Written by Kyle Dennis
We strive to identify companies that we feel have the potential for both short- and long-term gains. This week we detail a company that we think could nearly double in value in the short term.
Enanta Pharmaceuticals (ENTA) is a biotechnology company that focuses on the development of small molecules to treat infectious diseases. The company had a fairly recent IPO that debuted on the market on March 21, 2013, at $14 per share and closed that day at $17.18 per share. The company has gained investor interest since its IPO and has begun to appreciate over the last few months. Enanta is one of the few IPOs that has products in late stages of development with upcoming data releases. With a strong financial positioning and good management, we believe Enanta is very undervalued.
Hepatitis C Virus
Enanta's main focus is developing therapies for the Hepatitis C virus (HCV). HCV is a virus that causes inflammation of the liver and is usually transmitted between people through bodily fluids. Although HCV usually is symptom-less at the beginning, the virus actually is a leading cause of chronic liver disease. This disease is quite serious, as it is the leading cause of liver death in the United States.
According to the CDC, about 350,000 people die every year from HCV-related liver diseases and about 3.2M people in the United States are chronically invested with HCV. In 2011, treatments for HCV grossed worldwide sales of over $3.5B and are expected to continue growing.
HCV drug resistance occurs very quickly with single component therapies used in the past such as ribavirin and PEG-interferon. Typically these drugs are combined with several types of inhibitors that stop the virus at the different levels. Enanta is combining several drugs together into a "cocktail" to try to develop a therapy that attacks HCV from all angles. Below are some of the components:
1. Protease Inhibitors - Stop HCV at viral protease (which is an enzyme), where protein chains are cleaved into smaller proteins. Protease inhibitors have been the most intensively studied due to the high efficacy against HCV.
2. NS5B Polymerase Inhibitors - Work by slowing down HCV at the site of replication. They attack the virus by slowing the replication of viral RNA (which holds all of the viral information) that is transcribed into DNA. This combination attacks assembly and replication of the virus. NS5A are the newest class of anti-HCV molecules.
3. Rabavirin - Is also combined in half of these cocktails being studied in trials. Ribavirin is an antiviral agent that has been around since the 1980s.
Enanta has an array of ongoing trials to treat HCV. The company's product furthest along in development is ABT-450, a protease inhibitor. ABT-450 is being studied in several clinical trials as a "cocktail." In May, Enanta received Breakthrough Therapy Designation for ABT-450.
(click to enlarge)
ABT-450 Phase IIb "Aviator" Trial Data
The company released Phase IIb data on April 23, 2013, for ABT-450 and presented several posters on the results. The data showed positive results for both safety and efficacy when compared to other HCV drugs such as sofosbuvir, a product from Gilead (NASDAQ:GILD) also in clinical trials.
In clinical trials, Sustained Viral Response (SVR) rates are used to show the percentage of patients who show no level of a virus in their blood during treatment. When the virus (which in ENTA/ABBV's case is Hepatitis C) is suppressed to undetectable levels for a certain time period after treatment, the patient is known to have this SVR. SVR12 measures this rate at 12 weeks, SVR24 at 24 weeks, etc. The 24 week rate is more typically used since newer therapies are much more potent and effective than traditional ones. When we look at SVR rates of patients in the ENTA/ABBV Aviator trial, we see that these cocktails have demonstrated extremely high SVR rates against genotype I Hepatitis C patients, which is the most common genotype in America. SVR rates of 96%-99% were achieved after 12 weeks in treatment-naive patients, or patients who are new to treatment. In addition, SVR rates of 90%-95% were seen in patients after 24 weeks of treatment, reinforcing the efficacy of these cocktails. It is also noteworthy that in sofosbuvir trials, a potential future competitor, around 90% of patients who have previously failed treatment reached an SVR at 12 weeks, falling short of Enanta's 93%.
Trials studying antivirals also tend to show the bulk of efficacy and safety by the end of phase II trials, and rarely make it through these trials while not eventually getting through phase III trials. This is the reason why Gilead's and ABBV/ENTA's therapies will almost certainly make it to market. Luckily, the HCV market is massive, and both therapies will be able to grab an almost equally sized piece of that market due to the fact that they are the first all oral, interferon-free options.
Gilead's Sofosbuvir is seen in as a sure approval and is expected to be approved on 12/8 of this year with an NDA submission before mid-year. With breakthrough designation of ABT-450 in May, now ABBV/ENTA could possibly make it to market just before sofosbuvir. Whichever therapy comes to market first will also be an impact on sales. Being the first all oral, interferon-free therapy for HCV is a highly anticipated event for doctors. Whichever therapy doctors can prescribe to their patients first may determine which one they will prescribe as their go-to choice.
Achillion Pharmaceuticals (ACHN) is one small-cap biotechnology company that is working on developing an HCV therapy. The company's leading drug candidate is sovaprevir, which is in Phase II clinical development. Recently, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced it is keeping a clinical hold on sovaprevir and the stock plummeted. Achillion was trading at over a $900M market cap earlier this year, however is now down to below $300M.
Although there are many HCV therapies in development, we think Enanta could see a valuation of over $600M before Phase III data release and near $900M-$1B after good results. Achillion provides a good measuring stick to compare how Enanta could be valued. With a current market cap around $370M, we believe Enanta has significant room to run.
Enanta has levered several partnerships that have put the company in good financial standing. In 2006, Enanta partnered with AbbVie (ABBV) for development of ABT-450. Upon signing, Enanta received $57.2M and the potential for $335M more in milestone payments. Thus far, Enanta has received $55M of the milestone payments. Additionally, the company will receive a royalty payment on future ABT-450 sales. As part of the agreement, AbbVie also agreed to pay for all costs of developing, marketing and commercializing ABT-450. These terms are quite bullish for Enanta because the burden of paying for the clinical trials is on AbbVie.
Enanta also has a similarly structured partnership with Novartis (NVS). In 2012, Novartis and Enanta partnered for the development of EDP-239. Enanta received $34.4M at signing and an additional $11M the following year when Phase I trials began. As the product progresses, Enanta is eligible to receive $395M in milestone payments and royalties on EDP-239 sales. Like AbbVie, Novartis has agreed to pay for all development, marketing and commercialization for EDP-239.
Enanta has a very near-term catalyst that we feel should bring attention to the company. The company will be releasing Phase III trial data from ABT-450 for HCV at the 64th Annual Meeting of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases (AASLD) on November 3, 2013. On October 1, 2013, the company released a Press Release that stated:
There will be an oral presentation at AASLD highlighting data from study M13-393 (PEARL-I). PEARL-I is an interferon-free and ribavirin-free 320-patient study being conducted by Abbvie to evaluate the once-daily, two-DAA regimen consisting of ABT-450/r + ABT-267 in GT-1b and GT-4 HCV patients. SVR4 rates were 100% (39/39) in GT-1b treatment-naïve patients and 87.9% (29/33) among prior null responders (observed data). SVR12 rates will be presented during an oral presentation of this data on November 3.
The company is going to present one oral presentation and five poster presentations at the meeting. Below are the names and times each presentation will be given.
With a full slate of presentations at this meeting, it seems like the company is projecting it has positive data to announce. We expect good news to rally the stock past 52-week highs as investors realize the potential of Enanta.
We believe Enanta could warrant a speculative run similar to that of several oncological companies such as Celldex Therapeutics (CLDX), which has been on a tear in 2013 as investors have been speculating just how successful the company could become if data remains positive, resulting in eventual FDA approval. Celldex is using antibodies and immunodulators to develop treatments for several unmet oncological needs. Its leading product candidates are rindopepimut, an immunotherapy that targets the tumor specific oncogene called EGFRvIII, and CDX-011, a fully-human monoclonal antibody-drug conjugate (ADC) that targets glycoprotein NMB (GPNMB).
We believe the above 100-day chart shows the bullish sentiment on Enanta that mirrors that of Celldex before it broke out. Speculation has been very strong on Celldex, as the stock has run from about $7 to over $37 so far this year. Enanta looks set up to begin its climb in anticipation of a data release in November. The stock is showing a flagging continuation/wedge pattern recently that usually indicates to us that the stock will climb higher than its previous run.
IPO Lockup and Insider Activity
When a company goes public, usually the insiders in that company are in tons of profit. In the past, it became a problem when a company went public because insiders would look to sell their stock immediately to lock in their massive gains. Although this is smart of the insiders, it kept IPOs from trading honestly. To stop this insider activity on IPOs, an IPO Lockup period was created that is usually agreed upon between the company and the underwriting investment bank. This IPO Lockup is usually a period of 90 to 180 days that keeps insiders of the company from selling their stock.
When a company completes this period of lockup, investors have found that many times insiders sell their stock and it makes for an easy shorting opportunity. Many traders look for these opportunities to make a quick buck. A selloff was expected by some investors to happen when Enanta came off lockup. An article by fellow Seeking Alpha contributor Don Dion detailed the thesis behind the potential lockup selloff.
However, the stock's sell off never came. Instead, the stock rallied and investors saw no selling by insiders. Enanta was able to raise $56M from the offering, and the stock has been bullish ever since, only selling off slightly on the debt ceiling "crisis" in D.C, never coming close to its IPO price of $14.
With Phase III data release approaching, this is a very telling and bullish action by insiders. By not selling, the insiders are showing faith in the data and are willing to take the risk alongside investors.
When a company shows this kind of bullishness, it also provides us with a good sense of where the company is heading. We believe this is a strong sign that the company is expecting positive data and for the stock to move much higher than current levels, notwithstanding the already positive data from prior clinical testing as mentioned prior in this article.
With the bullish sentiment by insiders and upcoming catalysts, and a very low market cap of around $370M, we believe Enanta is undervalued. The company has levered great deals with big pharmaceutical companies that allows it to develop its pipeline and generate revenue without taking the financial risk. The fact that Novartis and AbbVie would pay for all of the development, marketing and commercialization for Enanta's products is also very bullish.
Additionally, Zacks recently added Enanta to its number 1 ranked list, indicating a strong buy.
We believe the stock could reach $30 a share in the short term and could be a double in the long term.
Disclosure: I am long ENTA. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Additional disclosure: Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational and entertainment use only, and should not be construed as professional investment advice. They are my opinions only. Trading stocks is risky - always be sure to know and understand your risk tolerance. You can incur substantial financial losses in any trade or investment. Always do your own due diligence before buying and selling any stock, and/or consult with a licensed financial adviser.