Seeking Alpha
About this author:

As the recession deepens, economic forces continue to drive consolidation in the retail industry, debt comes due and increasingly discerning consumers buckle down on discretionary spending, an analysis by 24/7 Wall Street predicts that a number of well-known brands are likely to disappear before the end of 2010.

To determine which brands are most likely at risk, 24/7 Wall Street examined 100 large brands it believes are in trouble and, for each, looked at public financial records, sales information, analyses from industry experts, the competitive landscape in each’s industry and the likelihood that a brand could be sold off in the case of parent-company financial trouble.

The analysis points to the most serious peril for the following 12 brands which, 24/7 Wall Street says are most likely to disappear by the end of 2010:

1. Budget rental cars (CAR): Though Budget’s parent company currently says it will continue to operate both the Avis and Budget brands, increasing debt problems, a weakening travel industry and intensifying competition will nonetheless cause the demise of the Budget brand, 24/7 Wall Street predicts.

2. Borders books (BGP): Declining sales, heavy losses and pressure from competitors Barnes & Noble (BKS) and Amazon (AMZN) - especially from new e-book readers - may prove too much for the brand when large amounts of debt come due in April 2010.

3. Crocs footwear (CROX): The decline in stock price from $72 per share in late 2007 to $2 today, ongoing financing issues, consumer belt-tightening and the end of a fad, leads to 24/7 Wall Street’s declaration that “Crocs won’t make it through the year.”

4. Saturn vehicles: As General Motors (GM) faces bankruptcy, 24/7 Wall Street said it will almost certainly shutter the brand, whose sales dropped 59% in the first quarter of 2009.

5. Esquire Magazine : While the Esquire brand is plagued with ad revenue declines and intense competition in the crowded men’s-magazine market, parent company Hearst faces problems on both the newspaper and magazine fronts and will not hesitate to close down underperforming brands such as this one to bolster its overall position.

6. Old Navy apparel: 24/7 Wall Street said that parent company Gap (GPS) - which currently markets the Gap, Old Navy and Banana Republic brands - is “a three-brand company living in a two-brand body” and cannot continue to sustain all three in the midst of steep, across-the-board sales declines. Old Navy, which is the weakest brand, will most likely not survive.

7. Architectural Digest Magazine: Amidst drastic cutbacks in high-end home sales and expensive redecorating, the once-healthy publication has lost 47% of its ad pages this year. Faced with other financial problems in its newspaper and magazine businesses, parent company Conde Nast will not be able to sustain the brand, according to 24/7 Wall Street.

8. Chrysler brand cars: Facing similar problems to GM as it teeters on the edge of bankruptcy, Chrylser LLC will not be able to support product design, manufacturing and marketing for a brand with many less sales than Dodge or Jeep as it gears up for restructuring.

9. Eddie Bauer (EBHI): Faced with declining sales, a stock price under $1, major debt problems and a CCC- rating, analysts say its lack of differentiation in the marketplace could prove the last straw. 24/7 Wall Street said it could be out of business by mid 2009.

10. Palm (PALM): A brand that 24/7 Wall Street says has been “at death’s door for some time,” faces life-threatening competition from RIM and Apple, and can only survive in the unlikely event that it can expand the smartphone market by increasing demand for its “Pre.” Dismal financial results and association with Sprint, the already-#3 US wireless carrier, will spell complete disaster.

11. AIG: The once-venerable insurance giant’s highly publicized financial problems, involvement in the financial crisis and subsequent bailout and indebtedness to the federal government, make it the “one large brand in America which almost everyone would like to see disappear,” according to 24/7 Wall Street. Because many of the company’s operating units do not bear the AIG name, they will continue to do business as they distance themselves from the “toxic” AIG parent brand, which eventually will go away.

12. United Air Lines (UAUA): As the travel industry faces unprecedented overcapacity in light of the recession, two of the large US carriers will soon need to merge to avoid bankruptcy. While it is not clear yet how such a consolidation will shake out, the stocks of UAL, American and US Air have plummeted. 24/7 Wall Street believes that United - the weakest of the carriers, soon faces a “merger,” which will most likely mean the end of the line for the brand.

Print this article with comments

This article has 44 comments:

  •  
    Seeking Alpha: best contributors have moved on... now it repeats others' content, only not as well as my Google reader.
    Apr 20 01:43 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Very useful article. As I prepare for the end of this rally (still, I imagine, months hence), I am on the look-out for faltering enterprises, and this was helpful.
    Apr 20 01:43 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Enjoyed the insight. Would like to see more about the others considered.
    Apr 20 04:28 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Oh no!

    Not 'Architectural Digest'!

    Where will I get my hard-hitting architectural news stories about California beachfront homes?

    I guess I'll just have to watch 'Cribs' or 'Entourage', but it's not the same.
    Apr 21 07:30 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I would add Kodak to the list
    Apr 21 08:57 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    This is HORRIBLE! Please write your congressperson and urge him/her to bailout these brands to preserve the American way of life for the children. These brands are too big...a part of our past to allow to fail. They are also pretty logos and neat ads that keep a lot of people in jobs.

    I only regret M-TV didn't make the list.

    I'm with Scissors, worst SA article evah.
    Apr 21 10:50 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    BeWhew! Hell is surely collecting its debts for the nation's financial gluttony of the last years.

    Yes indeed, Hot Richard, it's a darn shame that MTV is not going away!

    I knew a lot of brands were most likely going, but when you see it in writing, it drops a quite different bomb perspective on your brain!

    BeWhew!
    Apr 21 11:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    EBHI seems to b doing well. They just got there Term loans extended till 2010 so what’s the deal with this article?
    Apr 21 02:22 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "Well-known brands," yes. Venerable brands, hardly.

    We would have all been better off had the Gov. let Chrysler parish the first time. And good riddance to the others.

    America, let's stop spending so much money!!! Make AXP, MC and Visa the next to fold!!
    Apr 21 10:41 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    It warmed my heart to see those disgusting Crocs on the list. What will their shuffling, sloppy zombie-fans wear on their feet now?
    Apr 22 01:35 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    A great article. When you think about it, the sooner the cull occurs, the better. Absent Borders, Barnes & Noble may make a little money --- notice that Best Buy has done OK since Circuit City gave up the ghost. Similarly, UAL desperately needs to end its sorry life, and auction off the gates, a capacity shrink in airlines is long overdue, and will lead to more pricing power for the remaining carriers.

    Its the same story with Palm, Eddie Bauer, Chrysler & Saturn-- they all represent excess capacity which, once taken out of the system, will allow the survivors to operate more profitably.
    Apr 22 06:16 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    hmmm? a month before the Pre is to be released its going away? I dont think so. Palm built this market and has the experience to innovation to carry on. I also read somewhere that linux is going away too. I also heard that microsoft is dying a slow death. we'll see with windows 7 which is supposed to kick some new life into mac.

    rim and apple are losing people left and right because of unstable os problems. they are headed towads palm. look at the list of the storms and older iphones landing there that can be upgraded. i myself was going to get a storm until i saw a friend who says its crap.

    the reviewers, the video and developers are enough to let us know we, palm know we have a new innovator on our hands and it will continue to change with higher speeds, new os (free) upgrades. and yes i know sprint. well it has improved hills and valleys in the past years.

    this is not an end, its a beginning....
    Apr 22 08:28 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Add Motorola to the list
    Apr 22 12:52 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    In the two days since this article was written, CROX stock is up over 30%!

    It is more likely that 24/7 Wall Street won’t make it through the year.
    Apr 22 03:53 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Failures make other better managed companies do better.
    Apr 22 05:45 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    New York Times. K-Mart. The Street.com. Capital One.
    Apr 22 09:35 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    We've posted a response of sorts in a new article, The Top 12 Brands Likely to Survive:
    seekingalpha.com/insta...
    Apr 22 10:15 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    How can linux go away? It's an open source platform.

    Palm may have experience in the smartphone industry but it hasn't shown up to this point. Let's see how the Pre does.


    On Apr 22 08:28 AM TeckieGirl40 wrote:

    > hmmm? a month before the Pre is to be released its going away? I
    > dont think so. Palm built this market and has the experience to innovation
    > to carry on. I also read somewhere that linux is going away too.
    > I also heard that microsoft is dying a slow death. we'll see with
    > windows 7 which is supposed to kick some new life into mac.
    >
    > rim and apple are losing people left and right because of unstable
    > os problems. they are headed towads palm. look at the list of the
    > storms and older iphones landing there that can be upgraded. i myself
    > was going to get a storm until i saw a friend who says its crap.
    >
    >
    > the reviewers, the video and developers are enough to let us know
    > we, palm know we have a new innovator on our hands and it will continue
    > to change with higher speeds, new os (free) upgrades. and yes i
    > know sprint. well it has improved hills and valleys in the past
    > years.
    >
    > this is not an end, its a beginning....
    Apr 23 11:07 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I got no real worries on this one. Kohls is doing good now and they are by far better then old navy. And I was never really a Palm fan I prefer LG. It is sad about Borders though as they are a nice place to go and have a cup of coffee and sit back and read a book.
    Apr 23 02:39 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Whatever happened to people who could write in proper English?
    Apr 23 03:51 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    car stock is up 250% since this article..dosen't look like CAR -BUDGET is going anywere either


    On Apr 22 03:53 PM Suthrn wrote:

    > In the two days since this article was written, CROX stock is up
    > over 30%!
    >
    > It is more likely that 24/7 Wall Street won’t make it through the
    > year.
    Apr 25 01:09 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    "In the two days since this article was written, CROX stock is up over 30%! It is more likely that 24/7 Wall Street won’t make it through the year."

    This is exactly the kind of comment that is written by someone who is too focused on the day to day movements of a stock. Daily price action is meaningless. Where do you think the stock price would go the day they announced they were going bankrupt? That's the only day that matters.

    Enron was at $60/share... right before the stock tanked and went to $.04/share.


    On Apr 22 03:53 PM Suthrn wrote:

    > In the two days since this article was written, CROX stock is up
    > over 30%!
    >
    > It is more likely that 24/7 Wall Street won’t make it through the
    > year.
    Apr 25 02:47 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    UAL - proof that not only can the dead walk . . . they can Fly!
    Apr 25 05:10 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    On Apr 21 10:41 PM rich c wrote:


    >
    > America, let's stop spending so much money!!! Make AXP, MC and Visa
    > the next to fold!!


    Actually, MC and Visa handle both debit AND credit card transactions (IOW, they're working both _sides_ of the street. They should be fine.)

    I can't say the same for AXP, though. :(
    Apr 27 11:06 PM | Link | Reply
  •  



    On Apr 22 09:35 PM Dr. O wrote:

    > The Street.com.


    You really think Jimbo is going to let TheStreet.Com die?
    Apr 27 11:10 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Old Navy not suviving...please. Out of the 3 major brands, ON is the only one to have posted POSITIVE same store sales for 2 straight months now. They are the one keeping Gap, Inc same store sales from being as dismal as expected.
    May 13 10:32 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I agree with some of your predictions but I don't think the Old Navy brand will be going for a few more years and I think Banana Republic will be the brand to disappear with Gap focusing on keeping Old Navy. Chrysler will survive as a much smaller company, Penske has already saved the Saturn brand, AIG will survive under government control , Borders is good a possibility but I think Sears, Craftsman will most likely be a brand to disappear if not this year then next year. Some how I believe the Kenmore line will survive maybe spun off as it's own Corporation. Both Sears and K-Mart were on the brink of Bankruptcy and Sears only merged with K-mart in order to acquire the real estate holding which have taken a big hit this year and will continue to take a hit next year leaving both K-Mart and Sears as the next big retailers to fail. Kohl's will come out of the recession on the top.
    Jun 10 12:48 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I just cant imagine Old Navy dissapearring.. Sucks!
    Jun 17 03:44 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Good insight on Budget Rent A Car. They appear to be the weakest brand in that sector.
    Jun 17 04:20 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Potentially true unless these companies can obtain new financing and new ways to remake & save themselves. So, potentially wrong too.
    Jun 18 03:17 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    What ever happened to people who can spell.
    Jun 18 09:56 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I think this article is meant to drag down some good names by placing them next to junk.

    LONG PALM
    Jun 18 02:36 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    #4 - My understanding is that Roger Penske is buying the Saturn name and will continue manufacturing the vehicles.

    #8 - Chrysler is now going to have a stake owned by the government & UAW. No matter how poorly it performs, it'll get bailed out...AGAIN. It's not going anywhere.

    #9 - Good call Eddie Bauer filed for bankruptcy this week. Wish I'd shorted it!
    Jun 19 07:12 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    MAYBE THE GOVERNMENT COULD FOLD UP IT'S TENT AND GO AWAY
    Jun 19 07:38 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Didn't I read that Eddie Bauer might get bought out of bankruptcy by a PE group? Just because the company is filing bankruptcy doesn't mean the brand will disappear.
    Jun 19 10:19 AM | Link | Reply
  •  
    To dividendmachine:

    Cetin's negative rating is 5 times higher (lower?) than yours.

    I'm impressed that your dividend income is sufficient to support your family.

    Clearly, you've done the right things with your portfolio. Now, why not let us in on your 'secret.'

    Or will we need to subscribe to your investment magazine?
    Jun 19 12:11 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    You are correct. Eddie Bauer may be a slightly different, and smaller company, but it won't go away.

    On Jun 19 10:19 AM bcncv wrote:

    > Didn't I read that Eddie Bauer might get bought out of bankruptcy
    > by a PE group? Just because the company is filing bankruptcy doesn't
    > mean the brand will disappear.
    Jun 19 01:50 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    dividendmachine, SA is populated by angry, negative doom-n-gloomers. What can you expect?

    Often times the least popular comments here (especially if they are bashed by those end-of-the-world crowds) are the best ones for making money.
    Jun 19 09:11 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I've never understood the difference between Gap and Old Navy, as the product offering seems different shades of the same thing. Old Navy should go.
    Jun 19 10:58 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    If Eddie Bauer saw one of the retail stores today he would have a heart attack.
    Jun 20 02:46 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    fthe great strength of America is that this is the only p;ace where creative destruction happens doubletime. I wish yu'd add some TV shows to the list like "COPS."
    Jun 20 04:46 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I think you are wrong about GAP Inc. I think its three brand lines are actually well-differentiated and while the company may have some lean times ahead, I think it will survive. Furthermore, if you were to cut one of the three, Old Navy is not the one to cut in a down economy. Old Navy is affordable and resonably relevant.
    Jun 20 05:30 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    I'm hoping CNBC makes it a baker's dozen... they're pathetic shills for Immelt and the Street (with the exception of David Faber and perhaps one or two others).
    Jun 20 09:14 PM | Link | Reply
  •  
    Saturn is going to Penske...
    Jun 22 06:51 AM | Link | Reply