Seeking Alpha
Seeking Alpha Portfolio App for iPad
Finance
(1)

Think of it as Moore's Law in action.

HP (HPQ) is in a commodity product trap from which it can't escape. Talk of it being undervalued is thus premature.

You can see the problem with its new product line.

These are commodity products, with commodity prices. They are not exciting. They are not new or different. They are not an ecosystem, unless you consider ink-and-paper an ecosystem. Basically HP is running in place, waiting for Windows 8 to drop.

But waiting for Windows 8 means remaining a commodity-priced hardware company that lives inside another company's ecosystem, Microsoft's (MSFT). They are an office products company, selling into a replacement market. That means falling prices and tiny margins.

If there is to be a renaissance at HP, it will come from the former EDS unit. It will come from high-value consulting and cloud work, not from computers and printers. Think they can beat IBM (IBM)?

I don't.

Disclosure: I am long IBM, MSFT.

About this author: