Earnings Quality Issues for NYSE China Listings

A report by independent research firm RateFinancials says the ten-largest Chinese companies with American Depositary Shares listed on the New York Stock Exchange have poor earnings quality, although no accounting or listing rules are being broken. Problems vary by firm, but include such items as insufficient reserve provisions and negative working capital, in addition to signs of possible earnings management via "cookie jar" accounting, where companies report lower reserves in order to show higher revenues. The 10 top companies are: PetroChina, China Mobile, China Petroleum & Chemical, ChinaTelecom, China Life Insurance, China Unicom, Huaneng Power International, Yanzhou Coal Mining, Suntech Power Holdings and Sinopec Shanghai Petrochemical. "These companies are government-controlled enterprises masquerading as independent public companies, and it is virtually impossible to assess their financial condition given their poor level of disclosures," the report said. RateFinancial was critical of the NYSE for allowing the listings. The NYSE declined to comment, but sources say the NYSE's listing criteria are stricter than other's, the Financial Times reports.

Sources: Financial Times
Commentary: Investing in China, The Non-ETF Way • Fed Rate Cut Boon for Hong Kong, China Stocks • Beyond The U.S.: Currencies, China and India
Stocks/ETFs to watch: PTR, CHL, SNP, CHA, LFC, CHU, HNP, YZC, STP, SHI. ETFs: FXI, PGJ, CAF

Seeking Alpha's news briefs are combined into a pre-market summary called Wall Street Breakfast. Get Wall Street Breakfast by email -- it's free and takes only seconds to sign up.

Comments

[omooc:]

So, unable to gain satisfaction from NYSE, an outfit, of which I have never heard before, vented its dissatisfaction by spreading rumors. Be more responsible. omooc

2007 Sep 17 08:45 AM

[Steven Towns:]

Well, Forbes magazine (Oct. 1) picked up on the story in a piece entitled, "Made (Poorly in China)."

China Petroleum & Chemical [Sinopec] (SNP) is said to have a "board packed with inside cronies; loads of deals done with related government entities."

PetroChina (PTR) -- "Stretching payments to creditors; negative net working capital."

China Life Insurance (LFC) -- "Mortality projections wishful; accounts under Communist accounting standards appear to lack audit opinion."

Yanzhou Coal Mining (YZC) -- "Lowballing of doubtful accounts may indicate earnings manipulation; environmental liabilities possible time bomb."

Sinopec Shanghai Petrochemical (SHI) -- "FCF negative in 2006; new reserves for doubtful accounts declining."

2007 Sep 23 10:54 PM