China: Save the Stock Market Investor!

After an awful first quarter for Chinese stock markets (down 34%), there seems to be a rising crescendo for stock market support measures by the government.

On Wednesday, the China Securities Journal quoted a report by the State Information Center, an NDRC-affiliated think tank, calling on the government to take concrete steps to support local stock markets. Since the stock market plunge was “not in line with the country’s economic fundamentals,” argued the authors, it needed to be stopped. According to the report: “Historically speaking, a country with a fast-growing economy and an appreciating currency should see its stock market develop rapidly. China is exactly at this period of its development.”

History is always a sinuous thing in modern China, and its main purpose is to support current policy goals. Therefore, it probably doesn’t do much good to point out that there are plenty of cases in history of slumping stock markets in rapidly growing economies. That's not especially surprising when you consider that the stock market is supposed to be a gauge of future expectations, not a report card for past GDP growth.

What is more interesting to me is that a major think tank supported by the NDRC, the country’s top economic planner, is calling very explicitly for government intervention to support the market. “It is a common practice for governments to directly and resolutely intervene in financial markets in instances of major volatility, even in Western countries,” the report claimed, more or less clinching the argument.

Perhaps in line with the SIC sentiments, on Tuesday an official at the China Securities Regulatory Commission denied a rumor that there were net redemptions at mutual funds of about RMB 100 billion during the first quarter of the year. On the contrary, he claimed, total redemptions were about RMB 17 billion and total new subscriptions nearly twice that amount, according to Wednesday’s China Daily. The rumor, which seemed to have come from a 21^st Century Business Herald article, “goes against the facts and is misleading to investors,” according to the official.

The good news doesn’t end there. Wednesday’s Xinhua reported that “Investors remain optimistic about stocks.” According to a recent survey released by the CSRC, more than 60% of Chinese investors expect stock prices to rise. The Xinhua report goes into a great deal of detail about the composition of the retail investor base (or at least that part which answered the survey) but doesn’t say when the survey was taken. However, my best guess from reading between the lines is that it took place in January, before the big crunch, so I wonder how many people now still believe stock prices will rise.

My own interpretation of all these claims and clarifications is that the government is very worried about the stock market collapse and is doing everything it can to pump up excitement about the market. If this doesn’t work, I suspect that it will take more concrete steps. By the way, the market was up a little on Wednesday – about 0.6%.

Of course, if there is a turnaround in the stock market, it may solve one pressing concern, but it may also worsen another – and this is one of the main difficulties in which China finds itself: each of its problems is interlocked with other problems in such a complex way that policy choices are sharply constrained. Specifically, if there is a sharp stock market rally (and given monetary conditions, a slow, gradual rise in stock market indices has a very low probability of happening – it is either boom or bust), it may create yet another reason for speculative inflows.

In the past it seemed that speculative inflows were correlated with the thrilling performance of the stock market. When that game was over, inflows seemed to have shifted to bank deposits to take advantage of the more-rapidly rising RMB. A renewal of the stock market bull will only make monetary policy harder than ever to manage since it will probably encourage hot money inflows even more. Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

Meanwhile, there continues to be bad news on the food-price front. Wednesday’s China Daily reported that northern and northeastern China is suffering from the worst drought in decades. This will have a terrible effect on agricultural production, especially in the province of Heilongjiang, a region that is, according to China Daily, the country’s largest supplier of commodity grains, including corn, soybean, rice and wheat. Up to 51% of the province’s total planted area could face severe drought during the spring plowing season. This means that even if the inflation problem in China really is pork, and not money, as Ken Rogoff memorably put it, the pork problem may very well persist.

Eight more days to the March CPI release. I haven’t been hearing much in the way of price rumors, but I expect month-on-month inflation to be down a little and year-on-year inflation to be up over 7%.

Comments

[rainman]

the core issues are:
1. Will China earing grow under Yuan appreciation, rate hike and inflation (virus extended to rice price now.)
2. Present PE is still high compared with that of H share
3. How to deal with Xiao Fei and Da Fei, a good suggestion is to impose income gain tax on top of the huge gain by those interest groups and individuals.
4. This whole short fall to me is a healthy correction.

[rlirph]

One has to read carefully with what government officials say. Sometimes the officials deliberately make misleading and outright incorrect statements. Sometimes the officials do not know any better.

I am an American living in GZ in the past three years I can assure you that very few investors think positively about the stock market. All you have to do is to read the stock webblogs.

With the sharp decline of China's real estate prices many local citizens as well as I have taken hits in both the stock and housing markets. My real estate investment in a luxury condo project has seen a 50% price drop from October 2007 to March 2009. It is surprising that one do not see riots over housing price drops!

In the long run over the next five to ten years China represents a better investment opportunity than the U.S. There will be lots of volatility that go along with the ride!

[chinesepetti]

Mike read the history; very recent histroy, after the Japanese appreciated its currency the economy and stock market has been being slumped last 25 years and still going down. At least Chinese has a bit more respect than you young americans so this time they will not definitely listen to Mike's nonsense; Mike you better do some work for your own country regarding it's miserable credit crisis though!