Williams-Sonoma Inc. (NYSE:WSM)
Q4 2013 Earnings Conference Call
March 12, 2014, 05:00 PM ET
Gabrielle Rabinovitch - Director, Investor Relations
Laura Alber - Chief Executive Officer, President and Director
Julie Whalen - Chief Financial Officer and Executive Vice President
Patrick Connolly - Chief Marketing Officer, Executive Vice President and Director
Daniel Hofkin - William Blair
Matthew Fassler - Goldman Sachs
Matt McGinley - ISI Group
Gary Balter - Credit Suisse
Brad Thomas - KeyBanc Capital Markets
Aram Rubinson - Wolfe Research
Joe Feldman - Telsey Advisory Group
Welcome to the Williams-Sonoma, Incorporated fourth quarter and fiscal year 2013 earnings conference call. (Operator Instructions) I would now like to turn the call over to Gabrielle Rabinovitch, Director of Investor Relations, to discuss non-GAAP financial measures and forward-looking statements. Please go ahead.
Thank you, Ann. Good afternoon. This call should be considered in conjunction with the press release that we issued earlier today. Our earnings press release and this call contain non-GAAP financial measures that exclude the impact of unusual business events. A reconciliation of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures and our explanation of why these non-GAAP financial measures are useful are discussed in our release.
This call also contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, which address the financial condition, results of operations, business initiatives, trends, guidance, growth plans and prospects of the company in 2014 and beyond, and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from such forward-looking statements.
Please refer to the company's current press releases and SEC filings, including the most recent 10-Q, for more information on these risks and uncertainties. The company undertakes no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements to reflect events or circumstances that may arise after the date of this call.
I will now turn the conference call over to Laura Alber, our President and Chief Executive Officer, to discuss our fourth quarter and fiscal 2013 results and our outlook for fiscal 2014.
Thanks, Gabrielle. Good afternoon, and thank you for joining us. On the call with me today are Julie Whalen, our Chief Financial Officer; and Pat Connolly, our Chief Marketing Officer. I am proud to announce Williams-Sonoma, Inc.'s results this afternoon.
William-Sonoma, Inc. outperformed the recent holiday season, getting market share and demonstrating the structural advantage of our multi-brand, multi-channel business. Comparable brand revenues grew 10.4% and EPS reached $1.38 for the fourth quarter.
Strengthen our brands across the retail and direct channels with notable growth and our e-commerce business in conjunction with disciplined execution allowed our team to drive record operation results. We achieved these results against the backdrop of a shortened and challenging holiday shopping season.
Our fourth quarter completed a year of strong performance for Williams-Sonoma, Inc. with record revenue of $4,388 million, record non-GAAP operating income of $455 million and record non-GAAP EPS of $2.84.
At the beginning of last year, I outlined four key areas of focus. These priorities were to strengthen our brands, to lay the foundation for global expansion and new business development, to invest in our supply chain to reduce cost and improve service and to invest in the technologies and infrastructure underlying all these initiatives.
In 2013, we executed well against these four areas of our strategic plan. Our investments resulted in profitable growth and increased market leadership. We've kept our focus on our customers, the products and services that we offer and the way that we interact with our customers across multiple channels. As such, we have created a differentiated and highly relevant experience.
Highlights of our 2013 achievements include, first, the growth in our brands. Comparable brand revenue growth across our businesses in 2013 was 8.8% on top of 6.1% growth in 2012. Our exclusive products, great design, lifestyle positioning and accessible price points are allowing us to lead the market.
We love the entertaining cooking home furnishings and the furniture businesses. Our powerful brands offering exclusive products with high-touch services make decorating and entertaining, easy, fun and affordable. We're investing in store and online to provide the best experiences in retail for our customers.
Second, our global expansion and new business development. In addition to our multi-channel mindset and an organizational culture geared to multi-channel success, we are at our core entrepreneurs. Our global expansion and domestic new business opportunities are important growth vehicles. Our global vision is to serve our customers with the same high service, multi-channel model that has differentiated us in the United States.
In 2013, we reached a significant milestone by setting up the global infrastructure for our geographic expansion. In 2013, we entered Australia and United Kingdom with company-owned retail stores and fully-enabled e-commerce and distribution. We finished the year with six company on retail stores, five in Australia and one in London.
And we look forward to opening an additional eight retail locations in Australia in 2014 and continuing to build our e-commerce business. We also expanded our business in the Middle East with our franchise partner and secured a new franchise partner in Philippines.
In 2013, the global investments we made included capital expenditures to build out our stores, new stores systems capable of handling international currencies and payment types, and our new fully-integrated e-commerce platform that will allow us to have native sites in all the countries in which we will operate in-store. These are both capital and expense-related investments that we are incurring ahead of the revenues that they will generate.
The work we did in 2013 is laying a foundation for future growth. We are committed to a disciplined approach to global expansion and believe it represents a sizeable opportunity for long-term.
Our new businesses continue to develop and we are bringing new customers to our brands. Mark and Graham completed its first full year of business in 2013. We have continued to grow the offering, introducing new categories and selling great high quality gifts. Ranging from the whimsical to the sublime, our best sellers are across multiple categories.
And Rejuvenation serves as a general store of functional and beautiful goods for home improvement projects. In 2014, you will see continued expansion of Rejuvenation's product assortment and increased relevancy of its offerings.
Third, the further regionalization of our domestic supply chain. In 2013 we in-sourced furniture delivery hubs in three geographies and we further regionalized our retail fulfillment capabilities. We also expanded our U.S. upholstered furniture manufacturing operations, our personalization capabilities and we made progress in taking over our agent sourcing relations. By the end of this year, we expect to be directly sourcing almost all of our foreign purchases.
And fourth, we invest in the technology to support our multi-channel business. This fourth area is something I'd like to spend a little more time on today. Our technology investments are fundamental to support our topline momentum and create shareholder value for the long-term. The power of our brands in conjunction with our multi-channel excellence provides us with a competitive advantage.
In 2013, Williams-Sonoma, Inc.'s e-commerce revenue was $1,950 million with a three-year compounded annual growth rate approaching 18%. And overall in 2013, our direct channel represented 48% of net revenues.
Consumers have embraced the convenience and flexibility of shopping online. And the investments we have made in our brands and our user interface and our fulfillment infrastructure have enabled us to be one of the few retailers in our category to benefit from this shift online.
Offering relevant differentiated products and inspiring my sales experience as well as developing a community is as important online as it is in a store. Across channels we have focused on innovative, personalized, highly relevant shopping. Technology is redefining the customer experience and retailing has evolved and increasingly customers interact across channels. The investments we are making are allowing us to provide the best level of services to our customer.
As we look to 2014 and beyond, we are confident in the future of our company. All of our strategies are designed with a single-minded focus on our customers. We offer innovative exclusive products, a high-touch service model that helps our customers every step of the process, multi-channel excellence and an efficient vertically integrated supply chain. We believe that our proven execution and financial discipline will allow us to deliver sustainable returns and increased stockholder value.
Now, I'd like to spend a few moments discussing our brands. I'll begin with Williams-Sonoma. At about this time last year, we announced the appointment of Janet Hayes, as President of the Williams-Sonoma brand. We are proud of the progress her team has made in such a short time and are excited about the opportunities ahead of us in 2014.
In the Williams-Sonoma brand for fiscal year 2013, comparable brand revenues increased 1.5%. For the fourth quarter, comparable brand revenues increased 2.3%. The Williams-Sonoma brand executed its holiday strategy in an intensely competitive and promotional market.
Top-performing categories this holiday season included cutlery, bakeware and cookware. Our inspiring, well-designed relevant gift offerings and home-entertaining ideas made us top of mind from Thanksgiving to Christmas. Everything from our exclusive branded pizza maker to our proprietary holiday foods fueled seasonal sales.
The innovative products and units we introduced in January supported by refreshed floor sets and a wellness-focused early spring catalog were also highlights of the fourth quarter. Kitchens of real chefs, we designed a line of affordable, beautiful everyday essentials.
Our Open Kitchen line up with more than a 100 new SKUs features hardworking tableware, functional tools and durable cookware. Open Kitchen is accessible and relevant and early results show that it is driving new customers to the brand.
Excellence in retail execution also contributed to a successful holiday for the Williams-Sonoma brand. Inspirational visual merchandising and a fresh approach to our store experience, coupled with a better prepared and passionate field team drove meaningful improvement.
Our online and catalog marketing drives retail traffic as well as direct sales. And we saw a continued strength in our direct channel as we provided a high-touch, open online store for 24 hours a day during the compressed holiday season to compliment our in-store offering. We are pleased with our progress in the Williams-Sonoma brand during holiday 2013 and the learnings that we are taking into 2014.
Another key area of growth for the Williams-Sonoma brand in 2013 was the Williams-Sonoma Home Collection. In 2013, we introduced our new assortment of high-quality home furnishings and furniture and presented these products in an easy-to-shop, high-quality catalog format at an expanded assortment online.
Williams-Sonoma Home offers our customers exciting, beautiful stylish and differentiated aesthetics and the catalog showed three distinct collections each season last year. The results of the first year of this new strategy exceeded our expectations and we are building our product line as well as the marketing to support it. We believe Williams-Sonoma Home represents a meaningful opportunity for the company and we expect to expand the strategy significantly.
Next I'd like to discuss Pottery Barn. 2013 was a very successful year for Pottery Barn, as we executed against our strategy to be the leading specialty home furnishings retailer in the world. Key to this strategy is our accessible approach to decorating and our capabilities in product designs and lifestyle merchandising.
Across all channels our mission is to make decorating easy and fun. Our in-home service offering are competitive advantage. In Pottery Barn for fiscal year 2013 comparable brand revenues increased 10.4% on top on an increase of 8.5% for fiscal 2012, and 7.6% for fiscal 2011 for a three year stacked comp of more than 26%.
For the fourth quarter, comparable brand revenues increased 14.6%. The themes for Pottery Barn in the fourth quarter were decorating, entertaining and gift-giving. Key merchandise categories that drove our success were dining furniture, lighting, holiday decorating and gifting collections. This season our customers came to us, to decorate their homes and to make gift purchases. Our design and gift concierge services both in-home and in-store, made celebrating the holidays easier.
In 2014, we are excited to build on our momentum and the trends we saw in 2013. We're expanding our categories and our gift assortments. Refreshing and redecorating continues to be key priorities for our customer, and in 2014 we'll take our in-home services to the next level.
We believe that the Pottery Barn design point of view and value proposition has brought appeal, and that there is significant runway for growth ahead of us. We plan to broaden our assortment, offer greater aesthetic variation to our customers and make the process of buying furniture and home furnishings easier.
In the Pottery Barn Kids brand comparable brand revenues increased 7.8% in 2013, and for the fourth quarter comparable brand revenues increased 11.2%, following an increase of 7.7% in the fourth quarter of 2012. Fourth quarter strength was driven by our seasonal and gifting businesses as well as our furniture offerings. In addition, in Q4, our expanded nursery collections again exceeded our expectations.
For 2014, we're focused on delivering inspirational home furnishings and gifts for our Pottery Barn Kids customers. And as we look towards 2014, we see opportunity to grow the Pottery Barn Kids brand both specifically in our core business from home furnishings to furniture. We'll continue to introduce new collections that are high quality and extremely well priced.
We also believe we have a unique ability to create a differentiated customer service experience by offering our customers quicker and more consistent delivery of furniture. We'll build the product line concentrating on core categories with great quality, great design and great prices.
In the PBteen brand comparable brand revenues increased 14.1% in 2013, and for the fourth quarter comparable brand revenues increased 9.6%, following an increase of 6.4% in the fourth quarter of 2012. Our holiday season and PBteen was fueled by gift. Our big seasonal best exceeded our expectations and our textiles and furniture collections also delivered solid performance throughout the fourth quarter.
We're excited about the product line up in 2014 for teen and we will continue to offer high quality, trend right products that are exclusive. Over the past several years, we've learned how to effectively use collaborations to drive traffic and sales, and we have several new and impactful collaborations planned for 2014. Finally, we'll be extending our gifting programs to carry the momentum we felt coming out of holiday throughout the rest of the year.
Finally, I would like to discuss West Elm. West Elm had a record year with comp brand revenue growth of 17.4% on top of an increase of 17.4% for fiscal 2012, and 30.3% for fiscal 2011 for a three year stacked comp of more than 65%. West Elm exceeded the $0.5 billion milestone with $531 million in revenue in fiscal 2013. In the fourth quarter, comp brand revenues increased 18.3%, following an increase of 19.1% in the fourth quarter of 2012.
West Elm continues its fleet expansion at retail. In 2013, we opened 10 net new stores with three openings occurring in the fourth quarter. We are particularly pleased that our new stores are performing to our expectations and are driving new customers across channels.
Growth in the brand was broad-based across categories including furniture, textiles, decorative accessories and lighting. We continue to be confident in West Elm's ability to be a $1 billion-plus brand. With a strong multi-channel strategy that includes catalog, stores, online and the emerging social channel, West Elm is poised for continued growth in 2014 and beyond.
In 2014, West Elm has plans to open 12 new stores in seven new markets. The brands remains focused on creating a personalized and differentiated experience with three-key priorities, choice, community and consciousness.
Choice refers to the continued growth and evolution of West Elm's product assortment and menu of services. From an aesthetic perspective, we are seeing key trends in mid-century, industrial and decorative looks, and we are achieving growth in all categories of business. Handcrafted products and limited edition collections created in collaboration with independent artist continues to be a key differentiator among competitors.
In 2014, we'll continue to expand our assortment, particularly in lighting, furniture and textiles. West Elm's commitment to community remains a priority, as the brand continues to create engaging and brand-enriching experiences with classes, events and partnerships that bridge beyond in offline world.
Moving into 2014, West Elm is focused on working with partners of scale, continuing its successful partnership with Etsy and executing additional collaborations and partnerships as well. As a leader in social media, West Elm met major milestone with its social community in Q4 and is now one of the leading home furnishing brands in this space.
More importantly, West Elm fans and followers are engaged with the brand, driving content sharing, brand participation and sales via the social channels. Pinterest in particular continues to be the number one organic traffic driver to the West Elm website and Instagram photos from the West Elm community are now featured throughout the West Elm catalogs and on westelm.com.
In 2014, West Elm will continue fulfilling it's commitment to the conscience retail. Working with artisan groups around the world, West Elm is sourcing handcrafted products that differentiate the brand from other home furnishings retailers, particularly in their value market. In 2014, the brand will actively seek out additional ways to support and grow artisan businesses through projects such as adult literacy workshops and improve supply chain management.
In January, West Elm successfully introduced its first entirely handcrafted collaboration with New York-based fashion designer, Steven Alan. The collaboration was featured in publications, including the Wall Street Journal, Eldecor and New York Magazine. And in 2014, West Elm will make strides towards its Clinton Global Initiative commitment to action.
As we look forward to 2014 and beyond, West Elm has an exciting future ahead. Our strategy remains to profitably grow the brand and attract a broad base of customers, by offering choice in our products and services that will help customers express their own individual style and create a home that will connect with their story.
We will build community through connections with likeminded strangers, our crafters, collaborators, customers and associates and consciousness in everything we do, from handcrafted and local products to supply chain transparency and sustainability. The successful combination of these three factors is differentiating West Elm from its competition, and we remain confident in this brands ability to be a billion-plus business.
In summary, we're proud of the results, we achieved in 2013 in all of our brands and across our business initiatives. We are so fortunate to have a portfolio of brand that provide significant opportunities for growth and market share gains. We remain committed to customer service as our number one priority and we believe that there continues to be room for improvement.
We believe we have an opportunity to further demystify the decorating experience and help a larger group of customers achieve the home of their dreams. From cooking to entertaining to furnishing, we combine our passions for the businesses that we are in, with a focus on execution, disciplined decision making and state-of-the-art data analytics.
We are finding increasingly relative ways to market and serve customer both domestically and around the world, and we are very excited about the opportunities in the future. No one loves these categories more than we do, but we are not just category lover, we're supply chain experts and we are marketing maniacs. We apply data-driven analytics to drive relevance across all channels and we are extremely disciplined.
We accomplished what we said we are going to accomplish and achieved our objectives, growing sales, delivering operating margin expansion, growing earnings per share and returning excessive cash to stockholders. We have made progress against our long-term strategic growth initiative across our portfolio of brands both domestically and globally and we continue to prioritize the areas in which we are investing to maximize returns and enhance our competitive positioning.
Foundational to all of this, we have built one of the strongest teams in retail. And I would like to take a moment to congratulate our entire team for another successful year, and extend my sincere thanks to all of our customers and stockholders for their continued support.
And with that, I will turn the call over to Julie to review our financial results in detail.
Thank you, Laura, and good afternoon, everyone. Our results for Q4 and fiscal 2013 exceeded our expectations and reinforced the strength of our multi-brand, multi-channel model.
Before I walk you through the results in more detail, let me remind you that 2013 was a 52-week year as compared to the 2012 which was a 53-week year. The financial impact in 2013 of the loss of the 53rd week was approximately $70 million of revenues and $0.07 diluted earnings per share. All revenue and earnings per share growth will be discussed, excluding this impact from the loss of the 53rd week.
For the fourth quarter, net revenues grew to $1.466 billion or a year-over-year increase of 10% with comparable brand revenues increasing 10.4%. Net revenues in our direct-to-customer channel, of which approximately 92% came from e-commerce, grew 19% to $706 million or 48% of total company net revenues compared to 45% last year, a 300 basis point increase. Net revenues in our retails channel grew 2.7% to $760 million.
Total company operating margin for the fourth quarter was 14.8%. The 20 basis point decline of a record operating margin last year was due to our continued investment in our global operations and the loss of 53rd week.
The operating margin in the direct-to-customer channel increased 180 basis points to a record 24.7%, primarily driven by advertising leverage and lower general expenses. The retail channel operating margin decreased a 170 basis points to 17.2%, primarily driven by occupancy deleverage from the loss of 53rd week and the impact from our investments in global expansion as well as lower selling margins and employment deleverage, including investments in our global initiatives.
Corporate unallocated expenses increased 30 basis points to 6% of net revenues, primarily driven by higher employment costs and the deleverage from the loss of the 53rd week. Gross margin for the quarter was 40.6% versus 41.3% last year. The 70 basis points decline in gross margin resulted from lower selling margins and occupancy deleverage, primarily from the loss of the 53rd week and the investments in our global expansion. Occupancy costs were $149 million in the fourth quarter of 2013 versus $137 million in the fourth quarter of 2012.
SG&A decreased to 25.8% of revenue from 26.3% in the fourth quarter of 2012. This 50 basis point improvement was primarily related to reduction and other general expenses, including a reduction in year-over-year asset impairment as well as greater advertising efficiency, partially offset by higher employment costs, including the increased investments in our global expansion. These results drove diluted earnings per share growth of 8.7% to $1.38 in the fourth quarter.
For the fiscal year, net revenues increased to $4.388 billion or 10.5% with comparable brand revenues increasing 8.8%. By channel, net revenues in our direct-to-customer channel grew 15.6% to $2.115 billion or 48% of total company net revenues compared to 46% last year, a 200 basis point increase. Net revenues in our retail channel grew 6.2% to $2.273 billion.
Fiscal 2013 non-GAAP operating income increased 9% to $455 million. This resulted in a non-GAAP operating margin of 10.4%, a 10 basis point expansion versus last year, despite the financial impact from our continued investment in our global operations and the loss of the 53rd week.
A 130 basis point improvement in the direct-to-customer channel operating margins to 23.7% was partially offset by a 110 basis point decrease in the retail channel operating margin to 11% and a 10 basis point increase in corporate unallocated expenses. The 130 basis point improvement in the direct-to-customer channel operating margin was predominantly driven by advertising efficiencies.
The 110 basis points decrease in the retail channel operating margin was primarily driven by lower selling margins and occupancy deleverage, primarily from the capital investments in our business, the investments in our company-owned global expansion and the loss of the 53rd week in 2012. This was partially offset by the leverage of employment costs and lower general expenses.
The 10 basis points increase in corporate unallocated expenses was primarily driven by higher employment costs and the deleverage from the loss of the 53rd week. Gross margin for the year was 38.8% versus 39.4% last year. Gross margin was primarily driven by lower selling margins. Fiscal 2013 occupancy costs were $552 million versus $517 million in 2012.
Non-GAAP SG&A decreased 60 basis points to 28.5% of net revenues from 29.1% in 2012. This 60 basis point improvement was primarily related to greater advertising efficiency. In fiscal 2013, advertising expenses were $326 million or 7.4% of net revenues versus advertising expenses of $318 million or 7.9% of net revenues in 2012, a 50 basis point reduction.
This once again, demonstrates the flexibility of our operating model, as we use multiple levers such as advertising efficiency to drive revenue and operating profit growth. Non-GAAP diluted earnings per share for the fiscal year were $2.84, a 13.1% year-over-year increase.
Overall, we are very pleased with both the strength in the topline as well as our ability to drive operating margin expansion and growth in earnings per share, while absorbing the impact of our future growth investments and the loss of the 53rd week.
Moving to the balance sheet. Cash at the end of the year was $330 million versus $425 million last year. Cash provided by operating activities was $454 million, an increase of $90 million over last year. This cash flow allowed us to invest in the business by funding approximately $194 million in capital expenditures and to return more than $350 million to stockholders in the form of share repurchases of $239 million and dividends of $112 million.
We ended the year with $813 million in inventory, excluding the impact of the additional inventory in transit due to taking ownership earlier in the supply chain in 2013 versus 2012. Merchandise inventories increased by $108 million or 16.9%on a comparable basis.
This inventory growth was predominantly in our strongest growing brands Pottery Barn and West Elm as well as to support our growth opportunities. It was planned at this level to put us in a strong in-stock, inventory position as we enter 2014. Additionally, accounts payable increased by $146 million in 2013 versus 2012, due to higher inventory levels as well as the overall timing of payments.
Now, I would like to discuss our guidance for Q1 and fiscal year 2014. We expect 2014 to be another year of record revenues and earnings, while at the same time investing in our future growth. For first quarter of 2014, we expect to grow net revenues to a range of $920 million to $940 million with comparable brand revenue growth in the range of 4% to 6%.
Also in Q1, given the financial impact on the quarter of our capital investments in 2013, our continued investments in our global expansion as well as the investments in our supply chain infrastructure, including the opening of our new Dallas distribution center in the first half of 2014, we expect that our operating margin will be slightly below last year's operating margin rate and diluted earnings per share will be in the range of $0.41 to $0.44 per share.
On the year, we expect to grow net revenues to a range of $4.63 billion to $4.71 billion with comparable brand revenue growth in the range of 5% to 7%.
Operating margins are expected to be in the range of 10.2% to 10.4% and diluted earnings per share are expected to be in the range of $3.05 to $3.15 per share. We are also reiterating our three-year outlook for revenue and EPS growth that we discussed last March. With revenue projected to grow in the mid-to-high single-digits and EPS projected to grow in the low double-digits to mid-teens.
From a capital perspective, we are maintaining a balanced capital allocation strategy, investing in the business and returning cash to our stockholders through share repurchases and dividends. We believe this will provide the best returns for our stockholders over time.
As such, we expect our 2014 capital investments in the business to be in the range of $200 million to $220 million. In addition to our required annual investments in our retail fleet and IT infrastructure, we will be investing in our global expansion, constructing new stores predominantly in West Elm and the Pottery Barn brands, supporting our supply chain initiatives and further developing our e-commerce platform.
Last year, we announced a $750 million share repurchase program. We are now in the second year of this program with $511 million remaining. We expect to repurchase shares throughout this coming year. In addition, today, we announced a $0.02 or 6% increase in our quarterly dividend of $0.33 per share.
On a two year basis, this represents an increase of over 94%. This is the ninth dividend increase we have had since the inception of our dividend program in 2006, further demonstrating our commitment to returning excess cash to stockholders.
We believe that our track record of disciplined capital allocation together with our EPS growth of 46% over the past three years, demonstrate our ability to deliver returns to our stockholders. With the strength of our brands, our long-term growth initiatives and a culture of financial discipline, we remain committed to continuing this performance.
I would now like to open up the call for questions. Thank you.
(Operator Instructions) We'll take our first question from Daniel Hofkin from William Blair.
Daniel Hofkin - William Blair
Just a couple of questions maybe about the flow of the quarter, December versus January, and what you're seeing so far in the beginning of this year just from a business flow, weather standpoint if you will? And then just a clarification on your three-year plan, are you rolling that forward or are you saying that inclusive of what you did this past year as well as what you're expecting for 2014, kind of the three-year EPS growth that you're targeting?
So on the Christmas season, the holiday season, it feels like a long time ago already. We're already actually working on holiday '14. We had a strong holiday performance from the beginning of Black Friday, Cyber Monday started-off strong, gave us insight to what our customers are most focused on and carried through our January, our brands all of them in January bringing in new product and they have been well received by our customers.
With that said, the weather is certainly real. I typically don't like talking about the weather, because we're in retail and weather is a variable each season, but it did, it was worse than it was last year. In February, we did have an unusual amount of our stores closed, with more than seven times the number of closures this year as last year.
So it affects particularly the bricks-and-mortar channel, we're fortunate to have a developed e-commerce channel. And at this point, we don't expect a lasting impact because the weather usually evens out, but it certainly is real. As we look at the whole year, we see a lot of opportunities regardless of weather and we are building on the successes we saw last charismas and also the areas where we know we can make improvements.
And I'm going to get Julie, might you answer the question on EPS.
As far as the three year outlook, yes, that's reiterated what we already said for the existing three years, it's not rolling it out an additional year.
We'll take our next question from Matthew Fassler from Goldman Sachs.
Matthew Fassler - Goldman Sachs
My primary question relates to the comment you made on social as it relates to West Elm. I know that this is a business that reaches out to somewhat younger demographic perhaps than your other channels and perhaps that's why you're focusing on it more for social, but can you talk about just how commercial/social is for you, because if so you're one of the first to really speak about it as a meaningful driver? And also then talk about what kind of potential you might see for the other brands to capitalize on that channel as a revenue generator?
I think West Elm has really build social into the fabric as a brand from the very beginning. And they've won a lot of awards, particularly in their Pinterest category. I think they were awarded one of the top-ten sites on Pinterest, but all of the brands really are active there. In fact, Pottery Barn was the first brand ever to meet with Pinterest.
We met with them when they were in a tiny grange in Palo Alto and have been working with them on beta projects from the very beginning. It's a great source of referral traffic and it helps to expose the brand. And then we know that those people will come back when they're thinking to buy it.
So the initial conversion may be not as high as, say a paid search firm, because the customer is really coming to the site to discover the brand and then they come back later when they're in the market. But it's a very important part of what we do and we have real working council among all the social media heads of the brands. They get together every month and we share best practices. So we are advancing a social across all of our brands.
Matthew Fassler - Goldman Sachs
And is it accretive financially as you work on this and whether it can be scaled profitably?
We believe it will be yes.
We'll go next to Matt McGinley from ISI Group.
Matt McGinley - ISI Group
The first question is on the supply chain and the additional inventory that you took on. Does that normalize as you cycle through the course of the year? You had a big spike in the third quarter or do you continue to take on more categories throughout the course of the year? How should I think about that from free cash flow and a gross margin standpoint? Does that inventory investment ultimately translate that to helping gross margin?
Yes, so there is a couple of things going on there. First, we have, if you're looking at the balance sheet, there is sort of an artificial step up, because beginning I think it was Q2 of last year. We started reporting inventory earlier in the ownership process through the supply chain.
We started consolidating all of our inventory purchases with our Singapore entity for our global procurement. So that then gets sold to third-party entities and to our internal entities around the world. As a result of that that's just a timing change, we're taking ownership of that inventory earlier. So when we hit Q2 of this year that will be anniversaried.
As far as the level of the inventory that we have on the books outside of that on a comparable basis, we believe our inventory levels are strategic. They obviously help drive our Q4 results. And they position us well for entering into 2014. I think you saw that we had a step up in Q3 and look at our Q4 results.
So the biggest drivers of the inventory increase are primarily in our brands fueling our growth, which is Pottery Barn and West Elm with 15% and 18% comps in the fourth quarter alone. And we also have additional inventory this year that we didn't have last year to support our global expansion and new brands and across our core brands inventory increases really in our top-selling programs. Our inventory trend that has grown substantially and therefore its driving part of this increase, but it's going to help to improve in stock levels for our future sales.
So we think it's very strategic and any sort of extra inventory that there is a concern about it's already anticipated within our guidance for our gross margin.
Matt McGinley - ISI Group
And my second question is on the margin progression you had over the course of this year. You had a very good year in terms of margin expansion in DTC driven by all the improvements you talked about in the business. And then it was somewhat challenging in retail based on the promotion, international rollout, and then I guess likely in that 53rd week. Would you expect 2014 to have such a profound bifurcation in the margin trends based on higher expense or does that margin gap between the two segments narrow in 2014?
We don't really provide that kind of guidance by channel. But we do know as a retail channel, it does drive sales to our direct channel. So depending on where the customer is shopping in a particular time you're going to see fluctuation in our retail operating margin. And then as you mentioned a significant impact to retail operating margin from the upfront cost associated with our global expansion, which will continue into 2014.
With that said, we're always after making that retail profitability stronger, so we have long-term plans to improve that. Retail profitability is a complex issue and the retails channels integral to our strategy. So there is several things we are looking at. It's very, very important to our e-commerce traffic and building brand equity and obviously gets customers comp shopping online.
So some of the factors that are working in our favor are exclusive product design, of course, our cost advantages from the in-sourcing of our foreign agents and our regionalized supply chain that insures quick fulfillment to our customers and retail stores while mitigating freight cost.
On a flip side what's working against us is a persistent promotional environment in retail. And the high demand for the desirable Class A mall space, and of course, the fact that we believe in paying our associates for their performance. So we do believe that over time, we can maintain our operating profitability in our retail channel and keep our stores great is really important to us.
We'll go next to Gary Balter with Credit Suisse.
Gary Balter - Credit Suisse
They are all good, the divisions, but the one that was surprising was the Williams-Sonoma, and you talked Laura a little bit about kind of some of the steps you've taken. Could you go into a bit more detail about how that's turning around so well and bit of your outlook for 2014?
It was a successful holiday season, perhaps the most successful we've had in five years. We know that our strategy to bring in more exclusive products and to improve our retail execution and to refine our marketing model is working and that we can build on it. And also importantly, we know now that our results are really a function of our execution and the things we do.
It doesn't mean we can ignore the competition, there's a lot of it, from the biggest online retailer, flash sale entrance, traditional department stores and alike. We know that if we execute our strategies well, we're going to grow. And we have a lot of exclusive products coming through the pipeline across categories, very competitive. So I'm sorry not to share all those exciting things to come with you.
So it's both product but also execution at every level and especially in our retail stores. I think the last thing I'll say about it is that we've had much more cohesive marketing and that makes a big difference. We took the approach of testing and rolling ideas and we knew that not every test would work, but we have had many of them work and we're building on those areas.
And we are moving forward in a disciplined way and analyzing our results as we progress and it's an exciting time for the Williams-Sonoma brand. The team is motivated and empowered and we are really excited about the future, and believe that we are going to see gradual and sustained growth over time.
We'll take our next question from Brad Thomas from KeyBanc Capital Markets.
Brad Thomas - KeyBanc Capital Markets
I wanted to just follow-up about operating margins in general. I know as part of the three-year plan that you outlined last year, that as you move further back into the plan that there would be an opportunity to generate some leverage and some margin expansion. I know in the first half of this year there will be some unique investments. But how are you thinking about margins, as we move to this year and as we look out to even 2015?
So we've guided our operating margin for the year at the high-end to be in line with last year's new record operating margin, and it represents record operating income for our business. Can it be higher? Sure, over time. Right now, we are continuing to invest in the business and it's important to remember that we do plan to drive continued long-term profitable growth by investing in our business both domestically and globally. So we are maintaining significant earnings growth, while investing for the future to fulfill our vision to doubled the size of our revenues.
There is absolutely no structural reason why we can't raise our operating margin, as we did in 2013, but we are invested in our business and future growth and we are focused on operating margins dollars, which is going to be growth that's gradual and incremental over time. We're always focused on expanding our operating margin when possible and this will occur, which is factored within our three-year outlook.
We'll go next to Aram Rubinson from Wolfe Research.
Aram Rubinson - Wolfe Research
I've got two, if you could answer them both if not then one. Amazon is making a change to their prime membership, where they will be taking prices up by some amount that we don't yet know. For a company that's historically gotten, let's say, maybe some flack for charging for shipping as much as you do, you think that relieves a lot of the pressure or shifts kind of the marketing message that you'll be offering? And the second question has to do around customer metrics. For a lot of companies that are in e-commerce, they talk about new customer growth cost to acquire a lifetime value, I was wondering if there was any way you'd subjectively just give us a range around some of those measures?
We watch what everyone does. Our Mantra on shipping is that it needs to be easy to understand and competitive, but also that you can't ignore the difference in our business, shipping large scale furniture into peoples homes versus shipping apparel. And we have never believed that free shipping was a good idea in furniture, in particular, because when two people to come to deliver that sofa to your door, you know that it's not free.
And also the customer is very smart and that they will add up the price of the product plus the shipping and compare it to someone who may embed the shipping into the price, and so we look at total prices offered. And I think as people have to grow into a profit model, a lot of the online players, we're going to find free shipping on larger items is a very difficult business model.
So it doesn't surprise me. And at the same time, we're very different from the Amazon and that we're offering exclusive products in our brands and across all of them, including Williams-Sonoma. We're continuing to differentiate ourselves further from commoditized product that is offered elsewhere. And that's probably the best anecdote to this issue of people undercutting prices. I'm going to let Pat answer the customer metric question.
Aram, great question. I think new customers are absolutely essential to any business, and so we're constantly acquiring new customers. We acquire new customers at a profit. And I think as you point out, some analysts are beginning to write about how e-commerce pure plays are getting away with reporting rapid growth with little or no earnings. And we actually believe that ultimately the greatest stockholder value will accrue to those companies that can demonstrate both growth and a high rate of earnings.
And we've started six e-commerce businesses here and all of our e-commerce websites have been profitable within a matter of months, while growing rapidly. So we believe you can grow and be profitable at the same time. And we're one of the few retailers that actually brings out and shows their e-commerce operating contribution on their financial statements. So we can do both we believe.
We have time for one last question, from Joe Feldman with Telsey Advisory Group.
Joe Feldman - Telsey Advisory Group
I wanted to ask about the store plans, I know it's more focused on West Elm and you mentioned Pottery Barn too. But how are thinking about it in light of the strong e-commerce sales, because my understanding was also that because of the strong e-commerce maybe you wouldn't need as many stores as once thought years ago. And maybe just can you talk about the balance between the two?
We believe our stores are billboards for our brands and that they are the face of our brand and that the great service. And the in-store experience really supports our e-commerce sales and makes our customer confident in ordering from us, because they've been to our stores and they see our stores in their mind as they place the goods online, the orders online.
We have said before, we have a very disciplined real estate process. It's a constant process of looking at each market as leases come up to renewal and in come cases we expand remove, in other cases we close the store. And we're constantly testing retail formats in all of our brands. We're always trying to take the experience to a new level. So you're going to continue to see us do that and particularly where there is great landlords with exciting new projects, we want to be part of them, because we believe it's a key to the customer experience.
Joe Feldman - Telsey Advisory Group
And then, if I could ask another question. You mentioned on with the Pottery Barn brand expanding the in-home decorating part of the business. Could you give a little more color on that like what do you guys are thinking and what might be required in terms of staffing and presumably a bit more of people to go into homes or just if you could give a little more color on that?
We have been so fortunate to have such a strong field team that has embraced this initiative and they're really driving it. They are really rolling out more trainings and more people are being certified. We've brought more technology into the stores to help them serve the customers both in-store and also in the customer's home. And so we're going to continue to improve the tools we give them both the technology but also swatches you see in some of our stores, new design studious that we've put in.
And then we're also doing some pretty competitive things with our one-on-one interactions. We've always been very focused on the one-on-one interaction. It's incredibly difficult to do, because it's a continuous feedback group really between the database management, customer engagement strategy and execution. And we are really I think ahead of what most people can do, because while they may have good intention, they don't have the data analytics to know what the customer wants. To simply put, if we know who you are, we can market to you better and we know who you are.
Joe Feldman - Telsey Advisory Group
A similar kind of question, the Williams-Sonoma Home expansion, I guess what is giving you the confidence there and maybe you could give more color. Because I recall few year ago, you paired it back as separate stores, and I know now it's not really stores, but has there been a change or is it the way you're approaching it, the way you're marketing it. What's helping to drive that, the increase there?
We have a big aesthetic change. The goods are entirely different, high-end goods, but a much more casual approach to it. And really understanding who you're selling to, you're selling to a person who is buying a bigger home, I'm not someone who's pairing back, and that aesthetic is very different than what we offered before. We're using our knowledge from our other home furnishings brand to choose the products and also to put together compelling catalogs, and then also to optimize the website, because it's an online business, it's easier to maneuver.
And that is the way we have incubated most of our businesses here, I think all of them is to start online first and to really build the customer base and test new things, before we do anything at retail. We know the market is there with the higher-end goods and we can see through our response rates and our income per book that the customer is really responding, and with every mailing we are able to add more customers to our house file and expand our reach.
And that concludes our question-and-answer session for today. I will now turn the conference call back over to Ms. Alber for any additional or closing remarks.
Sure. Thank you all for joining us this afternoon. We really appreciate your time and your continued support. And we'll speak with you again in May.
Thank you. And that does conclude our conference call for today. We thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Copyright policy: All transcripts on this site are the copyright of Seeking Alpha. However, we view them as an important resource for bloggers and journalists, and are excited to contribute to the democratization of financial information on the Internet. (Until now investors have had to pay thousands of dollars in subscription fees for transcripts.) So our reproduction policy is as follows: You may quote up to 400 words of any transcript on the condition that you attribute the transcript to Seeking Alpha and either link to the original transcript or to www.SeekingAlpha.com. All other use is prohibited.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HERE IS A TEXTUAL REPRESENTATION OF THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S CONFERENCE CALL, CONFERENCE PRESENTATION OR OTHER AUDIO PRESENTATION, AND WHILE EFFORTS ARE MADE TO PROVIDE AN ACCURATE TRANSCRIPTION, THERE MAY BE MATERIAL ERRORS, OMISSIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE REPORTING OF THE SUBSTANCE OF THE AUDIO PRESENTATIONS. IN NO WAY DOES SEEKING ALPHA ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS MADE BASED UPON THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ON THIS WEB SITE OR IN ANY TRANSCRIPT. USERS ARE ADVISED TO REVIEW THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S AUDIO PRESENTATION ITSELF AND THE APPLICABLE COMPANY'S SEC FILINGS BEFORE MAKING ANY INVESTMENT OR OTHER DECISIONS.
If you have any additional questions about our online transcripts, please contact us at: firstname.lastname@example.org. Thank you!