LIBOR Credibility in Doubt

Bloomberg is reporting Libor Poised for Shake-Up as Credibility Is Doubted.

The benchmark interest rate for $62 trillion of credit derivatives and mortgages for 6 million U.S. homeowners faces its biggest shakeup in a decade as lawmakers question if banks are understating borrowing costs.

For the first time since 1998, the British Bankers' Association is considering changing the way it sets the London interbank offered rate, according to Chief Executive Officer Angela Knight, who appeared before a parliamentary committee in London today. ``We've put Libor under review,'' Knight said in an interview yesterday. The BBA will announce changes May 30, she said.

The BBA, an unregulated London-based trade group, sets Libor by polling 16 banks each day on the rates they pay for loans in dollars, British pounds, euros and eight other currencies. The association is under pressure to show the rates are reliable following complaints by investors that financial institutions weren't telling the truth after the collapse of subprime mortgages nine months ago contaminated credit markets and drove up borrowing costs.

While the BBA set the one-month dollar Libor rate at 2.72 percent on April 7, the Federal Reserve said banks paid 2.82 percent for secured loans later that day. Secured loans typically yield less than unsecured debt."The Libor numbers that banks reported to the BBA were a lie," said Tim Bond, head of global asset allocation at Barclays Capital in London. "They had been all the way along."

LIBOR As Of 2008.05.13

Curve watchers anonymous has been watching LIBOR.


The above table from Bloomberg.
Reasonable spreads can be seen in the red box on the right.

A year ago the spread between the Fed Funds Rate and LIBOR 7 basis points, today it is 52 basis points. Bear in mind these are snapshots. LIBOR was acting poorly many times over the past year, especially last August-September and November-December, where the spreads were even greater than they are today.

I checked LIBOR the day after the last Fed rate cut. It was 2.72 so it has been drifting lower in recent weeks. This has been the pattern. The Fed cuts rates and it takes weeks for LIBOR to come in. Historically that is not the case, nor should it be the case.

One Month LIBOR Table



click on chart for sharper image
The above chart thanks to MoneyCafe

Money Cafe reports one Month LIBOR on or after the first of the month for a one month deposit in U.S. Dollars on the last business day of the previous month. Thus the above table reflects a credit crunch in August and November.

At the end of April the spread between LIBOR and the Fed Funds rate was 80 basis points. It is now down to 51 basis points, assuming of course one can believe that is what banks are really charging each other for overnight loans.