Pessimistic GDP Forecasts Could Be A Bullish Sign

by: Kshitij Consultancy Services

Summary

Initial forecasts of global GDP forecasts may be off the mark by a relatively wide margin.

Contrary to expectations, the forecasts do not tend to get much better with subsequent revisions.

The markets seem to have priced in all negative news, including Brexit, and no positive news is visible currently, making a lot of space for positive surprises.

It is to be reasonably expected that initial forecasts of global GDP may be off the mark by a relatively wide margin. However, contrary to what might also be reasonably expected, the forecasts do not tend to get much better with subsequent revisions. Still, tracking the changes in the forecasts over time might give us useful insights into global economic sentiments.

This surmise is based on our study of the changes in averages of global GDP forecasts by various agencies for 2015 and 2016 from January 2015 to July 2016.

Comparing 2015 Actual GDP with 2015 and 2016 Consensus Projections

The study below shows how the 2015 GDP consensus forecast turned from optimism to pessimism.

The chart above tracks the difference between the forecasts for 2015 GDP since January 2015 and the actual 2015 GDP that later came out at 3.1%.

It shows that the initial forecasts were 0.29% higher than the subsequent actual. The difference kept reducing over time and actually went down to -0.25% by January 2016.

The positive difference over the period January 2015 to September 2015 is marked in the chart as "Optimistic Forecast" and the negative difference from October 2015 to March 2016 is marked as "Pessimistic Forecast".

This next chart tracks the changes in the difference between GDP forecasts for 2016 and 2015 since January 2015.

Initial forecasts suggested that 2016 growth would exceed 2015 growth by 0.20%. This difference grew to 0.41% by Aug-2015. This period is marked as "Initial Optimism".

Later, as the 2015 forecasts were revised downward, the 2016 forecasts were also revised downwards such that the 2016-2015 difference came down to 0.26% by March 2016. This second period is labeled as "Pessimism on later revisions".

The fact that the "Forecasts minus Actual GDP" difference swung from a large positive to a large negative in the first chart (instead of stabilizing near zero) supports our surmise that initial forecasts did not improve with subsequent revisions. But, what explains the swing itself? Why did the nature of forecasts change from optimistic to pessimistic?

Presumably, the sharp fall in commodity prices and in the Chinese stock market from April-May 2015 compelled a lot of forecasters to downgrade their projections for Chinese growth and to become gloomy about global growth prospects as well. Further, we see that this gloominess impacted not only the forecasts for 2015, but also the forecasts for 2016, as seen in the second chart. This leads to our second surmise that whether or not the GDP forecasts can be useful in estimating actual GDP, the changes in the GDP forecasts can be used as an indicator for getting a handle on global economic sentiments.

In the next part, we present the background of our study and look at the sentiment aspect a little deeper.

Initial forecasts had an optimistic bias earlier. Might be a little pessimistic now.

Here we track the consensus global growth forecasts for 2015 and 2016 from January 2015 to July 2016 and also the actual 2015 GDP published by IMF at 3.1% in April 2016.

Note that the forecasts for both years were revised lower over time. The period from January 2015 to September 2015 is marked as "2015 Optimism" as the 2015 GDP forecast in this period was higher than the actual. This later turned into pessimism by January 2016.

The higher projections for 2016 over 2015 till September 2015 are marked as "2016 by 2015 Optimism". This too has turned into pessimism now as the 2016 forecast is now lower than the 2015 actual.

Forecasts depend on market sentiments

Most of the cuts in the 2015 GDP forecasts were seen between July-December 2015, during which period Crude prices and the Chinese equity markets also saw sharp declines, as tracked in this chart.

This raises the suspicion that downward revisions in GDP forecasts were more a reflection of sentiments in the global commodity and equity markets, rather than estimates of real economic growth.

Going back up to the chart on the top of this page, we see that the 2016 consensus forecast (3.04%) has been cut further since mid-2016, and now stand lower than the 2015 actual of 3.10%. The post Brexit sentiment is reflected in the June revisions and possibly indicate bullish signal for 2016.

CONCLUSION

The markets seem to have priced in all negative news, including Brexit, and no positive news is visible currently. If some positive surprises kick in the latter half of 2016, the actual GDP figures could come out better than the forecasts, exactly as it happened in 2015.

Early indications of positive surprises are the better NFP (non-farm payroll) data in the USA for June and July and the increase in July PMI (purchasing managers' index) figures worldwide. Is further growth improvement in the offing?

If we use the GDP forecasts less for their intended purpose of estimating GDP and more as indicators of global macroeconomic sentiment, we are inclined to take a contrarian stance and be more optimistic about economic growth than the consensus. This study bolsters our overall bullishness on global commodity and equity markets.

In the last part, we give an overview of the data sources and the methodology of this study.

Data Sources:

The consensus forecast used in the above charts are the average of forecasts taken from 29 major institutions (including respective governments and central banks, the IMF, OECD and World Bank) that publish forecast reports at different time intervals during a year. Majority of the projections are seen in the months of April-July and October-December. Forecasts made earlier is kept constant until any revisions are made.

Methodology:

Projections by different institutions like the IMF, World Bank, central banks, S&P, Goldman Sachs, etc. are tracked and revisions are updated every month for the current and the upcoming years. The average of forecasts made for a particular year in a particular month is tabulated as below. Note that the figures in the table are arbitrary examples taken to reflect the trend in the actual projections:

Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it. I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.