Seeking Alpha
Profile| Send Message|
( followers)  
As reported yesterday, January durable goods orders tumbled 7.8%.

New orders for U.S.-made durable goods fell by a much sharper-than-expected 7.8 percent in January as nondefense goods orders saw their biggest monthly decline ever, a government report showed on Tuesday. A steep drop in orders for Boeing Co. (NYSE:BA) airliners helped push down nondefense orders for durable goods, items meant to last three years or more.

Excluding volatile transportation orders, which are heavily skewed by aircraft, durable goods orders fell by 3.1 percent in January, their steepest drop since July 2005, the Commerce Department reported. That followed a downwardly revised gain of 2.8 percent in December.

Economists polled by Reuters had forecast that orders for durable goods would fall 2.5 percent, orders excluding transport would drop 0.2 percent and orders excluding defense goods would rise 0.3 percent.

Thus read the headline number, which combined with a selloff in China and a bad print or two to send the markets hazardously close to closing below the December closing low of 12,194. But we always argue that the month-to-month volatility, compounded by seasonal adjustments that may not always make sense, provide the headline number with little value. Instead, we prefer to look at year/year changes before seasonal adjustments are made.

Our analysis has provided a useful advance read, making us more cautious when all appeared well. So what does it tell us now?

Perhaps most importantly, the orders for Durable goods are not plummeting. In fact, it is possible that they are already recovering from the bottom placed in November for orders and December for shipments.


Excluding transportation, however, orders are still declining and likely to lead shipments lower. Particularly worrying are growing inventories, which have outpaced sales and order growth for five consecutive months.

durables ex-transport

Computers rebounded from a weak December that could have been explained either by tough comparisons to Christmas 2005 or to anticipation of Windows Vista. Problem with the latter interpretation: businesses were able to get Vista in November and account for the better part of spending on computers. Furthermore, the weak January rebound doesn’t exactly look like pent-up demand.


Net result, the market probably over-reacted to the negative headline, but has plenty of catching up to do for all the underreacting it has been doing the last few months.

Source: Delving Into Durables: Yesterday's Overreaction Doesn't Make up for Months of Underreacting