last May!), but clearly this is a game that is rapidly losing participants. When I first realized we were in for a terrible bear market in the summer of 2007, I was worried that I didn't know how it might end. At the time, I was most concerned about housing and guessed that the end would be the nationalization of the GSEs. Nope, that wasn't it!

Over the past few months, as we have gotten by definition closer to the bottom both in time and in level, I have gained further clarity regarding how to tell that the economy is at a bottom, and it isn't anytime soon. I have identified three major signs to look for when anticipating an end to this depression:

  • Home prices will actually be cheap compared to median incomes (overshoot)
  • Savings rates will be approaching 10%
  • Debt to Asset levels will be lower in general for companies and significantly lower for Financial companies

It's really that simple and all about deleveraging, but it takes time and will look very ugly along the way. I am sure that there are other milestones, but these are certainly among them. Even when the bottom is in for the economy, the higher tax burden to pay for the "rescue" and continued consumer aversion to spending (is that possible in America?) will constrain growth for years to come most likely.

Stocks, though, are a tougher call. They will bottom earlier than the economy, and they may have fits and starts. Bear markets typically have the most powerful rallies of any type of market in terms of percentage moves up over a short period of time. I have suggested on a few occasions that the lows could occur late in the year in a range on the S&P 500 of 625-675 (1/17 blog) with an interim bottom in the March/April time-frame (we are there). I followed up that forecast with some additional support last month. I now want to add that I have additional insight into the actual level of the interim low I expect over the next few days or weeks:

S&P 500 at 666

Yes, wouldn't that be ironic? One hell of a terrible market bottoms at the sign of the Devil (click on chart to enlarge). Maybe the apocalypticists are right! The low on Friday was 666.8 - close enough for me! Maybe we have to close there. It isn't too far away...

666

I have written a lot of very negative articles in the past few months and several that suggested selling specific stocks, and every single one of these stocks appears to have priced in the issues that I saw. I am hard-pressed to recommend a sale at this level in any of them except maybe Wal-Mart (WMT), which has rallied back and could see a flight from quality. General Electric (GE), Weight Watchers (WTW), Kraft (KFT), and AT&T (T) may not merit "buys", but they sure seem overdone and likely to at least retrace some of their losses.

So, while I have given up beating the rally drum (at least publicly!), I do remain hopeful that we are due for a bounce. It sure seems like everyone has given up. I continue to suggest that the market can't erode faster than time, yet it does (we are down 25% though the year is only 18% complete, suggesting at this rate that it could go below zero). I do expect that we could face more pain later this year even if we do bounce here, but I sure appreciate the potential for a 666 low!

Disclosure: No position in any stock mentioned

Print this article with comments

This article has 15 comments:

  •  
    sp500 at 666, its possible. Whether it the low, nobody knows.
    Mar 09 08:12 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    You know You Mock God, it's not good. Did you ever think that all that's going on right now with our economy just might be a Judgement from God. Read the Bible how God took out nations because of their sins.
    Mar 09 08:24 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I think you read something into the article Alan did not intend. If making a reference to a biblical concept or passage is mocking God, then every Christian I know is guilty.


    On Mar 09 08:24 AM Cliff-1954 wrote:

    > You know You Mock God, it's not good. Did you ever think that all
    > that's going on right now with our economy just might be a Judgement
    > from God. Read the Bible how God took out nations because of their
    > sins.
    Mar 09 08:40 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Cliff 1954,

    You should not be offended by casual reference to "666" in the context of a seemingly damned event. Although you may surmise from his surname that Alan my be a Jew, I view positively anyone of any faith who calls to mind the Scriptures' warnings about powerful, centralized world government. Go back and study the passage in Revelation 13:16-18, which says,

    "Also it causes all, both small and great, both rich and poor, both free and slave, to be marked on the right hand or the forehead, so that no one can buy or sell unless he has the mark, that is, the name of the beast or the number of its name. This calls for wisdom: let the one who has understanding calculate the number of the beast, for it is the number of a man, and his number is 666.”

    Dave

    Mar 09 12:04 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Its true that "the higher tax burden to pay for the "rescue" and continued consumer aversion to spending (is that possible in America?) will constrain growth for years to come most likely."

    This is exactly what happened in the depression era. The DOW went from 380 to 40 over a several year period, not in a quick crash as most people think. An equivalent several year decline in the DOW will leave us a little below 2000. All this in spite of any government intervention - in fact the huge debt that we an incurring will actually help to cause this decline.
    Mar 09 12:13 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The Devil you say? We are in a negative directed bubble. What is different now is the negative bubble can't go to zero. If it does we are all in deep trouble; more so than now. So I believe the worst case senario (or a good buy point and market bottom) for the S&P500 is near 450.
    Mar 09 01:07 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I actually started talking about 666 back in November.

    trendandvalue.blogspot...

    (hope no one minds the self-promotion, but it seems relevant to the discussion...)

    as to whether it's a bottom... that's a little more tricky. my wave count speaks to a bounce here then a 5th wave decline. could be a non-confirming 5th, but too early to tell. a fall below 666 would target 616 and then 465.
    Mar 09 01:26 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Nice call - you should be right on gold too... The 666 came earlier than you or I projected. Probably means it won't hold ultimately...


    On Mar 09 01:26 PM Lucas199 wrote:

    > I actually started talking about 666 back in November.
    >
    > trendandvalue.blogspot...
    >
    >
    > (hope no one minds the self-promotion, but it seems relevant to the
    > discussion...)
    >
    > as to whether it's a bottom... that's a little more tricky. my wave
    > count speaks to a bounce here then a 5th wave decline. could be a
    > non-confirming 5th, but too early to tell. a fall below 666 would
    > target 616 and then 465.
    Mar 09 02:53 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    While S&P 666 would be cute for a bottom, S&P 500 makes more sense. The bearish, now not that bearish, view of $50 earnings in 2010 with a 10 multiple gives us S&P 500.

    Also, if we bottom at about 40-50% of GDP, which is typical among a massive market bottom (also given a lower GDP), that would give us around S&P 500.

    Then it's just a matter if things begin to stabilize or our government decides for tax hikes part II, stimulus part II, etc.
    Mar 09 04:21 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    thanks.

    yeah, if we get a bounce in stocks here, then maybe on the next decent Gold will get taken down too.

    in the short-term Gold needs to close below 900 soon to keep the reaction going.


    On Mar 09 02:53 PM Alan Brochstein wrote:

    > Nice call - you should be right on gold too... The 666 came earlier
    > than you or I projected. Probably means it won't hold ultimately...
    >
    Mar 09 04:22 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    You could be right on the ultimate low - I was just addressing a temporary one that I would hope might be the ultimate but wouldn't count on it. In a world of 7%-8% 30yr Corporate Bond Yields, 10PE on trough earnings (10% earnings yield) seems extremely cheap, but this has been a market of extremes...


    On Mar 09 04:21 PM Michael_Cohen wrote:

    > While S&P 666 would be cute for a bottom, S&P 500 makes more
    > sense. The bearish, now not that bearish, view of $50 earnings in
    > 2010 with a 10 multiple gives us S&P 500.
    >
    > Also, if we bottom at about 40-50% of GDP, which is typical among
    > a massive market bottom (also given a lower GDP), that would give
    > us around S&P 500.
    >
    > Then it's just a matter if things begin to stabilize or our government
    > decides for tax hikes part II, stimulus part II, etc.
    Mar 09 07:18 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    And GE closed at 6.66 on Thursday....
    Mar 10 01:40 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Very nice - didn't realize that one, though I did comment that day on my article from 12/27 that it was overdone at 6.40 (seekingalpha.com/autho...)



    On Mar 10 01:40 AM User 238208 wrote:

    > And GE closed at 6.66 on Thursday....
    Mar 10 10:22 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    The charts of Markets Indexes and of lots of stocks are not showing any good signs. The rally today(3/10) has nothing to do with reality.
    Support lines are not valid and prices are plummeting in the search of REAL support lines, which are probably deeper.......
    Dont kill the messenger and do not think I am a downer!!
    Everybody is tired of bearish news,and we all know that in the long run the trend is bullish, but for the next months,BEARS rule...............
    Mar 10 09:00 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This temporary low makes sense.. after all, devil-worshipping traders will be placing their buy limits at $666, effectively putting in a level of support.
    Mar 12 03:47 PM | Link | Reply