Seeking Alpha
Profile| Send Message|
( followers)  

My continued lack … well, maybe a better word is reduction … in blogging has been compensated by increased conference speaking. Aside from the event in Singapore I participated in last week, the other recent big ETF event was the “Inside ETFs” conference in Palm Beach Gardens Florida in January. The organizers of that event are a multi-armed entity called Index Publications LLC who publish the ETFR (Exchange Traded Fund Report) and the Journal of Indexes. Index Universe is their online portal and, in my opinion, along with the published work of Deborah Fuhr at Morgan Stanley provide pretty much all there is to know about indexing and ETFs on this planet.

I know that I’m keeping up with these experts after having bumped into Jim Wiandt (President of Index Publications and Publisher of IndexUniverse.com) in an event last year in Hong Kong. I’ve seen Deb Fuhr at basically every ETF related conference I’ve been to in the past year including the one in Singapore and we’re both speaking at an emerging markets derivative/indexing conference next week in London that should be very interesting as there’s great debate these days of the merit of investing in the developing world given the global market turmoil.

But this post is to let you know that IndexUniverse.com has put up an interview I did with them recently. I’ll likely get a bump in traffic to this blog (heartfelt thanks to IU) and I only wish I had more recently published material up for new visitors. Truth is that I have about a half dozen drafts sitting on the back of this site ready for finishing touches … some of them written many months ago with data/charts that need updating. I suppose I should be writing about the latest regulatory news about actively managed ETFs or maybe something on ProShares’ upcoming 130/30 ETF. There’s actually a lot of interesting new stuff out there in terms of product and industry developments but what interests me even more is the broader picture and what’s happening in this major down market. So here it goes …

I believe that this is where all the more interesting ETFs will “make it or break it”. What has been the trend in ETF land over the past couple of years? Not plain vanilla, low cost ETFs but the exact opposite: Niche sectors. Emerging markets. Thematic funds. Inverse exposures. Many of these have very low correlations to the bread and butter SPY/QQQQ type of holdings. The inverse ETFs go further in providing the zig while the markets zag. Yet, of course, we find what happened with Claymore and their fund closures. Clearly, there will be winners and losers. But these are exciting times for the industry. Many of the new products should do well in this tough environment but many won’t. There’s a parallel to hedge funds (I always do this!).

Nearly every hedge fund manager must have been sweatin’ it during the long and continuous bull market of 2003 to 2007. Basically every hedge fund manager should be in nirvana in this current market environment. The truth is that many are taking advantage of what the market is now providing them but I’d bet that many, many more are in their own version of hell. It’s tougher and tougher to find alpha out there and doing well in down markets is not the same sport for hedge funds as it was thirty, twenty or even ten years ago. Just darn too competitive. Finding a really good hedge fund that isn’t closed to new investors is tough. Thus, building a robust portfolio of hedge funds must be close to impossible. Certainly, the evidence from hedge fund indexing seems to show that the more you try to diversify hedge fund holdings, the more it becomes simply ultra-high cost closet indexing.

I believe that successful hedge fund investing is possible if you have the adequate resources. The term adequate usually evokes a feeling of minimal requirements … this does not apply to hedge fund investing. I’m not talking about minimum investment amounts but the acumen required to provide the necessary qualitative due diligence as well as forensic accounting needed to properly filter the good from the bad. Unfortunately, not everyone can be Yale. And for too many investors, the premium for giving up liquidity and transparency is simply not enough. ETFs, way over at the other end of the active-passive spectrum provide both liquidity and transparency … and now access to the small corners of the global capital markets complex.

Could this be why ETFs and their move towards niche offerings and now active management have the potential do grow even within a lengthy down market? That has always been the argument against indexing and ETFs … they fail to do their thing in bear markets. But if ETFs are no longer just about tracking plain ol’ S&P 500 (NYSEARCA:SPY) and MSCI EAFE (NYSEARCA:EFA), but providing inverse equity index exposures and currency hedges and low correlated commodity exposures and so on - well then it’s certainly possible to be bullish on ETFs in a bear market.

Source: Bullish on ETFs in a Bear Market