Barron's Misses the Other Side of the Commodities Story
-
Font Size:
I’m sure many of you have seen the Barron’s cover story this week [$], claiming that the commodities upside is driven mostly by speculators. On a basic level, this is true — all investors are basically “speculating.” But we know that’s not what the author meant.
I don’t mind if someone presents a bearish case on an investment possibility. Regular readers may have noticed that my research reports dwell heavily on the risks to our investments — I spend a lot of time trying to discern and even dreaming up risks to any investment.
What amuses me in this particular case is the article’s lopsidedness. It doesn’t once address the possibility of being wrong. Fine, if you write a newsletter but pretty lame for financial “journalist.” I’ll probably post later about the importance of filters but in the meantime, here is a link to another story by the Financial Times last week that presents another side of this argument:
Non-exchange Traded Commodities Outpacing Exchange Traded Brethren
According to this article, many commodities like iron ore, coal, steel and other obscure minerals you never think of are rising in price despite the absence of speculators (due to lack of accessibility). Anyone following negotiations between Vale, Rio Tinto, BHP w/ Asian countries re: iron ore or following the coal companies can attest to the demand for those goods.
Of course, the Barron’s article does not address this issue but there it is. Speculation or demand? I leave it to the reader to determine which scenario is more reflective of reality.
Disclosure: None
Get Seeking Alpha Free Stock Alerts by Email!
Get Free Stock Alerts by Email!
-
Editor's Picks
-
Most Popular
- A Long Housing Boom Won't Yield to a Brief Recovery
- Why Congress Blames Index Speculators
- What Are the Prospects for Stagflation?
- State Street Launches 10 Ex-U.S. Sector ETFs
- Eisai Victorious Over Teva and Dr. Reddy’s in Aciphex Compound Patent Case
- Financials Future Still Uncertain
- Full list of Editor's Picks »
- As WaMu, Wachovia Ready Earnings, Comparisons to Wells, USB Are Telling »
- Apple F3Q08 (Qtr End 6/28/08) Earnings Call Transcript »
- Three Stocks To Be Held To Infinity and Beyond »
- Crazy Dividends »
- Apple Investors Nervous as Earnings Call Approaches »
- Wall Street Breakfast: Must-Know News »
- Historic Financial Collapse Underway? »
- Mother of All Short Squeezes? »
- China Poised to Pounce on U.S. Coal Suppliers »
- Is Natural Gas Down for the Count? »
- Barron's Goes Bullish on Banks, Again »
-
Long Ideas
-
Short Ideas
-
Cramer's Picks
- Dollar Back? - Fast Money Recap (7/23/08)
- Terex: Overlooked Bargain
- EBay is a Not Com – Cramer’s Lightning Round (7/23/08)
- Buy Costco, Get Sirius -- Cramer’s Stop Trading! (7/23/08)
- Intuitive Surgical's Q2: A Lesson in Errors of Perception
- Chevron: Good Choice for Conservative Growth Investor
- Pfizer Beats: Recommended at or Below $18
- Illumini, Intuitive: This Healthcare Outperformance Brought to You by the Letter 'I'
- Cynosure: Growth Expected as Sales Go Global
- More Bad News for the Anti-Ethanol Crowd
- Full list of Long Ideas »
- Get True Religion - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/22/08)
- Principal Financial Group Vulnerable to Commercial Real Estate Softening?
- Increases in Shorting, Only for Some
- Is a Ban on Short Financial ETFs on the Horizon?
- Is There a More Efficient Shorting Tactic?
- Short Oil as a Long Investment
- Ford's Financial Services Business About to Enter the Red
- Educational and Training Services Are An Excellent Short Opportunity
- Short Selling: Others Want Protection Too
- The SEC's Campaign Against Naked Shorting: Misguided or Right On?
- Full list of Short Ideas »
- EBay is a Not Com – Cramer’s Lightning Round (7/23/08)
- Buy Costco, Get Sirius -- Cramer’s Stop Trading! (7/23/08)
- Soup Target; Cramer's Mad Money (7/22/08)
- Get True Religion - Cramer's Lightning Round (7/22/08)
- Copper Down Low - Cramer's Stop Trading! (7/22/08)
- Banks Hit Bottom – Cramer’s Mad Money (7/21/08)
- Ends In X - Cramer's Stop Trading! (7/21/08)
- Great American Companies – Cramer’s Lightning Round (7/21/08)
- Market Rotation Bolsters Financials - Fast Money Recap (7/18/08)
- For Everything, Wind - Stop Trading! (7/17/08)
- Full list of Cramers Picks »
Most Popular Feeds
-
ETFs
-
US Market
-
Long Ideas
-
Alt. Energy
- Full list of feeds »
Hedge Fund Jobs
Job Seekers:
- Search jobs by category
- Get job alerts by email or live feed
- Apply online
Employers
- See all recruitment options
- Get applications online or by email



This article has 3 comments:
Looks like more than speculation to me.