Are We At A Fear Fatigue Juncture In The VIX?

by: Bruce Pile


Over the last couple of months, the VIX seems to have signaled an all-clear for stocks.

A larger time frame view, however, has the VIX agreeing with many of the better economic cycle monitors.

There is another fear index that is now sharply disagreeing with the outlook of the VIX.

We've all heard a steady drumbeat of negative developments about oil, bad debt, sluggish economies, blah, blah for well over a year now. And we've seen some unsettling rallies in the VIX associated with all this, but now the AAII Sentiment Survey has just a 24% bearish reading. The mean is about 30% with one standard deviation from the mean being 21%. So we are nearing this extreme level of lack of fear in the stock markets right now. The last time it was one standard deviation or more too low was back in November - when we should have been very afraid.

Have all these problems that have gradually edged the average value of the VIX up for many months now, magically gone away? No, if you bother to check, they are actually getting worse, as I have discussed in some of my recent articles. Are we in denial? Are we inebriated? Just what is our mental state?

The Information Discounting Ability Of The VIX

As for substance and keen analytical insight, we tend to think of the fear index like we think of a manic-depressive teenager in love. But can the behavior of the VIX really signal anything about the forthcoming behavior of the market? Looking at a VIX vs. SPX chart such as the one below from The Palantir Blog, one could surmise just that by simply paying attention to the slope of the VIX:

Click to enlarge

Here we see that the VIX will change to an up-slope in its base or support values between spikes as we approach important market tops. And what's really bizarre is that the VIX collapses out of that up-slope just before the really bad market thrashings begin. More on that later.

Even better than the stock market at foretelling recessions is the ECRI (Economic Cycles Research Institute) Weekly Lead Index, which looks at the economic cycle components that turn before the rest. This index has a remarkable record if you just look at the trends it makes:

Click to enlarge

The trend breaks come months before the stock market turns and the recessions. How do these trend changes compare with the above VIX trend changes? Since the VIX wasn't invented until 1993, we will just look at the last two great bear turns - 2000 and 2007:

Click to enlarge

The VIX changes in trend preempt even the ECRI changes in trend, suggesting an even better economic information discounting ability than one of the most respected economic predictors around.

So Why The Big Collapse In The VIX Recently To Historic Lows?

Why do we typically see a collapse of the VIX below its long, slow uptrend just in front of the main collapse in a bear stock market as mentioned above? The only thing I can figure is a kind of fear fatigue where investors know there are serious problems developing for the market, but they are just tired of hearing about them. They maybe just start viewing it all as the wall of worry that seems to permeate markets most of the time. That justifies investing in bull markets, which climb the proverbial wall of worry, but it also seems to be a repeating pattern in approaching bear markets. We are seeing a repeat of the VIX reaction to the approach of the 2002 market collapse and the 2008 episode:

Click to enlarge

The upward sloping support line shows a gradually increasing unease with investors over a period of many months, then a massive VIX spike into the classic pennant formation. Then there follows a break of the pennant back down to the more gradual encroachment of fear. Here the market becomes tranquil, sentiment is rosy, and investors are tired of hearing "wolf." This sounds a lot like the present.

But this appears to be the danger point when a turn back up in fear begins. In 2002 and 2008, there is one more fade of the VIX back to the support trend before the major stock collapse begins. We are at the first touch of the trend line now in the 2016 version of this pattern. There is certainly no guarantee of a repeat of the past, but markets do tend to move in repeating patterns controlled by human psychology. And the fear index is certainly one of the most psychological of them all.

Other Economic Cycle Forecasters Agreeing With ECRI

James Picerno just published an article "US Financial System Risk Eases After Reaching a 4-Year High" summing up the current "stress test" the Fed regional banks publish. I want to focus on the one done at Cleveland:

Click to enlarge

He shows some of the other banks' indices in this article, which do not show as dire a run-up currently as this one. But if you examine those other graphs, you see that nearly all of the severe run-up they did in the last recession was well after the start of the recession, providing essentially no early warning. The Cleveland tabulation seems to be a little more excitable and ahead of the curve, even if it did give a false signal in 2011.

Picerno also recently posted "Macro-Markets Risk Index Signals New US Recession" where this markets-based economic lead indicator shows its first recession signal since 2007:

Note this is also a lead indicator, shooting up over the 50% tipping point before the start of a recession. It gave a false signal in 1997, signaling only the stock crash, but no recession. However, it was not faked out in the 2011 troubles, not even going anywhere near the 10% mark.

And if you like trouble indexes that weren't faked out in 2011, consider another fear index besides the VIX. Credit Suisse has what it calls the Credit Suisse Fear Barometer:

Click to enlarge

Despite all the PIIGS stress on the global financial system, this fear index remained unperturbed and, in fact, went down during this time. But as we go into 2016, this index has gone the opposite direction of the VIX. Note that, since mid-2014, this also seems to lead the VIX in fear spikes as in the October 2014 market sell-off and the August 2015 sell-off. Could it be front running the next sell-off?

It is worth noting that the Fear Barometer is a much braver fear index than the VIX, having thumbed its nose at all the 2011 dangers and remaining more unruffled in the sell-off of last August. In fact, if you take a longer view of this index versus the VIX and compare for bravery, as in this piece from Phil'sStockWorld, you see this:

Click to enlarge

Not even the horrors of 2008 could run this fear index up. But now, it's more afraid than ever before. The above article, by Tyler Durden "Goldman Questions Rally, Fears Looming Event Risk Amid Record VIX Longs" explains two differences between the VIX and the CS index. The Fear Barometer measures the relative put/call volume whereas the VIX just measures total volume. And the Fear Barometer is geared to a 3-month outlook whereas the VIX is pummeled by every wind of rumor every minute.

Whether you go by the brave Fear Barometer or the slopes of the jumpy VIX, the market's fear gauges are registering danger in concert with the best economic cycling tools available (this does not include Fed Speak). Adjusting appropriate hedging screws in portfolios would be wise.

Disclosure: I am/we are long VXX, VIXY, TVIX.

I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.