Did you know that designers for the last 17 Academy Award winners for Best Visual Effects used Autodesk (ADSK) software? Since its introduction of AutoCAD in 1982, Autodesk continues to develop the broadest portfolio of state-of-the-art 3D software for the architecture/engineering/construction (AEC), manufacturing, and media and entertainment markets worldwide. These customers use Autodesk software to design, visualize, and simulate their ideas before they're ever built or created.
But the shifting sands of technology -- both the company's and customers' access to it -- have been creating some headwinds for this pioneer. Two weeks ago, Autodesk reported fiscal second-quarter 2014 non-GAAP earnings that beat the consensus. But the reaction among investors and analysts since has been mixed and the stock recently fell to a Zacks No. 5 Rank Strong Sell due to steeply falling EPS estimates, as the following chart displays:
A Change to the Business Model
While Autodesk's competitors sell advanced software for upward of $10,000, AutoCAD sells for only about $4,000, maintaining its foothold as the de facto standard with 85% market share. The software's price means AutoCAD is the only option for smaller firms -- a market the company's competitors have only recently begun to target, as we will see in a moment.
Autodesk has grown revenues since the recession by convincing customers to switch to a subscription model for AutoCAD software. In this model, customers get automatic updates and new features in exchange for a recurring fee. The model is much more profitable for Autodesk -- only 22% of Autodesk's customers buy software in this way, but they account for nearly half of the revenues. However, this transition was recently modified to include a move to offer more rental and usage-based pricing options. And this gave the company a lack of financial visibility, causing them to withdraw revenue and profit guidance for the next several quarters -- which, of course, left analysts no choice but to take their estimates down.
The news isn't all bad. It's really about how the company is altering strategy and responding to the shifting sands of technology, customer needs, and the competition. According to WikiInvest, "Autodesk is trying to increase the adoption of 'next-generation' 3D software products as compared to the 2D market. It recognizes that the 3-D segment would be a key driver for growth for the company in the future. This would definitely provide Autodesk with the opportunity to up-sell its massive 2-D installed base into higher average sales price (ASP) 3-D software and to boost growth."
3-D Competition Drivers
The "3-D printing" and design industry has become front-page news thanks to innovative companies like 3D Systems (DDD) and Stratasys (SSYS). You could say these guys have put the CAM back in CAD/CAM with "additive manufacturing" techniques that use constructive polymers to "assemble" new products, almost a molecule at a time.
And Autodesk not only must answer these innovation calls, they could see challenges to their own turf. 3D Systems recently acquired the cloud-based collaboration software Relevant Products/Services portal, TeamPlatform. This acquisition will help DDD in attracting AEC customers engaged in computer-aided design (CAD) and other 3D projects.
ADSK also faces competition in its conventional markets from UGS (Siemens) who is offering its 2-D software very competitively online. Again from WikiInvest: "UGS has indicated that there have been over 33,000 downloads of the Solid Edge 2-D drafting tool in the four months since its introduction. While the number of downloads does not pose any major threat, UGS's decision reflects a belief by some that basic 2-D tools will become commoditized and could be given away for free in an effort to help drive 3-D adoption."
Recent optimistic comments by analysts at Wedbush Securities confirm that Autodesk is still a force to be reckoned with in its home markets, even as it reinvents itself. They view the acceleration of ADSK's model change as a net positive, and even though they had to lower estimates into next year, they maintain their Outperform rating and 12-month price target of $43.
But until the earnings estimates stabilize and begin to rise, it might be best to stay on the sidelines because the stock will probably only get cheaper. Until then, investors interested in the future of Autodesk might want to check out the upcoming Inside 3D Printing Conference & Expo in San Jose, Calif., on Sept. 17-18. Joining Avi Reichental, president and CEO of 3D Systems, and S. Scott Crump, founder of Stratasys, will be Carl Bass, president and CEO of Autodesk, to deliver one of the conference's three keynote addresses. His future vision of the company might have a multidimensional effect on both investors and analysts.
Autodesk: Free Stock Analysis Report (email registration required)
3D Systems Corp.: Free Stock Analysis Report (email registration required)
Stratasys: Free Stock Analysis Report (email registration required)
ExOne: Free Stock Analysis Report (email registration required)