Seeking Alpha
About this author:
Submit
an article to

Aside from a reduction in the purchase of GSE debt from $200 billion to $175 billion, there were no substantive changes to the Federal Reserve's policy statement today after the central bank concluded two days of deliberation.

Naturally, the "freakishly low" short-term lending rate of between 0.0 and 0.25 percent will be maintained and, more importantly, the key phrase "for an extended period" was left intact.

For those of you not wearing a Fed decoder ring, this means, "Continue to speculate with borrowed money on any asset class that you think might go up in price because you've got nothing to fear from the central bank."

Of course, markets reacted as you might have expected - the dollar went down and just about everything else went up. Gold moved up about $6 an ounce within minutes.

This is shaping up to be a "recovery" in asset prices that looks a lot like the last one. The only thing is, if history is a guide, asset prices don't really start to move until they start raising interest rates - that seems to be many, many months away.

For those of you who might be interested in this sort of thing, the last two policy statements are shown side-by-side below.

Just a little light typing was required this month:

I'm probably not alone in thinking that this is going to end badly ... again.

Print this article
Comments
31
You are viewing the first 20 comments View all »
     
  • They're hoping the horse will talk.

    Two thieves are brought before a king. He says, "Take them out and hang them". One of them says, "Wait, your Majesty. If you give me a year I can get your horse to talk. I swear it." The king say, "OK, you have your chance."

    When they are alone again, the other thief says to the thief that said he can get the horse to talk, "What do you mean, you can get the horse to talk? You don't know anything about making horses talk." The first thief says, "A lot can happen in a year. The king might die, I might die, and who knows, maybe I can make the horse talk."
    2009 Nov 04 03:36 PM Reply
  •  
  • I don't think the FED can even get the horse to walk.
    2009 Nov 04 04:14 PM Reply
  •  
  • A horse is of course, a horse of course, unless the Fed endorses the horse.....
    2009 Nov 04 04:26 PM Reply
  •  
  • What do you expect, at fed rate 0-0.25 the Fed ran out of ammunition and not much can be done, and with trillions of $$ created, the printing press must stop now, otherwise we will witness the demise of the $ and the US economy forced into depression.
    2009 Nov 04 04:28 PM Reply
  •  
  • The Fed did the right thing. The economy is incredibly weak with massive excess capacity.

    The dumbest thing you could do is nip the recovery in the bud.
    2009 Nov 04 04:29 PM Reply
  •  
  • "Continue to speculate with borrowed money on any asset class that you think might go up in price because you've got nothing to fear from the central bank."

    Amen.
    2009 Nov 04 04:41 PM Reply
  •  
  • The Fed can only manipulate the markets so much. Eventually, natural market forces will overwhelm their ability to do so.

    The Fed is just building the dam higher and higher....but the concrete they're using is getting weaker and weaker.

    Let's just say you won't want to be here when the dam breaks....

    In my opinion, the right thing to do is the acknowledge what the true state of the economy is (i.e. miserable) and stop artificially propping it up and telling everyone that the recovery is underway. Once we own up to this, we can finally channel the stimulus is the right direction which is into the hands of small businesses and factories.....not big Wallstreet banks.


    On Nov 04 04:29 PM American in Paris wrote:

    > The Fed did the right thing. The economy is incredibly weak with
    > massive excess capacity.
    >
    > The dumbest thing you could do is nip the recovery in the bud.
    2009 Nov 04 05:03 PM Reply
  •  
  • Thank you for the side-by-side comparison!
    2009 Nov 04 05:19 PM Reply
  •  
  • I'm probably not alone in thinking that this is going to end badly ... again. ABSOLUTELY 100% CORRECT. Question is : How soon? It proves to me the Fed is "boxed in," and the Fed can't raise rates until tax receipts from jobs goes positive. Until such time Uncle Sam won't have the cash flow to pay treasury debt payments and meet other social security and defense obligations. My own belief is since trashing the dollar is equivalent to "protectionism" through a tariff in another form, why not just go all out and tell the China that the U.S. will no longer honor their U.S. debt holdings? Ditto for Japan. I know the implications of telling China and Japan to eat it are very political and drastic ... but so is paying a wheelbarrow of money for any imported goods into the U.S. Obama's union teams seem to think the weak dollar will bring jobs back to this country .... but any foreign company who sets up shop in the U.S. isn't going to invest much in anything for "sweat shop" labor. Those movie shots shown on CNBC of factories in China and Vietnam that look "state of the art" are just that ... ART. In fact, most factories in China are nothing more than a crummy building with a few tables for people to assemble whatever junk the world needs ... those are the type of manufacturing jobs ... I mean "junk assembly jobs" that will come to America.
    2009 Nov 04 05:49 PM Reply
  •  
  • Interest rate rises are the result of increasing asset values, not the cause.
    2009 Nov 04 06:54 PM Reply
  •  
  • You just gave me a thought. All these homeowners are walking away from their mortgages and stiffing the banks because they were supposedly conned into loans they couldn't afford. Well, maybe the same thing happened to Uncle Sam. China and Japan kept selling us stuff we couldn't afford but we didn't know it because they kept loaning us the money. This is predatory lending and we shouldn't be responsible for paying back loans we figured we could refinance later. Who knew the economy would tank? These were non recourse right?


    On Nov 04 05:49 PM ryanclarke wrote:

    > I know
    > the implications of telling China and Japan to eat it are very political
    > and drastic ... but so is paying a wheelbarrow of money for any imported
    > goods into the U.S. Obama's union teams seem to think the weak dollar
    > will bring jobs back to this country ....
    2009 Nov 04 07:20 PM Reply
  •  
  • Can you hear Bubble II forming?

    Lots of commercials encouraging credit card purchases. FHA and Fannie/Freddie pushing home buying at 3% down payment.

    The FED and the media are going to convince everyone that things are "normal" so then they will go back to spending what they don't have.

    The boys on Wall Street will go back to gambling with derivatives.

    The formerly "lagging" indicator of employment will surprise to the downside.

    And then....?
    2009 Nov 04 07:41 PM Reply
  •  
  • For years the U.S. government has had no luck in pressuring other nations, especially China, to allow their currencies to appreciate. Now, these currencies are naturally appreciating with the almost 0 interest rates from the U.S., but China remains somewhat stubborn on the issue still, the hope is now that their neighbors will also place pressure on them to allow their currency to rise. It's a shame that so many people must suffer economically just to get the dragon to play fair.
    2009 Nov 04 07:48 PM Reply
  •  
  • They didn't change a thing because we are so "LESS BAD" than before. Actually we are in worse bad and about to get worser!!

    They didn't change anything because NOTHING HAS CHANGED from a year ago. Actually, things are probably worse. There is no recovery to date, it's all BULLSH*T. If things were better they would have push rates a little bit. They are the same because you can't slow down something that IS NOT happening. And folks, if something was happening, explain to me why the unemployment numbers keep going up????

    More unemployed, more foreclosures, more bank failures, more uncertainty, more money printed.....more bad, less good!

    They are getting ready for major failures with their new to big to fail legislation - you wait and see!!! Citigroup, Bank of America, AIG, GM again, Chrysler, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, GE..........They will wipe out the bond holders and stock holders and these companies will be able to wipe billions off their books and it won't cost taxpayers a penny. Makes you wanna go out and buy some stock, don't it!!!!!!!

    You watch what happens in the next six months - NOTHING!!!! Hope and propaganda is your market friend. Watch your money!
    2009 Nov 04 09:43 PM Reply
  •  
  • This is the best slicing and dicing of the November 09 Fed statement I have seen so far.

    Perhaps we are now ready to take the next step.

    The Fed has made itself so irrelevant to the cause of financial responsibility (the only foundation of a true recovery) that the Fed simply doesn't matter anymore.

    I have observed for years that Fed announcement days have been treated as more important than the sum total of all company earnings statements. Why is that? Because the Fed's economic manipulations have been more important than the market's fundamentals since the inception of the Greenspan era.

    So... I now declare that era closed. Economic fundamentals matter again, and the Fed doesn't. The Fed is committed to financial speculation, period (let's not even mention the SEC), and those committed to economic growth (and savings) had better act on that knowledge.

    I have a license to speculate, but I don't wish to play that game. I'm sitting it out in gold until sanity returns - which it will, as it always does (absent the rise of totalitarianism - always a risk in extreme circumstances).

    When the Fed has been entirely discredited and the market again becomes subject to rational forces, I will re-enter the market. I just don't yet know when that will be. The abolition of the Fed might be a positive indicator, though!
    2009 Nov 04 10:02 PM Reply
  •  
  • As US keeps printing money, so are the euros. As USD devalues so are other major currencies. There's nothing wrong with low value of dollar, it just means US will stop spending less on foreign goods. The trend is your friend, don't fight the Fed as they always say. The dollar flood will bring asset prices like it or not.
    2009 Nov 04 10:22 PM Reply
  •  
  • I like the author's title because staying with a manipulated market status quo like we have is a concern. Although the stock market breathes a sigh of relief for now, it is only compounding the risk the market will bear when rates are forced to move up. The Federal Reserve is choosing to have an explosive tightening rather than a coordinated one when inflation rises.

    So on that note, when rates rise will the housing market really be better than it was before. I would generally say when mortgage rates hit 7-8% we will be quite a bit worse off and Fannie, Freddie, Ginnie, the Fed, Treasury, FDIC, and FHA will be in a world of trouble dealing with a gamut of bad bonds, foreclosed properties, and no demand. As we all learned not too long ago, persistently low interest rates only encourages those who can't afford assets to purchase them. Especially if they feel they can walk away and leave the lender out to hang when rates rise. And especially when the lender thinks it can walk away and leave the taxpayer out to dry.

    There is a big cause for concern indeed with no change from the Fed.
    2009 Nov 04 10:41 PM Reply
  •  
  • I am an engineer by training and not a seance. However, my inside tells me somehow there is something very sinister about this printing madness.

    How could one print itself to richness? Akin to the infamous pain killer drug VIOXX, the side effects will only show up years down the road. Then, it would be too late.

    Stay tuned. The market crash occurred in September 2008 and it is now November 2009. Where we are in now is only ACT I Scene II of the Play. As I gaze into the future, I see a new kind of economic hell too horrifying to describe.
    2009 Nov 04 10:59 PM Reply
  •  
  • Thanks for the side by side comparison. Very nice.

    The analysis was spot on as well, and we have a nice comment stream as well despite a couple of spammers thrown in.

    Now there's not much to do other than to hope & pray the patient begins to come out of his coma, realizing there are still significant problems to overcome even if that happens.
    2009 Nov 04 11:43 PM Reply
  •  
  • Why is everyone soooooooooooooo concerned with everything the central bank does?
    Leave threm alone.
    After all, they solved the crisis.

    RIGHT?
    2009 Nov 05 12:34 AM Reply
You've only read the first 20 comments