Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT) shares have had a stellar 6 months, rallying almost 30% in that time in anticipation of an improving construction market in the US and stabilization in other key markets after a difficult year in 2013.
However, based on a number of factors I believe CAT shares are substantially overvalued at the current price; I estimate fair value, even with optimistic assumptions, is closer $70.
After adjusting for inventory impacts and non-recurring items, Q1 was weak
At face value, CAT Q1 results seemed encouraging. CAT reported flat revenue and EPS of $1.61 and $1.44 before/after restructuring costs, versus $1.31 in the year-ago quarter.
Almost half the EPS improvement of nearly 10% was attributable to the lower share
|FREE||SA PRO MEMBERS|
|IDEA GENERATOR||X||Exclusive access to 10 PRO ideas every day|
|INVESTING IDEAS LIBRARY||X||Exclusive access to PRO library of more than 15,000 ideas|
|SECTOR EXPERT NETWORK||X||Exclusive access to all sector experts for direct consultation|
|PERFORMANCE TRACKING||X||Track performance of all PRO stock ideas|
|PROFESSIONAL TOOLS||X||Professional Idea Filters to zero-in based on industry, market cap and more|