The Best Utilities For Dividends, Part 1

 |  Includes: FTR, MYRG, ORAN, WIN
by: Bennington Investment Ideas

Utility stocks have long been known as good dividend payers. Many utilities are regulated businesses with highly predictable returns and consistent track records of growth. This enables them to pay consistent and growing dividends. This article will take a broad look at the utility sector, as defined by, and identify some of the top dividend performers.

More than just electric power

The utility sector is actually a diverse sector. A simple way of thinking about it would be to consider all the companies that provide basic services that a home needs. This ranges from water to power to natural gas to communications. Some of these industries, most notably power and gas, are often highly regulated. However, there are a fair number of states that allow competition for electricity. This occurs at a retail level, while the distribution utility (e.g., company that manages the wires to your house) will typically remain a regulated monopoly. This is a natural monopoly since it would be silly and not cost effective to have more than one set of power lines going into a house. An example of a publicly traded retailer would be the Just Energy Group (NYSE:JE), which is based out of Canada. JE competes in key deregulated U.S. markets, including Texas and New York. Other important states are New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Massachusetts. The following table shows the key industries included in the Utility Sector:

Utility Industry Statistics
Industry Aggregate MC ($ Billions) Total Companies Companies Paying Dividend Percent Average Dividend Yield
Regional Wireline Comm. 11 7 4 57% 10.0%
Diversified Comm. Services 967 58 26 45% 4.6%
Electric Power 964 86 75 87% 3.9%
Non-US Wireline Comm. 28 5 4 80% 3.6%
Water Supply 39 15 13 87% 2.8%
Gas Distribution 171 29 27 93% 2.5%
Electrical Construction 11 5 2 40% 1.9%
National Wireline Comm. 7 4 2 50% 1.0%
Utility Sector 2198 209 153 73%


Click to enlarge

Source: Data provided by premium services. Author Calculations. Average dividend yield is calculated on a market capitalization weighted basis and includes companies that do not pay a dividend - their yield would be 0%.

The first observation is that Utilities are indeed a good place to look for dividends. Of the 209 companies in the sector, 73% offer some sort of dividend. The average dividend yield across all 209 companies is 4.1%. If you just look at dividend payers, that yield jumps to 4.4%. What this really says is that the 56 companies that do not pay dividends are actually quite small relative to the other companies. In fact, these companies only represent 8% of the aggregate market capitalization.

The second observation is that even within the Utility Sector, there is a wide range of dividend yields. The Regional Wireline Comm. companies offer a weighted average yield of 10.0%. This industry includes Frontier Communications (NASDAQ:FTR) with a 10% dividend yield and Windstream Corp. (NASDAQ:WIN) with a 11.8% yield. It does not actually include Centurylink Inc. (NYSE:CTL) despite their common grouping with FTR, WIN and CTL as wireline companies with suspiciously high dividend yields. groups them in the National Wireless Industry which is part of the Computer and Technology Sector, but of course that makes sense. The other 5 Regional Wireline Comm. companies are pretty small. Also showing the range of dividend yields is the stark difference between power and gas. While the electric utilities average a 3.9% dividend yield, the gas distribution utilities only offer an average of 2.5%. The following table shows the distribution between these two industries.

Click to enlarge

Source: Data provided by premium services. Author Calculations.

The above chart shows a slight skew for higher yields in the Electric Power Industry, despite a larger number of companies that don't pay dividends. It should also be noted that the average yield is based on a market capitalization weighting.

The third observation is that some of these sectors might not typically strike investors as utilities. For example, Electrical Construction, which includes companies like MYR Group Inc. (NASDAQ:MYRG) but excludes a Quanta Services Inc. (NYSE:PWR) seems to be further from utilities. Both MYRG and PWR provide contracting services to utilities where they are responsible for installation and maintenance of power lines at both the transmission and distribution level. Yahoo Finance lists PWR and MYRG as competitors. This also highlights the challenges in doing industry screens with data sets.

The fourth point is more of a note than an observation. The industry, Diversified Communication Services, is one of the larger industries, but reflects a range of foreign companies and tiny upstarts. These companies range from the more familiar to dividend investors like France Telecom (FTE) to a little more obscure Hickory Tech Corporation (HTCO), a $140 million market capitalization company in the U.S. providing communication services to retail customers.

Looking at Individual Companies

While the average yields across the industries are interesting, ultimate investment decisions are more for specific companies. The following table shows the top ten dividend yields in the sector among companies with a market capitalization above $500 million. I tend to exclude smaller market capitalization companies from my rankings due to potential liquidity issues and other considerations.

Top Ten Utility Dividend Yields
Ticker Name Last Close Market Cap ($ Millions) Yield Industry
FTE France Telecom S.A. $ 10.60 28,078 14.1% Diversified Comm. Services
WIN Windstream Corporation $ 8.45 4,990 12.6% Regional Wireline Comm.
FTR Frontier Communications Company $ 4.08 4,073 10.0% Regional Wireline Comm.
AESAY AES TIETE-ADR $ 9.21 1,819 9.6% Electric Power
CNSL Consolidated Communications Holdings, Inc. $ 18.08 721 8.8% Regional Wireline Comm.
DTEGY DEUTSCHE TELEKM $ 11.73 50,689 8.0% Diversified Comm. Services
TAC TransAlta Corporation $ 13.69 3,538 8.0% Electric Power
VIP VimpelCom Ltd. $ 11.27 18,350 7.9% Diversified Comm. Services
GDFZY GDF SUEZ-ADR $ 20.80 50,187 6.8% Electric Power
VIV Vivo Participacoes S.A. $ 26.25 29,486 6.5% Diversified Comm. Services
Click to enlarge

Source: Data provided by premium services. Author Calculations.

This is a starting point list for additional research on these companies. It should be noted that a fair number are foreign companies that might create other tax considerations. Furthermore, these yields do not necessarily mean that the stock is fairly valued. I've been bearish on FTR for a while and FTE has its challenges as well. The follow up article will provide a ranking with adjustments for growth and risk.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Additional disclosure: Disclaimer: This article is for informational and educational purposes only and shall not be construed to constitute investment advice. Nothing contained herein shall constitute a solicitation, recommendation or endorsement to buy or sell any security.