Seeking Alpha
About this author:
Submit
an article to

The Bureau of Economic Analysis announced Thursday that our economy might be growing again–for the first time since the second quarter of 2008 – and hence that we might be out of this recession. “Might” because it’s just their first (”advance”) estimate (the next update will come out late November), and “might” because the NBER business cycle dating committee won’t officially declare an end to the recession until well after it’s ended. Nevertheless, I must give kudos to Mark Zandi of Economy.com for having predicted back in the spring that the recession would end sometime in October; here’s an interview he gave on NPR’s Marketplace today.

Of course, even if the NBER eventually verifies that, yes, the recession is now over, it’s too early to “celebrate.” The economy recovering “in aggregate” doesn’t at all imply that the typical American family’s economic picture has brightened–particularly because the labor market is always the slowest to recover. And I’m still not sure the good news on the auto industry is really good news, because the Cash for Clunkers effect could be mostly temporary–see this by Dean Baker. (Although as a sister to a Ford (F) engineer, I’m really happy about the really positive news on the reliability of Ford vehicles that came out this week. Is it coincidence that they were the only company of Detroit’s Big Three that didn’t take a government bailout? I think not…)

Print this article
Comments
8
  •  
    The only thing that is growing is the size of gov't, gov't bailouts and gov't debt. To equate that with economic growth as the public suffers and mires in depression is hardly reason to celebraete or be optimistic about and "recovery".
    2009 Oct 30 11:27 AM Reply
  •  
    Fake money(fiat dollars), dishonest debt,transfer payments, bribes to consume(what people can neither truly afford or really need) : this is the stuff of Q3 GDP expansion. Was there ever an economy anywhere at any time built on this basis?
    Govt. Statistics can and do turn vapors into solids, mirages into oases, and lies into history but toxic vapors, mirages and lies can only destroy: they cannot create.

    A citizenry that eats vapors, chases mirages and believes lies inevitably finds itself hungry, exhausted and betrayed.
    2009 Oct 30 11:43 AM Reply
  •  
    It is not recovering in aggregate, it recovering in statistical abstract!
    2009 Oct 30 12:46 PM Reply
  •  
    This article was very short. Thanks!
    2009 Oct 30 04:11 PM Reply
  •  
    If its growing how come out of a family of five one has a job and when you try to seek employment else where its pointless. Barrak said women go to college freakin great forget about the soldiers who forgot to try and protect this country. Growth where the goverments pocket?
    2009 Oct 31 07:50 AM Reply
  •  
    I have owned a Ford Escort for nearly 20 years and I traded it in for a 09 Ford Focus. With the Ford Escort they recommended that I change my oil every 3,000 miles with my Ford Focus they recommend that I change my oil every 6,000 miles. Is this progress or what?

    By the way, I am more than satisfied with my Ford Focus.

    The dollar is accepted as legal tender by most central bankers: and, as I watch a squire climb a tree in my neighbor’s backyard, I know the central banks are the store house for excess dollars. I think that our economy is not experiencing the economic dislocations caused by too much currency because these central banks act as the black hole for excess dollars.

    I also think that national currencies being used as a global currency is an un-stainable way of conducting global trade, so the global currency system must be changed in order for global trade to function effectively.

    Your analysis does not take into consideration this global currency imbalance and, once the currency change does occur, the consequence to the US economy. So it is easy for you to say our economy is improving, when, in reality, our economy will imploded once the dollar is not longer accepted as global legal tender.
    2009 Oct 31 02:12 PM Reply
  •  
    Imagine that you are a car dealer that had a lot full of cars which sat unsold for nine months. Then cash for clunkers unloaded most of your inventory and saved your company from bankruptcy. Do you really think that dealer is going to restock as many cars as he started the year with? No way! At best, dealers will order some cars to replace some of the best sellers. But I believe most dealers will refrain from restocking in any meaningful way until they see the Main Street economy improving.
    2009 Oct 31 03:58 PM Reply
  •  
    UNLESS WELL PAYING MANUFACTURING JOBS ARE BROUGHT BACK THIS COUNTRY AND GIVE PEOPLE BUYING POWER, WE WILL NOT SEE ANY SIGNIFICANT GROWTH... CORPORATE AMERICA CAN NOT SEND OUR JOBS TO SLAVE LABOR COUNTRIES AND IMPORT THOSE PRODUCTS BACK TO THIS COUNTRY AND EXPECT THOSE WHO'S JOBS THEY HAVE TAKEN AWAY TO BE ABLE TO AFFORD THOSE PRODUCTS.
    2009 Oct 31 09:07 PM Reply