Market Commentary by Citigroup’s Chief Strategist

I saw this interesting interview with Tobias Levkovich on CNBC last week. He shared some good points:

• Market Valuations: His price target is 1550(S&P 500), based on valuations, sentiment, and implied earnings growth. Predicts flattish earnings(~$86) in 2008 and 2009 for S&P500. Energy and materials will underperform in 2009 (because of declines in the commodities sector). This would be offset by outperformance in the financials and the consumer discretionary. Refused to discuss specific valuations. Valuations need to be discussed based on risk premiums, historical context, and bond yields; and not in a vacuum. Pointed out that homebuilders looked deceptively cheap in 2005.
• Commodities: Cyclical conditions will effect the commodity trade severely. To put it simply, commodity prices do go down in a recession. (Note: I discuss this in my post here). A similar thing happened during the inflationary 1970s recession. Agriculture, fertilizers and the chemicals look like the dot-coms.
• Savings rate: This is going to get worse in the next 5-10 years because of demographics. Retiring baby boomers would be using their savings. (This would be worldwide.) Not really a problem because wealth is growing enormously. Implication: Savings rate isn't a useful metric anymore. This could potentially have negative implications for the markets?
• Elections: Current year would be the first time since 1928 that sitting President or VP isn't up for reelection. So the administration doesn't have the motivation for election year stimulus that normally happens. Conclusion: Historically, election years have been good for the stock markets. May not be true this year.
• Asia: Asian companies have really low return on equities (ROEs), even though asset turnover is at a 16 year high. Whenever this turnover goes low, the ROEs will collapse. Don't want to be there when that happens. Not sure where this data point came from, but this is interesting if true. (Note: To understand the DuPont ROE breakdown, refer to this entry)
• Real estate: Real Estate bubble and appreciation are far worse outside the US. So you cannot point to the US selectively. I agree. Except the problems in the US are not just about house price appreciation, but caused primarily due to negligent and fraudulent lending practices.
• Post-elections: Critical issue for the post election year is this: are we moving towards more protectionism? Will we abrogate on tax treaties? What about tariffs/ protection quotas? Could be very devastating for markets. Asserts that taxes will go up across the board regardless of who gets elected. This is because they will look to fix AMT before they extend the Bush tax cuts.
• Markets: He talked of a W shaped pattern in the markets. Things will get worse before they get better. The worsening credit conditions effect the economy with a 9 month lag. Hence mid-year to year end, we'll still have problems and will see a slowdown in the industrial side of the economy. Earning estimates for the year end are still too high. Note that there has been some chatter about a double-dip recession. See this and this. Double dip is essentially a W pattern.
• Industrial sector: Talked about an industrial sector slowdown. Even though people talk of resilience in the US exports and the BRICs, two thirds of the “international” for US companies is in Europe. This could hence slow down.

Disclosure: None.

Comments

[moose60061]

Well thats the "sky is falling" scenario if I ever heard one!!

[Sajal]

I don't think so. He does have a price target of 1550 for 2008, which is a ~17% upside on the S&P 500 from Friday's close to year end.

[jayz]

What about his prediction about C? Why would I get stock advice from someone whose firm may or may not afloat by the end of the year?