- Since the present day market is continuing a pattern of schizophrenic behavior, we discuss the use of guideposts as a portfolio risk management tool.
- Guideposts were helpful in 2008 and during the 2010 "flash crash" in equities.
- Two short-term guideposts are discussed to monitor risk in the coming weeks.
Schizophrenic Market Still With Us
In a May 14 article, we discussed ways to reduce personal bias and increase investment flexibility. Since the present day market is continuing a pattern of schizophrenic behavior, we will discuss the use of guideposts as a portfolio risk management tool. Thursday, the news from Europe had a potentially mixed message; economically negative, but it could move the European Central Bank closer to taking some stimulative action. From The Wall Street Journal:
The euro-zone economy grew only slightly last quarter, suggesting that its convalescence from crisis remains troubled and putting added pressure on the European Central Bank to enact fresh stimulus measures. Economic activity in the 18-country currency zone rose by 0.8%, in annualized terms, in the first three months of 2014 compared with the previous quarter-well below economists' expectations.
Imagine If You Used Guideposts In 2008
We could have picked any number of charts, ratios, or indicators to use a guidepost implementation example. We chose the chart of the S&P 500 relative to being short the S&P 500 (NYSEARCA:SH). If we are to experience a sharp correction or enter a new bear market, it will begin to show up on the long vs. short chart. A simple visual inspection of the charts below tells us 2014 still looks better than ugly periods in 2008 and 2010. We will be watching the chart closely Friday, especially if the bears begin to roam again.
As we covered in detail in October 2013, a guidepost can be paired with an IF-THEN type approach to risk management:
If the 2014 chart above takes on a 2008 or 2010 look, then I will reduce my exposure to stocks by X%.
Is the long-short guidepost a foolproof way to help manage portfolio risk? No, but it can help us improve our odds of investment success. Since no indicator or guidepost is perfect, using numerous inputs to create "guidepost redundancy" is prudent, which is exactly what our market model does.
Understanding we are pushing the "boy who cried wolf" envelope relative to emphasizing the vulnerable technical state of the markets, it should be noted that markets that slice through a flat 50-day moving average often morph into corrections (right side of chart below). Therefore, we can use the S&P 500's 50-day as another guidepost. The good news is the price closed above the 50-day Thursday after dropping below it intraday (left side of chart below). The bad news is the flat look of the 2014 50-day; it is indicative of indecisive investors. A good rule of thumb: do not anticipate what will happen tomorrow; the market rarely cooperates.
The ongoing situation with Mr. Putin played a role in Thursday's pullback in equities, reminding us that it needs to remain on our risk-management radar. From Reuters:
Global equity markets fell on Thursday and safe-haven U.S. and German government bonds rose on fears over escalation of the crisis between Russia and Ukraine. lovak Prime Minister Robert Fico said Russia's Vladimir Putin told multiple European states that Moscow will not supply gas to Europe as of June 1 if Ukraine does not pay its bills. Moscow and Kiev have taken tentative steps to resolve this dispute.
We made no changes to our mix of stocks (NYSEARCA:SPY), bonds (NYSEARCA:TLT), and cash Thursday. However, we did review all accounts and build trade files for two possible defensive chess moves, just in case Friday morning gets hit with an ugly stick. TLT gave us something green to look at Thursday; it gained 0.80%.
Disclosure: I am long SPY, SH, TLT. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.