Economic Report Summary: Consumer Sentiment Index at 26-Year Low

More weakness in housing, a 26-year low in consumer confidence, and rising import/export prices highlighted last week's economic reports.

Stocks and bonds ended with the S&P 500 Index down 2.7 percent to 1,333, now down 9.2 percent for the year, and the yield of the 10-year U.S. Treasury note fell 1 basis point to 3.47 percent.

Pending Home Sales: The National Association of Realtors' [NAR] index of pending home sales fell 1.9 percent in February to just 84.6, its lowest reading since the index began in 2001. This monthly tally of existing homes entering a sales contract agreement has dropped 21.4 percent from the year-ago level of 107.6.

Lawrence Yun, the trade group's chief economist, said in a statement that the pending home sales dip "implies we're not out of the woods yet, though an era of successive deep sales declines appears to be over." The Realtors group maintained its prediction that the housing market would pick up in the second half of the year and that the median price of a U.S. home would decline by just 1.4 percent. The NAR has an abysmal track record of forecasting sales volume and prices.

International Trade: The trade gap between the U.S. and the rest of the world unexpectedly widened in February to $62.3 billion after an upwardly revised $59.0 billion deficit in January. Exports increased 2.0 percent; however, imports surged 3.1 percent as the U.S. purchase of consumer and other goods from foreign trading partners set a new record.

The value of petroleum imports fell by 5.1 percent and energy related imports declined 12.5 percent. Crude oil prices rose modestly from $84.09 to $84.76, a record high; however, the quantity of imported oil fell 11.1 percent from January, consistent with lower energy demand amid a slowing U.S. economy. Oil prices will be much higher in the March report which, when combined with the surprisingly large trade deficit in February, may be enough to push economic growth into negative territory for the first quarter.

Consumer Sentiment: The Reuters/University of Michigan consumer sentiment index plunged to a 26-year low, dropping from 69.5 in March to 63.2 in April, well below analysts' expectations near 70.

The April reading was the lowest since March of 1982, during the 1970s "stagflation" hangover, exactly two years after government reported inflation had peaked at an annual rate of 14.6 percent in 1980.

Interestingly, the annual inflation rate in March of 1981 was 10.6 percent and in March of 1982 it was 6.9 percent, meaning that the mood of the consumer was still rather foul after two years of moderating prices.

Even more interesting is that sentiment is about the same now, with inflation at four percent, as it was in 1982, when inflation was almost double that rate at about seven percent. This is a good indication of how inflation is underreported today versus a quarter century ago, as consumer sentiment generally tracks inflation and gasoline prices more than anything else.

There have been only twelve worse readings for this index over its 50-year history, which, when you think about it, is a truly astonishing statistic. By this measure, since 1958, the mood of the consumer has been worse only two percent of the time. High food and energy prices are weighing on the consumer as one-year inflation expectations rose from 4.3 percent in March to 4.8 percent in April, the highest reading since 1990.

Import/Export Prices: Import prices surged 2.8 percent in March after an increase of just 0.2 percent in February and export prices surprised to the upside as well, gaining 1.5 percent after a 0.9 percent increase the month prior. As was the case for the report on international trade earlier in the week, the rising price of crude oil was not completely to blame for the overall monthly increase as non petroleum costs rose to a new all-time high.

Excluding petroleum, all other import prices rose 1.1 percent in March and 5.4 percent on a year-over-year basis. The monthly change was the highest monthly increase on record and the annual rate of increase was nearly double the 2.8 percent gain over the same months during 2006 and 2007.

On a year-over-year basis, overall import prices increased 15 percent, which is about the exact same percentage decline experienced by the U.S. Dollar, casting some doubt on the conventional wisdom of Fed economists that there is only about a ten percent pass-through between a declining currency and rising import prices.

Summary: This was a relatively light week of economic data, but it was all very bad - consumer sentiment at lows last seen in 1982, all-time lows for pending home sales, soaring import/export prices, and a widening trade gap that will cause real GDP growth for the first quarter to move even lower.

Consumer credit rose at only a modest pace, which is good for the personal savings rate but bad for the U.S. economy that is driven by consumer spending financed to an unhealthy degree by new credit.

The only bright spot for the week was a dramatic plunge in weekly jobless claims, but this comes off of the first reading above the psychologically important 400,000 level a week ago that was revised upward last week. Since the week-to-week changes are virtually meaningless, a sequence of many weeks of lower initial claims would be necessary to think that the job market will not deteriorate further from here.

The Week Ahead: The coming week will be highlighted by reports on retail sales on Monday and consumer prices on Wednesday. Also scheduled for release are reports on producer prices, New York area manufacturing activity, and the homebuilders' housing market index on Tuesday, housing starts and industrial production on Wednesday, and leading economic indicators and the Philadelphia Fed survey on Thursday.

Comments

[user 2lakes:]

I think the self serving NAR actual stands for NEVER ACTUALLY RIGHT on anything. Our local high school no longer has a cheerleader squad, maybe the realtors should scrap theirs too.

2008 Apr 13 10:36 AM

[Chris Marshall:]

I'm very bearish on the US economy, it has escalated from residential Real Estate and Finance problem, to enter the real economy of Industrial Corporations (GE). I fully expect the effects to be felt in the Retail sector and the Commercial Real Estate Market shortly.

I am looking for a silver lining, but so far the only thing that I can find is that the residential real estate prices in Texas, the Deep South and the rust belt, are nearing fair value.

Conversely the sunshine states are still very overvalued.

I believe that recession now is probable, maybe lasting up to 2 years. I believe that the US economy will start to grow about 15 months after residential real estate has reached bottom, but we're not there yet.

The NAR are a bad joke, there forecasting skills appear to motivated by the need of its members to sell quickly to survive.

2008 Apr 13 11:32 AM

[romorris:]

Another guy not bright enough to know to never use any information or data from the NAR.

2008 Apr 14 10:42 AM

[WAKEUP:]

Consumer Sentiment: Slowly, ever so slowly, the average American is becoming alert to the overwhelming array of negative factors he/she has confronting them at this time. A very low consumer sentiment reading is a hint that Americans suspect that what is coming is going to be very bad. Read, severe recession/depression.

2008 Apr 14 09:50 PM

[Tim Iacono:]

"Another guy not bright enough to know to never use any information or data from the NAR."??

Their data is useful, their forecast and spin is not.

What part about "The NAR has an abysmal track record of forecasting sales volume and prices." did you not understand?

2008 Apr 15 01:27 PM