If 'Real Journalism' Fails As A Business, Should Government Step In?
-
Font Size:
The chart to the right, which shows the stock price of the New York
Times Company (NYT) over the last five years, is somewhat representative of
the state of print journalism in general. They’re getting their lunch
eaten on the revenue end by Craigslist and (to a lesser extent) on the
page view end by blogs and other alternative news sources.
When the business model of “real journalism” fails, what should society do in response? When things are considered important, but can’t be supported with a business model, government sometimes steps in. National parks, highways, police and national defense are all examples. Should print journalism be next?
Last week Ralph Whitehead wrote about the issue for the Boston Globe, but said government must not step in. Today at a session led by Jeff Jarvis at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, noted Free Speech lawyer and Columbia University President Lee Bollinger said it should be considered as a viable solution to the problem. Carl Lavin at Forbes picked up the story, and I’m now squarely in the middle of it.
At first Bollinger only mentioned it as an idea put forward by others. When I questioned him, he said he supported the notion.
The idea is both dangerous and absurd. For Bollinger, who is a free speech advocate, to even consider the idea suggests he hasn’t thought through the consequences of the government financing the press. Freedom of the press is one of the most important checks on government. If they’re paying the bills, the press is no longer independent.
Print media is wonderful, and it would be a shame to ever see it fail. But these are businesses that need to sustain themselves in one way or another. Looking for a government handout to perpetuate a quaint but outdated way of life is the last resort of the desperate. It should be avoided at all costs.
Get Seeking Alpha Free Stock Alerts by Email!
Get Free Stock Alerts by Email!
-
Editor's Picks
-
Most Popular
- In a Vulnerable Bond Market, Two ProShares ETFs To Consider
- AOL To Shutter a Slew of Products
- The Nature of a Crowded Trade: This Time It's Housing
- American Express Calls Investment Banks' Bluff
- Japan: Recession-Bound As Exports Slow?
- iShares MSCI Mexico: Surprising Strength South of the Border
- Full list of Editor's Picks »
- Three Stocks To Be Held To Infinity and Beyond »
- As WaMu, Wachovia Ready Earnings, Comparisons to Wells, USB Are Telling »
- Wall Street Breakfast: Must-Know News »
- Steve Jobs' Health: A Red Herring »
- Financials: How - And When - We Reached the Bottom »
- Four Long-Term Winners Selling at Deep Discounts »
- Apple F3Q08 (Qtr End 6/28/08) Earnings Call Transcript »
- Earnings Preview: Washington Mutual »
- The Agriculture Boom Goes Bust »
- Crazy Dividends »
- Apple's a Buy Under $150 »
-
Long Ideas
-
Short Ideas
-
Cramer's Picks
- Opportunities in Small-Cap Asset Management Firms
- Alexco: Interesting Emerging Silver Producer
- The Hardest Trade - Fast Money Recap (7/24/08)
- TUP Up - Cramer's Mad Money (7/24/08)
- Buy Rent-A-Center -- Cramer's Lightning Round (7/24/08)
- Citi vs XTO Energy -- Cramer’s Stop Trading! (7/24/08)
- Potash Corp. Earns $2.82, a 220% Increase
- Mechel Drops 20% on Putin's Comments
- Auto Retailers' Ability to Pay Debt - What It Means
- Three Conservative Growth Industrial Picks: Adminstaff, Carlisle Companies and Illinois Tool Works
- Full list of Long Ideas »
- Collateral Damage From the War on Shorts
- Is the Gold Uptrend Over?
- Response to Raymond James' Q3 Conference Call
- eBay is a Not Com - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/23/08)
- Get True Religion - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/22/08)
- Principal Financial Group Vulnerable to Commercial Real Estate Softening?
- Increases in Shorting, Only for Some
- Is a Ban on Short Financial ETFs on the Horizon?
- Is There a More Efficient Shorting Tactic?
- Short Oil as a Long Investment
- Full list of Short Ideas »
- TUP Up - Cramer's Mad Money (7/24/08)
- Buy Rent-A-Center -- Cramer's Lightning Round (7/24/08)
- Citi vs XTO Energy -- Cramer’s Stop Trading! (7/24/08)
- eBay is a Not Com - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/23/08)
- Buy Costco, Get Sirius - Cramer's Stop Trading! (7/23/08)
- Soup Target; Cramer's Mad Money (7/22/08)
- Get True Religion - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/22/08)
- Copper Down Low - Cramer's Stop Trading! (7/22/08)
- Banks Hit Bottom – Cramer’s Mad Money (7/21/08)
- Ends In X - Cramer's Stop Trading! (7/21/08)
- Full list of Cramers Picks »
Most Popular Feeds
-
ETFs
-
US Market
-
Long Ideas
-
Alt. Energy
- Full list of feeds »
Hedge Fund Jobs
Job Seekers:
- Search jobs by category
- Get job alerts by email or live feed
- Apply online
Employers
- See all recruitment options
- Get applications online or by email




This article has 5 comments:
But why should the government be limited to failed or failing business models like these?
If government was going to get into the media business wouldn't it make sense to do it properly? One company, full multi-media access across the entire spectrum, from cell-phones and blackberries to TV and movies houses distributed through all means. Establishment of an officially sanctioned training program for journalists so that they know stuff. Cooperation between journalists and the diplomatic and military services around the world.
Oh, perhaps Madison Avenue should be included in the mix too. That way there wouldn't be any disorienting shocks caused by changes in coverage reflecting changes in ownership.
Fascism
Yates