The age of Canadian oil and gas income and royalty trusts - popularly dubbed “Canroys” - is over. The era of dividend-paying Canadian energy stocks, however, is just beginning.
Plunging natural gas prices and the cost of converting from trusts to corporations wreaked havoc with sector dividends from late 2008 to early 2011. And yields fell further as rising energy prices pulled their stock prices higher.
Even after all that, however, several of the strongest former trusts still pay out 7%-plus. And after the market turmoil of the past month or so, weaker fare are pushing 10%.
Better, more than a few have again started to increase dividends. As they’ve gotten used to operating as corporations, they’ve used surprisingly abundant cash flow to pay down debt and build strong production profiles.
Investors are not only seeing higher cash flow, but share prices are starting to head higher as well. And as reliable energy supplies globally become increasingly scarce that trend increasingly has legs.
To date Canadian producer dividend growth has been almost entirely from those most heavily weighted to oil. It’s not hard to see why. The dramatic drop in natural gas prices since late 2005 is still an under-appreciated drag on profitability for those weighted to gas. Despite a decided shift in Canadian producers’ capital spending to liquids production in recent years, gas still accounts for half or more of the production of many producers.
In late 2005 natural gas prices in North America peaked in the high teens, as the combined destruction of hurricanes Katrina and Rita triggered outright shortages. Conventional wisdom was the rise in gas prices was here to stay and that the U.S. especially would rapidly become a major importer.
Companies like Cheniere Energy Inc (NYSEMKT:LNG) made multi-billion dollar bets building capacity to import liquefied natural gas (LNG). Meanwhile, activity boomed in Canada’s Western Sedimentary Basin and the country’s national champion Encana Corp (NYSE:ECA) invested heavily in exploiting “non-conventional” gas resources across the continent.
Then came arguably the most revolutionary development in the energy industry since the modern drill bit: Producers at last cracked the code to unlocking oil and gas reserves trapped in shale rock.
The process - known as hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking” - is still controversial in some places. And some state and local governments in the U.S. are starting to regulate the chemicals that are essentially mixed with water to pulverize rock and liberate the energy. But the result is that producers can now access these reserves at costs that are in many cases below the expense of developing North America’s remaining and dwindling “conventional” energy reserves. For more insight into hydraulic fracturing and how it is revolutionizing the U.S. natural gas industry, take a look at Elliott Gue’s InvestingDaily.com article, U.S. Shale Oil Plays.
The unconventional natural gas revolution has set what appears to be a new baseline price for natural gas of somewhere around USD4 per million British thermal units. Prices still rise in winter and the peak summer cooling season, and they drop in off-peak spring and fall when air conditioners and heaters run less. But every push above or below the range seems to be met with resistance and support, respectively. And investors continue to react to the latest inventory numbers as evidence the market is becoming either more or less oversupplied.
Meanwhile, market sentiment for natural gas the commodity and natural gas producers could hardly be worse. One reason is almost total inability of North American producers to export via liquefied natural gas. That’s in large part the legacy of so much import capacity being built.
But, as noted in the InvestingDaily.com article, Asian LNG Demand and North American Exports, there are some projects underway to remedy that. One is the Kitimat project off the British Columbia coast, which is supported by a number of producers, including EOG Resources (NYSE:EOG). None of them, however, are close to fruition. Until they are the North American natural gas market will remain a local one, following its own supply and demand fundamentals.
That has been a decided negative for gas producers in recent years, as shale production has surged and the market has appeared to slide into a semi-permanent state of oversupply. The glut could expand even further in coming months, should North American industrial sales (28% of total U.S. gas consumption) begin to contract. Meanwhile, cooling demand continues to lag this summer despite extreme heat in some areas. Power plants use about 30% of U.S. energy supplies, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.
Use of gas to generate electricity is on the rise throughout North America. Even without definitive regulation on carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from power plants in the US, North American gas is increasingly cheaper than coal, for which overseas demand is extremely robust. And burning gas also emits far fewer pollutants that are currently regulated, namely sulfur oxide, nitrogen oxide and mercury.
Coal currently accounts for roughly half of U.S. power generation and an even higher share of lower-cost baseload plants that run most or all of the time. But nearly 35% of plants were built more than 40 years ago. Every year they get older and less efficient to run - and closer to being shut permanently.
The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) under President Obama has been a reliable champion for nuclear energy, approving license extensions for most of the currently operating plants. And it’s strived to keep construction of a new generation of plants on track, even as the Fukushima-Daiichi accident in Japan has revved up opposition to all things nuclear. It now appears the NRC will require even fewer modifications to plants as a result of its post-Fukushima study than it did following the Sept 11, 2001, terror attacks.
Even with all of that, however, nuclear power’s share of U.S. electricity production is unlikely to rise much above its current range of 20% to 22%. Neither is renewable energy likely to make much of a dent, given the small size of projects. The largest wind farm in the U.S., for example, is Idaho Wind, partially owned by Atlantic Power Corp (NYSE:AT). It’s quite profitable for its owners but capacity is less than 200 megawatts and it runs 25% to 30% of the time. Contrast that with 1,000 megawatts-plus for a modest-sized coal plant.
That leaves natural gas-fired power to fill the breach as well as projected demand growth of at least 10% by 2020. Coupled with potential use of gas for fleet vehicles - a process slowly but surely taking shape across North America - it adds up to a lot more demand for natural gas in coming years, even as industrial demand recovers.
The problem is markets are notoriously impatient, and this is going to take time. Fortunately, there is one type of natural gas that’s already in a bull market: Natural gas liquids (NGLs).
NGLs are naturally occurring elements found in natural gas, including propane, butane and ethane. By separating - or “fractionating” - these elements, producers can sell them separately. Because some are substitutes for oil, they fetch a much higher price than “dry” gas.
Ethane, for example, is used as a building block for polymers such as polyethene. Polymers are key elements in the manufacturing of plastics. Availability of that NGL has made it very cheap to produce plastics in North America. It’s also created something of an export boom for it, particularly to Europe as Asia demands more of Saudi Arabia’s output.
Propane has long been used for home heating, particularly in rural areas not served by conventional natural gas pipelines. The NGL, however, is increasingly viewed for a much broader range of uses, including transportation and other industrial processes.
Butane’s uses for heating are also well known, particularly for campers and backpackers. But it also has a range of uses, including as a refrigerant, a feedstock for production of base petrochemicals in steam cracking, and as a propellant for sprays such as deodorants.
For much of their history NGLs have been an afterthought for producers, who were far more focused on oil and conventional natural gas. “NGLs on the Up and Up” shows why that’s no longer the case and explains why gas producers across the board are now focusing intently their output of NGLs.
At the same time natural gas prices have fallen sharply to flatten this year, NGLs have headed higher along with oil. And unlike dry gas, NGLs are ready for export once they’re separated. As a result they’re priced for the still-robust global oil market, rather than the landlocked and depressed dry gas market.
The ability to make lofty profits from NGLs has even made it worth companies’ while to scale up production of dry gas, just to get at the liquids that come along with it. To be sure, producers will do better if and when natural gas prices finally do start to pick up steam. But for now they’re seeing a strong new source of profits from “the other gas.”
To date much of the NGL production surge has come from the lower 48 US states. But over the past few quarters we’ve seen Canadian companies step up to the plate, particularly the former royalty trusts. And much of the activity has been in the Western Sedimentary Basin, once a primary drilling area for gas but which has been hurt greatly by competition from shale.
One problem producers have had getting NGLs to market has been processing and transportation ability. That log jam, however, is beginning to break up, as energy infrastructure companies like Keyera Corp. (OTC:KEYUF) and Pembina Pipeline Corp (OTC:PBNPF) step up their investment.
Oil-focused producers are still far more likely to raise dividends in coming months, just as they’ve been the only companies to boost them the past couple of years. But as NGLs become increasingly more important, even the laggards could start seeing growth, and that, in turn, will return share prices to the upside as well.
For an in-depth analysis of NGLs and their global impact, check out Elliott Gue’s excellent Seeking Alpha article, U.S. Natural Gas Liquids Reserves Could Reshape Global Economy for Years to Come.
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.