Claims that the gold bull market has ended are incorrect. One of the main causes of recently lower precious metals prices is the fact that the U.S. dollar has strengthened against the euro. Since the U.S. dollar is the world reserve currency, a stronger dollar lowers the U.S. dollar prices of global commodities. Also, financial flights to safety, e.g., out of the euro or European sovereign bonds, temporarily increase demand for U.S. dollars and U.S. Treasuries, strengthening the U.S. dollar against other currencies and lowering U.S. Treasury yields.
(Click charts to expand)
As the great American author and humorist Mark Twain famously said in 1887, “the report of my death was an exaggeration.” Most analysts believe that the euro project has failed, which is to state the obvious. Nonetheless, the euro isn’t dead until European banks, the European Central Bank (ECB) and European political leaders decide to end it. However, they will not let it end in the foreseeable future.
European sovereign defaults, if they were allowed to occur, would not require the European Monetary Union (EMU) to end, although the Treaty of Maastricht would have to be amended. What is far more important is that there is no way to allow sovereign defaults, or to break up the EMU, while also salvaging the euro-denominated debts of countries exiting the EMU. Breaking up the euro would impact fragile European banks and that is simply the end of the discussion. The United States led the way into the brave new too-big-to-fail world in 2008 and “too big to fail” remains the underlying policy of Western governments. Setting aside the resulting economic catastrophe and growing social and political chaos in Europe, the current situation will continue.
Gold closed under $1,600 U.S. per ounce during the week of December 11, leading to the COMEX options expiration of December 17. In terms of the gold price, there may be a risk of a disconnection between the Commodities Exchange (COMEX) futures prices and physical supply and demand outside of the futures market. The COMEX, which is operated by the CME Group (linked to the MF Global debacle), could experience a liquidity drain due to fears over market integrity, resulting in a net liquidation of futures contracts. The Commitments of Traders (COT) report for the week ended December 13, showed that speculative long positions fell by 8,284 contracts while short positions rose by 924 contracts. Future COT reports (e.g., for the week ending December 23) might show larger changes.
Those seeking to invest in precious metals are likely to prefer alternatives to futures contracts, such as physical bullion, Exchange Traded Funds or mining shares. If the futures price of gold remains depressed while physical demand remains robust, premiums over spot for physical metal will rise and, at some point, might re-price the metal outside of the COMEX, making the COMEX (and London Bullion Market Association) price less relevant.
The euro is set to fall further against the U.S. dollar. Political rhetoric in Europe has indicated a deflationary bias on the part of European Union leaders. German Chancellor Angela Merkel is said to have an absolute phobia of inflation. European Central Bank president, Mario Draghi and Italy's unelected banker-government chief, Mario Monti, are said to be “very German.” In fact, Germany has resisted calls for the ECB to launch a U.S. Federal Reserve-style program of buying sovereign bonds (so-called quantitative easing). However, as long as (a) the major European banks are not allowed to fail, and as long as (b) no European government is allowed (by Brussels and by its own major banks) to default, there is no path forward other than inflation.
- No possible combination of economic growth, taxes or budget cuts will allow Greece, Italy or Portugal to repay their debts.
- The sovereign debt of Greece, Italy, and Portugal, cannot be paid in euros at their current value.
- The economies of Greece, Italy, and Portugal, are simply too weak to support even reduced government spending.
- The governments of Greece, Italy, and Portugal, cannot service or repay their debt from tax revenue.
- So far, austerity measures and, in the case of Portugal, financial plunder have been ineffective to resolve the debt crisis.
- In the near term, the governments of Greece, Italy, and Portugal, must continue borrowing or fail.
- Deflation in the eurozone would crush European exports and, therefore, cause an economic recession.
- A new recession in Europe would definitely affect Germany and cause economic collapse in Greece, Italy, and Portugal.
- Ultimately, a significant percentage of European sovereign debt must be written down by banks as a loss.
- Sovereign defaults would trigger an unpredictable domino effect in OTC derivatives, probably resulting in a chain of bank failures.
- European bank failures caused by losses on sovereign bonds would trigger a new, and more severe, financial crisis, including a cascade of OTC derivatives liabilities.
The political rhetoric emanating from Europe is propaganda intended to (a) strengthen the euro, (b) support demand for European sovereign debt, (c) calm the bond market, and (d) hold the bond vigilante wolf pack at bay. Chancellor Merkel has said that the euro can be saved “if we have the necessary patience and endurance, if we do not let reversals get us down, if we consistently move toward a fiscal and stability union.” However, the time required, assuming that the goal is workable, will cost many billions of euros in lending or bailouts to otherwise bankrupt sovereigns and banks. The loans and bailouts (and U.S. dollar currency swap lines from the Federal Reserve) are not only inflationary but are purely temporary measures that do nothing to address the root causes of the problem.
The European Union leadership has no solution and is merely kicking the proverbial can down the road in the hope that economies will recover and that banks will become strong enough to survive the inevitable write-downs. In the mean time, inflation is a persistent reality induced by the very same policy makers who are simultaneously denouncing inflation.
As the saga of European sovereign debt drags on, financial markets, responding the dynamics of the U.S. dollar and the euro, will remain volatile while mercurial investors continue the so called “risk-on, risk-off” approach and while analysts and commentators continue to vacillate between alternatives that include sovereign defaults, the collapse of the euro, the failure of major European banks, successful interventions (although they will be both inflationary and temporary) and fear of deflation.
Under the circumstances, it is difficult to rationalize the end of the gold bull market. In fact, the higher earnings of producing gold miners have only recently begun to appear in financial results after having been frustrated by higher production costs and other factors.
Ignoring the compounding effects of momentum traders and short selling, mining shares have come under pressure from a planetary alignment of falling metals prices, extreme volatility, seasonal tax loss selling by investors (for Canadians, completed by December 23) and selling by funds, e.g., to cover redemptions. As a result, the shares of many companies are currently trading near 52-week lows and the spread between gold and gold mining stocks is highly significant.
Volatility means that mining stocks are periodically on sale and the drop in the prices of precious metals mining shares represents a value buying opportunity. A savvy strategy at the bottom might be to sell shares of less developed companies where there are losses, i.e., if tax losses are desirable, and to move the remainder into shares of more mature, higher-quality companies that have also fallen in price, but that can be expected to rebound vigorously.