Black Swans, Bernanke Bubble And Nickel Markets

Includes: JJN
by: MetalMiner

By Lisa Reisman

Is nickel the sick man of today’s base metals markets?

Not so long ago, my colleague penned a piece on the nickel market with the apt description of it looking like a sick man. In most respects, that outlook remains intact. In fact, August had the most number of days of record LME nickel stocks.

However, a couple of recent developments have us wondering if a ‘black swan’ appears on the nickel horizon – or perhaps just a swan song?

Take, for example, this recent expose discussing what the New York Times calls the “Bernanke Bubble.” Others have referred to this bubble as a drug (we specifically speak of quantitative easing, QE2, 3, Operation Twist or whatever the term du jour one uses to describe the Fed’s monetary intervention). But the short of the long for nickel markets goes like this: many emerging markets have taken advantage of cheap U.S. loans to fund a range of projects from skyscrapers in Turkey, to steel production in India, or oil exploration in Brazil, according to the Times.

And as with all loans, one can’t borrow forever. These emerging market countries have to pay back their debts in dollars, yet they earn their revenues in their home countries, in home currencies – and all three currencies have depreciated in recent weeks.

So what does currency risk have to do with base metals markets, including nickel markets?

In short, the Times suggests the world faces major global currency risk. We’d concur.

The market “herd” has already left emerging markets in search of greater stability. All that remains includes debt repayment. That brings us to our next follow-on question – what happens if emerging markets default on their cheap USD loans?

Equity Markets Go Bust

And when markets go bust, commodities often move in the opposite direction and that suggests some potential price risk to the upside. However, commodities don’t always move in an opposite direction to stock markets (consider the 2008 bubble, in which both commodities and the stock market collapsed). But longer term, nickel history tells us that price spikes can occur against the backdrop of bad news.

Consider a 30-year historical look at nickel prices:

The price of nickel saw twin peaks. Source: Index Mundi

As our older readers lived through and may recall, the twin peaks back in 1987 and 1989 saw the Dow Jones Industrials fall a record 108 points. On Oct. 19, 1987, the Dow Jones Industrial average plunged 508 points, or 22.6 percent in one day. Prime rates rose during the summer of 1988, likely impacting the second shift up in prices and were subsequently lowered starting in June of 1989.

And though nickel remains in oversupply (China has mastered product substitution for primary nickel production), black swan events can still wreak havoc on markets, despite what underlying fundamentals and sick men might have you think.