Assuming the consumer experience won’t be adversely affected by the job cuts, this appears to be a good decision, from a shareholder perspective at least (some employees obviously might feel otherwise). Dell stock jumped more than $1 in after-hours trading to over $28 per share. The stock isn’t cheap enough to peak my interest, but I wanted to take a quick look and see what kind of upside investors should expect if the turnaround proves successful. The moves the company is making have a good chance to give the company some upside to currently low expectations this year and into 2008. But how much is the stock worth?
The reason I say Dell shares aren’t that cheap is based in part to where companies like HP and IBM (IBM) are trading (15x and 14x 2008 estimates, respectively). What kind of P/E should Dell get based on those comps? I would say 15 to 16 or thereabouts, but the good ol’ days of a 25 or 30 P/E for Dell seem to be over.
As far as earnings go, I decided to be pretty aggressive on this assumption, giving the company the benefit of the doubt regarding its new restructuring plan. Current forecasts call for about 2% revenue growth this year, followed by 6% in 2008. Changes at the company likely won’t produce results overnight, so a reacceleration in sales is likely to be more pronounced in 2008. Let’s assume they can grow sales 10% next year, to more than $64 billion.
Furthermore, let’s assume that Michael Dell can get the company back to peak operating and net income margins. Profits peaked at 6.4% of sales in 2005 before dropping to below 5% last year. Assuming 6.4% margins on $64.3 billion in sales for 2008, the company gets to earnings of $1.83 in 2008, well above current estimates of $1.49 per share. Assign a 16 P/E and the stock price would be above $29 per share. Even if we stretch the P/E to 18 (Dell used to trade at a premium when they were tops in the industry, so this is plausible if they regain their former glory) there is upside to $33 per share, about 16% above the current quote of $28 and change.
The bottom line: Dell stock could definitely keep rising if their turnaround efforts pay off in coming quarters, but make no mistake, this isn’t going to look like the 1990’s by any means.
Full Disclosure: No positions in any of the companies mentioned at the time of writing