As part of our process, we perform a rigorous discounted cash-flow methodology that dives into the true intrinsic worth of companies. In Alcoa's (NYSE:AA) case, we think the firm is fairly valued at $9 per share, below where the company is presently trading. However, with commodity producers such as Alcoa, the savvy investor will use a range of probable valuation outcomes in selecting his or her entry points. Commodity prices are just too volatile to not use a fair value range in equity analysis. Let's check out what this fair value range for Alcoa is in this article.
But first, a little background to help with the understanding of this article. At Valuentum, we think a comprehensive analysis of a firm's discounted cash-flow valuation, relative valuation versus industry peers, as well as an assessment of technical and momentum indicators is the best way to identify the most attractive stocks at the best time to buy. This process culminates in what we call our Valuentum Buying Index, which ranks stocks on a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being the best. Essentially, we're looking for firms that overlap investment methodologies, thereby revealing the greatest interest by investors (we like firms that fall in the center of the diagram below). This makes a lot of sense. Check out this video here.
If a company is undervalued both on a DCF and on a relative valuation basis and is showing improvement in technical and momentum indicators, it scores high on our scale. Alcoa posts a Valuentum Buying Index score of 6 on our scale, reflecting our 'fairly valued' DCF assessment of the firm, its neutral relative valuation versus peers, and bullish technicals. For relative value comparisons, we compare Alcoa to peers Allegheny Technologies (NYSE:ATI), Century Aluminum (NASDAQ:CENX), and Kaiser Aluminium (NASDAQ:KALU). In the spirit of transparency, we show how the performance of our Valuentum Buying Index has stacked up per underlying score (for holdings in the Best Ideas portfolio):
Our Report on Alcoa
• Alcoa's average return on invested capital has trailed its cost of capital during the past few years, indicating weakness in business fundamentals and an inability to earn economic profits through the course of the economic cycle. We think there are better quality firms out there.
• Alcoa is the world's leading producer of primary and fabricated aluminum, as well as the world's largest miner of bauxite and refiner of alumina. The company is diversified across a variety of end markets: aerospace, automotive, and packaging, to name a few.
• Alcoa's cash flow generation is about what we'd expect from an average company in our coverage universe. However, the firm's financial leverage is on the high side. If cash flows begin to falter, we'd grow more cautious on the firm's overall financial health.
• Alcoa's fundamental performance is heavily tied to volatile and unpredictable aluminum prices. The LME price for aluminum has oscillated between $1,200 to $3,200 per metric ton during the past five years alone -- a huge range.
Economic Profit Analysis
The best measure of a firm's ability to create value for shareholders is expressed by comparing its return on invested capital (NASDAQ:ROIC) with its weighted average cost of capital (OTC:WACC). The gap or difference between ROIC and WACC is called the firm's economic profit spread. Alcoa's 3-year historical return on invested capital (without goodwill) is 3.7%, which is below the estimate of its cost of capital of 9.8%. As such, we assign the firm a ValueCreation™ rating of POOR. In the chart below, we show the probable path of ROIC in the years ahead based on the estimated volatility of key drivers behind the measure. The solid grey line reflects the most likely outcome, in our opinion, and represents the scenario that results in our fair value estimate.
Cash Flow Analysis
Firms that generate a free cash flow margin (free cash flow divided by total revenue) above 5% are usually considered cash cows. Alcoa's free cash flow margin has averaged about 3.5% during the past 3 years. As such, we think the firm's cash flow generation is relatively MEDIUM. The free cash flow measure shown above is derived by taking cash flow from operations less capital expenditures and differs from enterprise free cash flow (FCFF), which we use in deriving our fair value estimate for the company. For more information on the differences between these two measures, please visit our website at Valuentum.com. At Alcoa, cash flow from operations decreased about 34% from levels registered two years ago, while capital expenditures expanded about 24% over the same time period.
Our discounted cash flow model indicates that Alcoa's shares are worth between $6.00 - $12.00 each. Shares have eclipsed the high end of this range. We wouldn't touch Alcoa at present. The margin of safety around our fair value estimate is driven by the firm's HIGH ValueRisk™ rating, which is derived from the historical volatility of key valuation drivers (think volatile aluminum pricing). We think savvy investors will always apply a rather large margin of safety around any commodity producers' fair value estimate.
Alcoa's estimated fair value of $9 per share represents a hefty price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio on last year's earnings and an implied EV/EBITDA multiple of about 9.9 times last year's EBITDA. Our model reflects a compound annual revenue growth rate of 1% during the next five years, a pace that is lower than the firm's 3-year historical compound annual growth rate of 8.7%. Our model reflects a 5-year projected average operating margin of 5.9%, which is above Alcoa's trailing 3-year average. Beyond year 5, we assume free cash flow will grow at an annual rate of 2.4% for the next 15 years and 3% in perpetuity. For Alcoa, we use a 9.8% weighted average cost of capital to discount future free cash flows.
Margin of Safety Analysis
Our discounted cash flow process values each firm on the basis of the present value of all future free cash flows. Although we estimate the firm's fair value at about $9 per share, every company has a range of probable fair values that's created by the uncertainty of key valuation drivers (like future revenue or earnings, for example). After all, if the future was known with certainty, we wouldn't see much volatility in the markets as stocks would trade precisely at their known fair values. Our ValueRisk™ rating sets the margin of safety or the fair value range we assign to each stock. In the graph below, we show this probable range of fair values for Alcoa. We think the firm is attractive below $6 per share (the green line), but quite expensive above $12 per share (the red line). The prices that fall along the yellow line, which includes our fair value estimate, represent a reasonable valuation for the firm, in our opinion.
Future Path of Fair Value
We estimate Alcoa's fair value at this point in time to be about $9 per share. As time passes, however, companies generate cash flow and pay out cash to shareholders in the form of dividends. The chart below compares the firm's current share price with the path of Alcoa's expected equity value per share over the next three years, assuming our long-term projections prove accurate. The range between the resulting downside fair value and upside fair value in Year 3 represents our best estimate of the value of the firm's shares three years hence. This range of potential outcomes is also subject to change over time, should our views on the firm's future cash flow potential change. The expected fair value of $12 per share in Year 3 represents our existing fair value per share of $9 increased at an annual rate of the firm's cost of equity less its dividend yield. The upside and downside ranges are derived in the same way, but from the upper and lower bounds of our fair value estimate range.
Pro Forma Financial Statements