Crash-Testing Abenomics

by: WisdomTree

By Jesper Koll

We remain convinced that Japanese risk assets-equities and real estate-are on track for a multi-year bull market. Our conviction is based on two essential pillars. The first one is our view that Japan's private sector has begun to focus on capital efficiency as a principal driver of corporate strategic focus. The second one is that Japanese policy makers are relentlessly focused on ending deflation and creating a pro-growth domestic macro-economic backdrop. Both pillars remain firmly in place, and we expect a decisive and united policy response from "Team Abe" to the deflationary threat posed by current global and domestic developments. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) is back in play to ease on January 28/29.

While Japan's corporate governance revolution is unlikely to be derailed by the current pullback in global markets, the current threat to Abenomics is very significant, in our view. Personally, I think Abenomics is now facing the most challenging "crash test" since its inception three years ago, because any national growth agenda is ultimately only as good as its success in building endogenous domestic forces strong enough to withstand a global deflationary shock.

Rising Deflation Risks

The current "crash test" consists of two major hurdles: economics and portfolio.

The economics is straightforward. It is the compounding deflationary pull from:

  • Falling global demand in general, China in particular;
  • Imported deflation from both yen strength and falling commodity prices; and
  • Domestic demand deflation forced by the negative wealth effect from falling asset prices. Note here that on January 12 TOPIX was down 17.7% from its August 2015 peak, while the S&P 500 was down "only" 9.9% from its May 2015 peak.

While it is difficult to model the exact impact of these compounding deflationary forces on Japan's inflation and growth outlook, sensitivity analysis suggests that the 5% appreciation of the yen and the fall in commodity prices alone have the power to push the Consumer Price Index (CPI) back into outright deflation (last reading of the national CPI was +0.3% year-over-year). It goes without saying that these are just the immediate first-round effects. Sustained global deflation momentum and yen appreciation would, before long, begin to cut into domestic employment and business investment plans. Clearly, downside risks to achieving any inflation target are rising.

Rising Portfolio Risks-Negative Returns for Abenomics Portfolio This Fiscal Year

The portfolio risks are even more significant, in my view. This is because the entire portfolio reallocation agenda of Abenomics-cut domestic bonds, raise domestic equities and non-yen exposure-is being undermined. Specifically, yen equities are now down 9.1% since the start of the Japanese fiscal year (April 1, 2015); in other words, we are on track for the first negative fiscal year for yen equities since 2011. It would also be the first year of yen appreciation since fiscal 2011. And to add insult to injury, the negative returns of risk assets is offset by a sharp rally in the perceived "risk-free" Japanese government bonds (JGBs), with 10-year yields falling from 40 basis points (bps) at the start of the fiscal year to 23 bps on January 12.

Asset Performance from a Japanese Perspective-Negative Abenomics Portfolio This Fiscal Year?
Click to enlarge

The message is loud and clear: Portfolio rebalancing has been a key part the Abenomics strategy, with the BOJ, the Government Pension Investment Fund (GPIF) and Japan Post all advocating and implementing significant increases in risk assets to "lead by example" and for private asset managers and retail investors to follow suit. If these new "national model portfolios" do indeed show negative returns in the current fiscal year-which concludes March 31, 2016-there are bound to be significant negative repercussions. After all, Team Abe has often insisted that the transmission of a new virtuous cycle from portfolio rebalancing into the real economy, fiscal sustainability, corporate innovation and positive wealth for consumers remains at the core of why Abenomics will work. Failure to perform risks incurring the wrath of critics from both the conservative side and the opposition.

Policy Response Coming-BOJ in Focus on January 28/29

In short, the current threat to Abenomics is very real, in our view. The good news is that Team Abe is not complacent. A strong and unified reflation policy response is likely to come soon. A key focus falls on the BOJ. We had originally expected added easing to come at the March 14 or the April 27 policy board meeting; but given the growing sense of urgency forced by the combination of accelerating global and domestic deflation risks and growing pressure on Team Abe to renew its pro-growth credentials, added BOJ stimulus is now in the cards for as early as the January 28/29 meeting. Indeed, assuming global and domestic asset price volatility remains high, failure to act decisively and proactively now could severely endanger Team Abe's pro-growth credibility, in our view.

Important Risks Related to this Article

Investments focused in Japan increase the impact of events and developments associated with the region, which can adversely affect performance.

Jesper Koll

Jesper Koll, CEO of WisdomTree Japan

Jesper Koll was appointed Chief Executive Officer of WisdomTree Japan on July 1, 2015. Over the past two decades Jesper has been consistently ranked as one of the top Japan strategists/economists, working as Chief Strategist and Head of Research for major U.S. investment banks J.P. Morgan and Merrill Lynch. His analysis and insights have earned him a position on several Japanese government advisory committees and Jesper is also one of the few non-Japanese members of the Keizai Doyukai, the Japan Association of Corporate Executives. He has written two books in Japanese, Towards a New Japanese Golden Age and The End of Heisei Deflation. After arriving in Japan in 1986 Jesper initially worked as an aide to a Member of Parliament. Jesper has a Masters degree from the School of Advanced and International Studies at Johns Hopkins University and was a research fellow at both Tokyo University and Kyoto University. He is a graduate of the Lester B. Pearson College of the Pacific.