Stocks and Bonds Both Trading Near 52-Week Highs. Can They Both Be Right?

 |  Includes: AGG, IYY, SPY
by: TickerSense

Over the last few days, we’ve been witnessing a somewhat unique event in the markets, as both stocks (S&P 500) and bonds (US long bond future) have been trading at or near 52-week highs. Since 1982 there have been sixteen prior periods where this occurred.

Since strength in the stock market is generally regarded as a sign of a strong economy, while rallies in the bond market usually imply a weakening economy, investors are waiting for a resolution, or at least wondering who has it right - the bond guys or the stock guys. Conventional wisdom says that when it comes to the economy, the bond market usually has it right. We put this argument to the test and provided the results below.

While both asset classes have continued to gain in the weeks and months following prior occurrences, we found that following 100% of the prior occurrences where stocks and bonds hit 52-week highs, stocks have been higher six months later for an average gain of 8%. Bonds have averaged a gain of 4.1% and risen 75% of the time. 75% is pretty good, but stocks have been right 100%, which makes you wonder why so many people say the bond market usually has it right.

click to enlarge

stocks bonds near 52 week highs