Benjamin Graham is widely regarded to be the founder of modern value investing. His greatest student, Warren Buffett, attributes much of his success to Graham’s teachings.
Though Graham believed that much research is necessary and that no stock screening methodology is perfect, he did give us some guidelines on how to perform initial screening techniques to limit the number of investments that should be researched further. The following is a list of the attributes he suggests investors look for first. The italics represent our changes to his methodology based on the current market:
1. Price-to-book (P/B) ratio of less than 1.2.
Intangible assets such as intellectual property, brand name recognition, and customer base, are not reflected in the price-to-book ratio, so we suggest a P/B of less than 1.5, rather than 1.2 that Graham discusses. He recognized this fact as well and commented that the P/B could be up to 2.5 if the company has significant intangible assets.
2. Earnings per share [EPS] should have grown by 33% in the past 10 years.
Earnings thus should have grown around 3% per year. In this exercise, we go back 5 years, looking for 3%+ growth in earnings.
3. The price-to-earnings [ttm] ratio should be below 15.
Perhaps the most common valuation metric, the price-to-earnings ratio allows us to understand the earnings power of the company compared to its price. A high P/E ratio is common among "growth" stocks who are expecting phenomenal growth, but Graham believed that there is no way to be sure growth will continue at a pace that justifies the high price.
4. The current ratio should be above 1.5.
The current ratio represents the current assets divided the current liabilities. This ensures that if the company faces a crisis, they have 50% more assets than liabilities to work with. For this exercise, we are going to use the quick ratio instead, which is a more conservative number because it disregards any current assets that might be difficult to unload in a tight situation, such as inventory.
5. The company should pay out a dividend.
Dividends, in Graham's opinion, are a very important indicator of a company's financial health. Not only that, but they indicate a shareholder friendly management team, without which can spell disaster for shareholders.
Now that we have mapped out what Graham thinks makes a good starting point for a list of investments, we will show you the results of running such a screener in today’s market
The following companies meet or exceed Graham’s initial test and should be considered for review by the intelligent investor.
* Everest Re Grp Lt. (NYSE: RE) * Nationwide Fin Sv (NYSE: NFS) * Ashland Inc. (NYSE: ASH) * Omnicare Inc. (NYSE: OCR) * Protective Life (NYSE: PL) * Odyssey Re Holdings (NYSE: ORH) * Industrios Bachoc (NYSE: IBA) * Ares Capital Corp. (NasdaqGS: ARCC) * Kelly Svcs (NasdaqGS: KELYA) * Encore Wire (NasdaqGS: WIRE) * Agilysis Inc. (NasdaqGS: AGYS) * One Liberty Group (NYSE: OLP) * Nymagic Inc. (NYSE: NYM) * L.S. Starrett Co. (NYSE: SCX) * Ecology Environment Inc. (AMEX: EEI)
As always, don’t take these as recommendations, rather as a good place to start researching. Lucky for you, the Investment Advisor newsletter service we offer performs this research for you, providing analysis on what we believe the best value stock on the market each month for as little as $0.30 per day. Check it out!
In the interest of full disclosure, the author of this article does not own shares in any of the companies mentioned.