Surprising Reaction to Oriental Education's Earnings

Strange reaction in the stock of New Oriental Education (EDU), plus 6 percent- I guess expectations were just low enough that beating expectations for this quarter, along with lower future guidance is ok to keep the stock pumped up. I have only a tiny position at this point in this name, but it was nice to see a return to from for this stock after an abysmal last quarter [Jan 15: New Oriental Education Solid Report, Stock Trashed] - I thought the winter storms in China would cause more of a problem...

• Beijing-based New Oriental Education and Technology Group Inc., a provider of private educational services in China, said Wednesday that third-quarter earnings grew 38 percent as enrollment and deferred revenue jumped.
• Third quarter earnings rose to $11.6 million, or 29 cents per American Depositary Share, from $8.4 million, or 22 cents per ADS, a year ago. Revenue surged 47 percent to $48.1 million for the fiscal quarter ended Feb. 29, from $32.8 million in the prior year.
• Analysts surveyed by Thomson Financial expected third-quarter earnings of 23 cents per share on revenue of $44.3 million.
• New Oriental Chief Financial Officer Louis T. Hsieh noted that severe winter storms forced the company to close dozens of schools and learning centers in late January and early February.
• He said most affected students chose to defer their enrollments to future quarters rather than cancel their registrations. As a result, student enrollments surged 35 percent to 268,400 during the quarter, and deferred revenue balance, or money collected from students for classes in future quarters, more than doubled to $35.8 million at the end of the quarter.
• The company also noted that it has agreed to acquire a 60 percent equity stake in Mingshitang, a Beijing-based private school that specializes in tutoring students who want to retake the gaokao exam, the Chinese college entrance test.

Guidance

• Beijing-based New Oriental Education and Technology Group Inc., a provider of private educational services in China, predicted fourth-quarter revenue below Wall Street expectations on Wednesday after third-quarter results exceeded forecasts.
• New Oriental expects fourth quarter revenue to range from $32.1 million to $33.4 million, which represents a growth range of 29 percent to 34 percent. Analysts surveyed by Thomson Financial forecast quarterly revenue of $35 million.

Another case study of how we have absolutely no advantage trying to predict how the masses will react to earnings information. Even if I had known they were going to beat this quarter but guide down in the next, I would of had no idea how the stock would react. They did the exact same thing last quarter, beating expectations and put out conservative guidance and the stock was mutilated [Jan 15: Horrific Fall in New Oriental Education]. Three months later they repeat the same situation and the stock is up - mystifying. This is why this time of year (earnings season) is simply gambling when you place bets ahead of earnings...

Disclosure: Long New Oriental Education in fund; no personal position

Comments

[chinesepetti:]

I like to remind readers here; Mr Petti worked for Bear Stern and also he is working in a State Chinese Communist run school at the moment. Details please visit seekingalpha.com/autho...

China has many problems on its own; but it's very ironic the red communists do not mind Mr Petti (who is paid salary by the Chinese communist run school) being so critical of everything in China even the air he breathes every day.

2008 Apr 18 04:55 AM

[chinesepetti:]

All Mr Petti's pupils and seeking alpha readers here; the story about Mr Petti just does not add up! According to Mr Petti's views (you can read all his articles about China on this site ; strangely he only wrote about China), everything in China is in crisis even the air is filthy so why he is making a living there; getting paid from the red Communist school; why not go back to Wall street to work for Bear Stern ? Bear Stern is not dead yet.

It is time for Mr Petti and his loyal pupils to disclose his relationship with the red Chinese government now!!! And all readers on this site should also make such a demand; otherwise it's an insult to the intelligence of all seekingalpha readers!

2008 Apr 18 09:39 PM