Seeking Alpha
About this author:
Submit
an article to

With pretty much all major indexes pointing toward a lower market open this morning, it's time to think about the scary reality of the that stocks are facing right now... Welcome to the failure zone:

The bears are starting to sway the market right now, and it looks like the rest of the week could see things significantly lower. The "Failure Zone" -- that area between the red lines in the chart above -- is the area to watch in the next 2-3 trading sessions.

For the last few months the market has been in a series of rally and slide cycles generally lasting around a month. At the beginning of November, as the S&P 500 bounced off trend channel support (the lower blue line in the chart), it looked like we were starting yet another month-long cycle with a price target of around 1150.

But stocks hit the brakes early in the week, giving already nervous investors even more reasons to turn bearish. So, should you be worried right now?

Probably not.

While seeing the S&P make it up to trend channel resistance (the upper blue line) before turning tail would have been an ideal situation from a technical point of view, with the current cycle top only around 4% shy of that target level, we can safely assume that the market's just following its own rules right now.

And with the 50-day moving average AND trend channel support sitting well above 1050 right now, the market has a double safety net to fall back on.

Prognosis: Expect a couple weeks of losses down to the strongest of those two support levels.

But what about that "Failure Zone" in the chart above? The Failure Zone is basically the area that determines where stocks are headed in the short term. If stocks manage to break out above the danger zone, we'll likely make it to that 1150 cycle target that we were hoping for at the beginning of the month. If stocks continue to push below it, then expect that move down to support to happen sooner rather than later.

Either way, it seems pretty clear that a pullback is in store in the next month...


Print this article
Comments
15
     
  • Mr. Elmerraji: This is a good article.

    I'm playing for a breach of the "failure zone."

    If I'm wrong, that will make me a failure.

    You, my friend, have much potential. Keep going.
    2009 Nov 20 02:11 PM Reply
  •  
  • Agree! My charts are telling me the same thing. Ten days ago I suggested that we had around 14 days to make the trigger move for the leg down. However, I believe we have a double top or H&S pattern forming and either could take us down to about 1020, to finish the patterns.Normally I would not look for a "perfect" pattern, but the rally has set continuous high and low points that exhibit a high degree of regularity, thus I am looking for an almost perfect pattern. Also, I believe the trend channel you show has been broken and we are really looking for the third point on a new trend line starting at 10/02. I expect that bottom trend line to be breached with the pattern completion.
    2009 Nov 20 03:27 PM Reply
  •  
  • Addition: If the H&S pattern completes we could be looking at 950 on the S&P.
    2009 Nov 20 03:29 PM Reply
  •  
  • In case you have not realized, technical and fundamental analysis has been out of the window since March 9 2009.

    The central banker and the Fed are busy pumping up the market with billions of tax payer money.

    This is a one way street my friends, there is no room for failure of the market. There may be drop in the market, but it will last for a short period and there would be no meaningful correction.

    We live in an era of separation between the main street from Wall street. Good luck trying to apply Technical and fundamental analysis on your investment.




    2009 Nov 20 04:12 PM Reply
  •  
  • This reminds me of the "obvious" pullback we were going to experience in early July once the H&S pattern was confirmed. Yet the market kept rallying.

    While the fundamentals are no doubt bleak, to say the least, I'd be very careful about shorting this market until there is true confirmation that the next leg down has truly begun.
    2009 Nov 20 04:40 PM Reply
  •  
  • Just to be clear, this article is in no way advocating shorting the market right now. It's saying that we should expect the rally and slide cycles of the last few months to continue at the moment -- the current part being the slide...

    In the longer term, the uptrend is still holding strong (see the chart above).
    2009 Nov 20 04:49 PM Reply
  •  
  • We will know within the next week or two if Spx will have a good chance to rally more into December and early January or we start melting down or just waste time doing nothing but defining a new trading range.

    Probabilities in that order.

    Highest probability is still the consolidation range of higher highs and higher lows that has formed since August is either a regular flat or a running flat. An A-B-C pattern with the C-wave down finalizing at 1029 for SnP500 which was the last low in Oct 2.

    Target for a normal flat will be 1150 to 1182 range while a running flat scenario can support a rally toward 1270 to 1330 range.

    My comment of Oct 31, 2009 still stands as is.

    Running Flat failure can result in 957 as the most obvious support for the bulls if panic selling happens on the weekly chart. Vertical selloff usually happens when the running flat results in traders and/or investors running out of patience with the prolonged period by which the stock or the market not being able to produce a vertical rally despite their repeated attempts to drive it higher.

    Timing is everything when this type of higher highs higher lows start forming on the daily chart after a potential bottom has been established such as the one we had in March 2009.

    So far; my analysis at 1020 when Spx first tested the daily 50ma had been correct and at 1030 area on Oct 31.

    Either we go vertical rally on the weekly chart or traders and investors will run out of patience at this critical time period.

    The 12 days of rally will require 12 to 18 days consolidation range preferably a shallow one and not too much time doing nothing with the run from 1029.37 of Oct 2 low to the last high of 1113.69 as the defining range. An attempted rally toward 1121 fibo extension resistance is also not out of the question but more likely will result in a headfake.

    1081 and 1071 are the most obvious fibonacci supports on the 60min chart with the current wavecount structure. The daily 20ma can also provide a viable support for the bulls.

    As long as the bulls can keep preventing a sudden death meltdown and/or a prolonged indecision trading range; we are good to go for 1150/82 range and if time permits 1270 to 1330 range before the next earnings season starts January 2010.

    A potential panic selloff after the re-entry below 1101 is the last best hope for the bears for their meltdown agenda.
    2009 Nov 20 06:48 PM Reply
  •  
  • Correction: the last low of 1029 was Nov 2 not Oct 2.
    2009 Nov 20 06:50 PM Reply
  •  
  • There was so much skeptism for this rally in August, September and October.

    This was attested by the low volume rallies and high volume selloffs and the "unusual" rallies of VIX in Sept and Oct during rally days. Investors were buying protections during rallies and selling as much stocks as they can during selloffs at that time period.

    At this stage; perma-bears should be running out of capital already with the repeated short squeezes they suffered if not many of them bankcrupt already.

    Perma-bulls, at the same time, will be running out of cash and holding lots of stocks and may run out of patience if a vertical rally does not happen soon. They may decide to sell and take as much profit as they can while the going is still fairly good if not great at all.

    Most TA's failed to recognize that the volume spikes during sell-offs are divergence signals. During normal lower high lower low corrections; high volume sell-offs sustain further downsides. From August to Oct, high volume sell-offs resulted in higher prices later on. Those are the divergence signals.

    Those undecided investors will be the deciding factor.

    They kept reducing their holdings and many of them too disgusted with themselves by now that the markets are still going up. They are holding too much cash for nothing and can't buy at lower prices since the stock market just simply and plainly kept on going up.

    Any sign of volume pickup during rallies will start a stampede of those left-behind investors too tired of waiting for the market to give them a reasonable 10 to 20 percent pullback or discount.

    If we get a strong stampede; then 1270 to 1330 not too far away.
    2009 Nov 20 07:50 PM Reply
  •  
  • The uptrends have been weaker on every 'hump'. RSI peak a little lower at each hump. Bigger indication that we were NOT going to make that upper trend line you have drawn
    2009 Nov 20 08:46 PM Reply
  •  
  • I think chartist thinking doesn't really work at this point ihn time. The real driver and real concern is how much government/Fed money will be dumped on the market. If the answer is less or if the fed reverses QE the market tanks. If the answer is a lot more the market stays bouant. It's all about dollar depreciation these days. How sad.
    2009 Nov 21 10:05 AM Reply
  •  
  • Moon: My observation is that chartist thinking does work. I do it all the time, in day trading, or a couple of days trading.

    It's the fundamentals that no longer count. MSM does.

    How crazy it is that, fundamentally speaking, as the FED QE's our economy into an abyss, the stock market is rising.

    The quirky reverse conundrum theory is that if the FED does the prudent thing, to understand one can not spend what one does not have, then the entire planet will drop into a depression.

    Catch 22.

    What to do? I say take the pain now. Rather than putting it off, exacerbating the future pain that will endure for the next generation.
    2009 Nov 21 10:35 AM Reply
  •  
  • Glad I didn't listen to you and your dismissal of TA. I'm up 30% since November 2008 - that's with two market bottoms - and up 90% since the March lows. All because I have followed the technicals of my holdings (pre- and post-Nov 2008) - and of the market - very, very closely.

    Given the fundamentals of our economy, it's a perfectly valid choice to stay in cash now. You won't make any money, but on the other hand, because you aren't losing any either.

    But if your choice was to short this market, in face of a clear technical uptrend, well, the losses you incurred are exactly what you asked for.

    Ignore TA and market direction at your own peril.


    On Nov 20 04:12 PM twitee wrote:

    > In case you have not realized, technical and fundamental analysis
    > has been out of the window since March 9 2009.
    >
    > The central banker and the Fed are busy pumping up the market with
    > billions of tax payer money.
    >
    > This is a one way street my friends, there is no room for failure
    > of the market. There may be drop in the market, but it will last
    > for a short period and there would be no meaningful correction.
    >
    >
    > We live in an era of separation between the main street from Wall
    > street. Good luck trying to apply Technical and fundamental analysis
    > on your investment.
    >
    >
    >
    >
    2009 Nov 21 11:06 AM Reply
  •  
  • you can fool most of the people most of the time...so they do...

    none of the problems have been fixed...

    it's a zombie rally in a zombie market...

    it's Japan only global...
    2009 Nov 21 11:08 AM Reply
  •  
  • I believe the period Elmerraji chose to chart the ternd (Aug-Nov) is too short to predict the future trend (even for the next week). He should have chosen, I believe, a period of a year and then compare the economic condition(s) that are similar to that anticipated for the forthcoming period. Of course, since a lot of traders use such charting, the market is dragged or buoyed depending on what most large traders do. But, since the %ge of volume traded by the traders compared to the total trading (which is likely to be fluctuating) is not likely to be greater, especially during the current portfolio adjustment time and a lot of money still sitting on the side lines, a pull-back, if any, would be small and used by big cats to get in. Thus, in my opinion, the market will be moving sideways more than in large ups or downs. Therefore, instead of making my decision solely based on market movement, I will just evaluate movement of stocks in my own portfolio and guide myself for further action, knowing that many stocks just do not follow the market trend religiously or to the same degree any how.
    2009 Nov 21 07:17 PM Reply