Much Ado About Nothing

 |  Includes: GLD
by: Rohit Savant

William Shakespeare titled his play this way to emphasize that it was a fluffy enjoyable romantic comedy: No King Lear. What we these days call a summer date flick.

This piece deals with a tempest in a teapot. Unfortunately, it is not a funny comedy. Investors falling prey to predatory marketing hype may experience a tragedy of losing money on bad investments.

Gold marketeers are bending over backward to find ways to try to scare investors into buying gold (NYSEARCA:GLD), into continuing to believe the dream based on an economic nightmare scenario that gold will rise and rise forever to unfathomable heights. The scare tactics used to center on an imminent collapse of the global financial system, or your local bank, failed, despite the best efforts of governments in the United States and Europe to help promote the idea of gold as a safe haven and portfolio diversifier. Trying to scare people into buying gold based on the threat of hyperinflation also has failed, for the most part. There are still some believers in the inflation thesis out there, but most people have realized that when a significant part of the population does not have jobs that pay them enough to buy things, inflationary pressures tend to remain bottled up.

So the marketeers keep trying. Their current spiel focuses on a non-existent threat of insufficient gold in Comex registered and eligible inventories to meet demand, and, related to that, fears of a recently emerged but not really significant backwardation in gold prices. The first part says the more than 63% plunge in registered gold inventories, from 2,103,155 ounces at the end of April to roughly 767,000 ounces on August 23, means that there is not enough gold in the Comex warehouses for market participants to take deliveries. Secondly, the recent $0.10 to $0.20 price backwardation from August 6, between thinly traded front months was cited as evidence of strong physical demand, to support the claims that there will be an imminent "default" of Comex paper gold. (The definition the marketeers use of a Comex default is neither legally nor market-wise accurate, but when you are making stuff up, facts like that do not seem to matter.)

These claims cannot be further from the truth. First, registered stocks account for less than a third of total Comex reported gold stocks. While registered stocks have fallen sharply, combined registered and eligible stocks declined at a far less dramatic pace of 12.0% from end of April to 7,013,256 ounces as of August 23. More importantly, monthly data from the Comex shows that there is a greater 'cover' of inventories as a percentage of open interest than there was historically. In July the percentage of open interest backed by total Comex gold inventories stood at 17.5%. While this percentage has been declining since reaching 28.0% in March 2012, stocks are equivalent to a vastly higher percentage of open interest than the period from January 1985 to April 2004, during which time the average was 12.0%. In fact, for much of the past decade the percentage of open interest covered by total stocks was much lower. It moved in a range of 6.1% - 16.8% between August 2000 and April 2004, and dipped to as low as 13.6% as recently as December 2007.

Click to enlarge

The same is true of deliveries relative to stocks, and deliveries relative to open interest. In both cases, the ratios show that there have been lower rates of deliveries in recent years compared to stocks and open interest than there was prior to 2005. The monthly ratio of deliveries relative to stocks averaged 7.1% from January to July, compared to 25.2% from January 1992 to December 2004. During the same period this year the monthly average ratio of deliveries to open interest was 1.47%, compared to 2.39% from January 1992 to December 2004. Any talk of delivery problems, shortages, and defaults is totally unfounded based on these historical ratios.

Click to enlarge

Click to enlarge

Futures contracts are financial instruments designed to allow commercial entities to hedge the price risks inherent in their businesses, by attracting investors and speculators who are willing to take on that price risk with the hope of making a profit by taking on this risk. Futures contracts are not designed for physical delivery, and they largely are not used in that fashion. This is true across all commodities, and not just gold and silver. In almost all commodities the delivery rates are very low, usually a tiny fraction of the total open interest. The concerns of an imminent shortage of deliverable stocks are uncalled for.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.