How Do You Cure a Credit Bubble?
-
Font Size:
I'm a bit puzzled by some of the
underlying thought processses behind those proponents of a massive
government bailout of some sort of the US housing industry. On one
hand, they seem, for the most part, to be agreeing with the premise
that the state of the US balance sheet, whether our private (consumers)
or our public (the government) is at minimum unsound and in the long
term creates extreme risk. On the other hand, they seem to be saying
that the only way out of our current difficulties is to continue to
expand credit. Huh?
Via Financial Times (a fine paper in many respects, but can't say I agree with this particular opinion):
Moreover, the US has structural vulnerabilities that Japan did not have: low household savings, untested derivative markets, and a large current account deficit.
But there may be a conflict between the private interest of the banks and the public interest in continued credit expansion.
So, were financially unsound and its in the public interest to become more financially unsound? Continued credit expansion, the so called "hair of the dog" approach is really what we need? When does it reach the point where it's time to enter a good detox center (managed credit contraction) instead? So, levering the entire world's output and the entire worlds stock market capitalization at over 10x thru derivatives alone isn't enough (estimated size of derivatives market $516 trillion divided by $48 trillion world GDP or by $51 trillion world stock market capitalization)? Keep the frat party going as long as possible, keep misallocating far too many resources into financial engineering and real estate?
Then of course, there are those within the "We'll fix our balance sheet by borrowing and leveraging some more crowd" who want to "fix" our situation via some sort of upside down Nixonian price controls, i.e. price floors. So is the thought process something along the lines of "Just because temporary price controls were a disaster doesn't mean temporary price floors won't work out just wonderful"? This via the Senate banking committee chairman (Chris Dodd):
What we're trying to do here, in addition to providing assistance to the homeowner, is to create a floor...
So what is the right price to set it at, i.e. the floor? Is it better set by free markets or by government subsidies? Furthermore, what if Chris Dodd and the like were to actually to "succeed" in putting a floor on house prices (doubtful but lets just play "what if"). Is having housing prices artificially subsidized at levels far above long term trends actually in the long term best interest of our economy? Further, is it in the best interest of those looking to buy a house both now and in the future to not only have to pay some of their tax money subsidizing the cost of housing, but to overpay once more in buying an artificially overpriced house?
It seems to me that trying reflate the bubble in some way shape or form is about the worst thing we can do. The only viable long term solution is to attempt to deleverage / contract the credit cycle to a market driven level of balance, but given the magnitude of the rise, to do it in some sort of managed fashion. As to the particulars of how best to manage it? There are plenty of arguments to be made on each step of the way, sure to provide plenty of fodder for discussion. Some of my own thoughts are here, including perhaps the less conventional belief that it may be time to consider putting away the interest rate tool after this coming week.
Get Seeking Alpha Free Stock Alerts by Email!
Get Free Stock Alerts by Email!
ETFs In Focus
-
Editor's Picks
-
Most Popular
- Latest Commodities Indicator: Fed Policy
- Thoughts on Mohamed El-Erian's 'When Markets Collide'
- Priceline: More Headwinds Ahead
- PFI: PowerShares Dynamic Financials Outperforms Its Peers
- Interview with Kevin Carter, AlphaShares CEO
- Report from the Bond War Frontlines
- Full list of Editor's Picks »
- Wall Street Breakfast: Must-Know News »
- Has Jim Cramer Crossed the Line with Sirius XM? »
- Buffett Takes Berkshire Hathaway on $4 Billion Spending Spree »
- Sirius XM Shorts Scrambling to Cover »
- Looming Financial Catastrophe: A Real Inconvenient Truth »
- No Leadership from Apple Right Now »
- AIG and the Lunacy of GAAP Reporting »
- Solarfun Power Holdings Co., Ltd. Q2 2008 Earnings Call Transcript »
- Apple's Biggest Rumor: iPod or Jobs? »
- Independence Day: Decoupling Gold and Silver from the Dollar »
- Frank Barbera: Precious Metals Heading to All-Time Highs »
-
Long Ideas
-
Short Ideas
-
Cramer's Picks
- Faith Doesn't Cut It - Cramer's Mad Money (8/29/08)
- Again With the Financials - Fast Money Recap (8/29/08)
- Potash One Will Be Top Performer in Agriculture Bull Market
- Luxury Retail Stocks: Two Worth a Look
- 11 Top Canadian Dividend Stocks Available as ADRs
- Natural Gas Is Oversold, and We Are Buying
- Libbey Inc.: The Glass is Half Full
- Mad Money Manual - Cramer's Mad Money (8/28/08)
- An Eye on Gustav - Fast Money Recap (8/28/08)
- Will You Look Back on Today as Your Greatest Missed Opportunity?
- Full list of Long Ideas »
- Priceline: More Headwinds Ahead
- The Option Arm Triplets: Dead Banks Walking
- Short Thesis Still Intact at FirstFed
- Short Story: Lehman
- 'Buy, But Sell' - What Are Analysts Thinking?
- Nordson's Rally Is Over, For Now - Barron's
- What's So Special About RadioShack? - Barron's
- Salesforce.com: It's All About the Guidance
- Three Casino Stocks Rolling Over
- New Web Site For Short Sellers: You Gotta Love Capitalism
- Full list of Short Ideas »
- Faith Doesn't Cut It - Cramer's Mad Money (8/29/08)
- Mad Money Manual - Cramer's Mad Money (8/28/08)
- Diversified Portfolios - Cramer's Mad Money (8/27/08)
- Gustav Moves Overdone - Cramer's Stop Trading! (8/27/08)
- GrafTech is Too Cheap - Cramer's Stop Trading
- The Rebound List - Cramer's Mad Money (8/26/08)
- The List - Cramer's Stop Trading! (8/26/08)
- Can't Turn My Back - Cramer's Lightning Round (8/26/08)
- The Pelosi Factor - Cramer's Mad Money (8/25/08)
- Buy Tech Weakness - Cramer's Lightning Round (8/25/08)
- Full list of Cramers Picks »
Trading Center
Hedge Fund Jobs
Job Seekers: Search jobs by category, get job alerts by email or live feed, apply online See full list of jobs »
Employers: See all recruitment options, get applications online or by email Post a job »



This article has 5 comments:
The problem, which Bush, Bernanke, et all seem immune too is that this will keep downward pressure on housing due to the mortgage rates staying high.
And of course we have oil at $110 a barrel, and wheat at over $10.00 per bushel. But food and oil don't count in inflation statistics, so we really don't have inflation. yea right.